Barnett or McKinley?

Verdict said:

Who does Barnett compare to in your mind? You have sort of described Almost Anthony Spencer (Barnett) and Bruce Irvin (McKinley).

Click to expand...

Barnett reminds me of a bigger James Harrison of the Steelers. Both are vicious, ferocious competitors who would eat your heart out if it meant winning. I would take Barnett over ANY edge player in this draft. Malik Hooker, to me, is the best all around player, followed by Mike Williams, WR, Clemson, then Barnett- IMHO. All three are the best & most complete players at their respective positions, create the toughest mismatches, & put greater stress on their opponents than anyone else in the draft.

I think the reports of Barnett being a subpar athlete are overblown. If you watch his clips you'll see him dropping that shoulder and bending that edge low.

It is a "highlight" video, but for the purpose of showing what I'm taking about it's worth watching.

Double Trouble said:

Barnett is a football player. One thing you won't see if you watch his games is QBs or RBs getting away from him once he gets his hands on them.

The biggest drawback with him is he's got an edge, he'll likely get his share of personal fouls.

Click to expand...

That's a plus. This defense needs some nasty.

to even make this a fair poll the question should be barnett at 28 or takk in the 2nd

Barnett will be long gone by the time we pick

CalPolyTechnique said:

I think the reports of Barnett being a subpar athlete are overblown. If you watch his clips you'll see him dropping that shoulder and bending that edge low.

It is a "highlight" video, but for the purpose of showing what I'm taking about it's worth watching.

Click to expand...

The word that comes to mind when watching his game is relentless!

To answer the OP, I like them both but Barnett gets the nod if both are available.

sadams said:

Barnett will be long gone by the time we pick

Click to expand...

I don't know, unless he tests well, I'd say it's possible.

Witten dropped to the third because there were other TEs who had better speed and measurable. Ppl downgraded the boring total player in favor of the tantalizing niche player. As always.

I think he'll be gone by 28, but I could see him going in the 20s.

sadams said:

Barnett will be long gone by the time we pick

Click to expand...

I agree this post should be more about Taco Charlton vs Carl Lawson vs Tak vs Charles Harris we are picking at 28 and all will be projects versus completed talent like Zeke, and Zack Martin. I like Carl Lawson some of you shudder at his injury history. Later in the draft we should still be looking at talent like Jordan Willis or Tanoh Kpassagnon if we sidestep the DE position in round 1 with "BPA".