Did I miss something on that call in the Detroit Game (winner)?

Cmac · Sep 24, 2017

Help explain the Official's call on Golden Tate's game winner, or so I thought.

StarBoyz83 · Sep 24, 2017

Cmac said:
Help explain the Official's call on Golden Tate's game winner, or so I thought.

He was down before the ball broke the pylon.

mattjames2010 · Sep 24, 2017

Clearly down.

perrykemp · Sep 24, 2017

mattjames2010 said:
Clearly down.

Nothing clear about that photo.

CF74 · Sep 24, 2017

His knee touched before the ball broke the plane...

HeavyBarrel · Sep 24, 2017

The knee looks down (partially blocked by helmet) and it appears he's being touched on the right shoulder with the ball clearly short of the GL....would like to see the next frame though

erod · Sep 24, 2017

Doesn't seem right to get a 10-second runoff on a referee's mistake.

They could have probably gotten that ball spiked for another play.

Beast_from_East · Sep 24, 2017

He was down, but I don't get the 10 sec runoff.

TheCoolFan · Sep 24, 2017

It was the right call based on the rules but a tricky situation. In situations like this that are very close, refs should call it a TD so that they can review it. If they did the opposite and it actually was a TD but they called it short and the Lions ran out of time, they would have screwed the Lions on a TD. I believe it was 4th down too so the Lions would not have been able to spike the ball and reset...it would have been a QB sneak-type of play most likely.

Game of inches, that's the risk you run when you throw it short of the endzone in those situations.

Jason 82 Witten · Sep 24, 2017

mattjames2010 said:
Clearly down.

Uh no, not clearly

mattjames2010 · Sep 24, 2017

perrykemp said:
Nothing clear about that photo.

What are you talking about?

Hand on shoulder, shin/knee on the ground. Are you people blind? Haha

mattjames2010 · Sep 24, 2017

Since people have bad eyesight, they have slow motion shot. Got watch at 22 seconds in. He was down.

Sarge · Sep 25, 2017

HeavyBarrel said:
The knee looks down (partially blocked by helmet) and it appears he's being touched on the right shoulder with the ball clearly short of the GL....would like to see the next frame though

If the view is partially blocked by the helmet........it's NOT CLEAR.

Cowboys_22 · Sep 25, 2017

I thought that kind of stuff only happened to the Cowboys

I feel your pain Lion fans

...... sorta

Doomsday · Sep 27, 2017

The 10 second run off seems fair to me. If the refs got it right and marked it down at the 1 yard it would take at least 10 seconds for the refs to place the ball and the Lions to get lined up to run another play.

The offense shouldn't get another down just because the refs messed up, that wouldn't be fair to Atlanta.

Idgit · Sep 27, 2017

I like seeing DET fans get their hearts ripped out over and over. Reminds me of all the whining they did about the Hitchens' face guarding call that was rightly picked up in the playoff game a few years ago.

speedkilz88 · Sep 28, 2017

Doomsday said:
The 10 second run off seems fair to me. If the refs got it right and marked it down at the 1 yard it would take at least 10 seconds for the refs to place the ball and the Lions to get lined up to run another play.

The offense shouldn't get another down just because the refs messed up, that wouldn't be fair to Atlanta.

This is the reasoning, but it is untrue. There are actual game instances where teams got off the next snap within the 8 seconds that the Lions were facing.

First time I've seen a 10 second runoff without an offensive foul. So I assume this is a new rule. It was not thought out. Punishing the offense for an official review is stupid.

Ghost12 · Sep 28, 2017

speedkilz88 said:
This is the reasoning, but it is untrue. There are actual game instances where teams got off the next snap within the 8 seconds that the Lions were facing.

First time I've seen a 10 second runoff without an offensive foul. So I assume this is a new rule. It was not thought out. Punishing the offense for an official review is stupid.

It's not a new rule, it just isn't seen all that frequently. I saw it once before, but the team had a timeout left so they spent the timeout in lieu of the runoff.

Lions got a raw deal here, not that I am losing any sleep over it. I think they could have lined up and run a final play if the original call was right.

Kevinicus · Sep 28, 2017

Surprised nobody has mentioned the shot where there is 11 seconds left on the clock when he was downed (which I don't know how anyone could say it's not clear - leg is clearly hitting the ground to the left of the helmet, being touched, ball short).

EST_1986 · Sep 28, 2017

Kevinicus said:
Surprised nobody has mentioned the shot where there is 11 seconds left on the clock when he was downed (which I don't know how anyone could say it's not clear - leg is clearly hitting the ground to the left of the helmet, being touched, ball short).

Just about to say that. When he was down there was 11seconds left..

Did I miss something on that call in the Detroit Game (winner)?

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Vet Min Plus

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Red, White and Brew...

Well-Known Member

Rising Star

Fattening up

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member