Is There Any Scenario You Envision Welcoming Garrett Back as HC?

817Gill · Mar 6, 2019

SJ and JJ have both made it clear in the media that the team needs to take a step forward in order for Garrett to be back. This might all be conjecture but if we take them at their word, what would JG have to do to be welcomed back by the fans? NFCCG appearance, NFC Title, SB appearance, SB win, or nothing at all?

Does it have to do more with how the team looks or how far they go?

Personally, he would have to win a SB for me to feel like he deserves to be back. What do y’all think?

acr731 · Mar 6, 2019

Beast_from_East · Mar 6, 2019

NFC title game appearance...………..I think that is a fair ask after a decade on the job.

If you cant win a Divisional round game after a decade being a head coach, its time for you to go.

Hardline · Mar 6, 2019

The scenario I see is he's back no matter what.

CT Dal Fan · Mar 6, 2019

Winning a Super Bowl is the only way.

I don't hate Garrett, but it's time for a change if this team again comes up short. I think 2014 and 2016 were JG's best chances but they fell by the wayside for various reasons.

Having said that, the Cowboys were the youngest of the 12 teams to make the playoffs last year, so logic suggests they'll only get better. At least, that's my hope.

CATCH17 · Mar 6, 2019

No.

Even winning a Super Bowl would have little to do with his coaching and more to do with the roster.

He is completely talent dependent and gives us no advantages on game day.

millennial_legend · Mar 6, 2019

CT Dal Fan said:
Winning a Super Bowl is the only way.

I don't hate Garrett, but it's time for a change if this team again comes up short. I think 2014 and 2016 were JG's best chances but they fell by the wayside for various reasons.

Having said that, the Cowboys were the youngest of the 12 teams to make the playoffs last year, so logic suggests they'll only get better. At least, that's my hope.

anything short of an Alshon Jeffery jump ball at the end of the NFC title game & he's toast

ICP · Mar 6, 2019

Undefeated season with a Super Bowl Trophy

Beast_from_East · Mar 6, 2019

Unless Jerry and Steven are just flat out liars, then get over the hump must by definition mean getting the team further than it has before. Currently, the team has never made it past the Divisional round.

Ergo...………….logic would dictate that the team would have to advance past the Divisional round in order to get "over the hump".

Ergo...………….NFC title game appearance at a minimum for Garrett to return if Jerry and Steven were actually telling the truth.

CT Dal Fan · Mar 6, 2019

Beast_from_East said:
NFC title game appearance...………..I think that is a fair ask after a decade on the job.

If you cant win a Divisional round game after a decade being a head coach, its time for you to go.

Depressing fact of the day: since the Cowboys last won the Super Bowl in January 1996, they are one of only three teams (Lions and Commanders are the others) not to reach the NFC Championship Game.

DHCBF66 · Mar 6, 2019

817Gill said:
SJ and JJ have both made it clear in the media that the team needs to take a step forward in order for Garrett to be back. This might all be conjecture but if we take them at their word, what would JG have to do to be welcomed back by the fans? NFCCG appearance, NFC Title, SB appearance, SB win, or nothing at all?

Does it have to do more with how the team looks or how far they go?

Personally, he would have to win a SB for me to feel like he deserves to be back. What do y’all think?

Undefeated season, World Champions.....

Beast_from_East · Mar 6, 2019

CT Dal Fan said:
Depressing fact of the day: since the Cowboys last won the Super Bowl in January 1996, they are one of only three teams (Lions and Commanders are the others) not to reach the NFC Championship Game.

Dam dude, way to depress the hell out of everybody :angry:

CT Dal Fan · Mar 6, 2019

Beast_from_East said:
Dam dude, way to depress the hell out of everybody

Sorry.

Let me atone: the Cowboys have the NFL's highest all time winning percentage and have still participated in more postseason games than any other team despite their recent title drought.

Big_D · Mar 6, 2019

I see no reason at all to keep him here. Times up for Garrett after 2019.

Number1 · Mar 6, 2019

817Gill said:
SJ and JJ have both made it clear in the media that the team needs to take a step forward in order for Garrett to be back. This might all be conjecture but if we take them at their word, what would JG have to do to be welcomed back by the fans? NFCCG appearance, NFC Title, SB appearance, SB win, or nothing at all?

Does it have to do more with how the team looks or how far they go?

Personally, he would have to win a SB for me to feel like he deserves to be back. What do y’all think?

JG ain't the problem - it's the FO

I'll give you a simple example, why risk your season (and super star RB and franchise QB) on a 2nd round OT moved to LG ... when they could have resigned J Cooper?

over time any coach is only as good as his FO

I'll welcome him back and hope he can get JJ sober

coult44 · Mar 6, 2019

Beast_from_East said:
NFC title game appearance...………..I think that is a fair ask after a decade on the job.

If you cant win a Divisional round game after a decade being a head coach, its time for you to go.

So not one conference championship in over a decade would be fine? Not. RJ g better than 15 other teams for one time in his career would be ok, and being second best would be enough to welcome in back? Hahahah, funny

_sturt_ · Mar 6, 2019

Every year is its own thing. Until you know all the obstacles and can assess the outcomes against those, it's premature to make hard-and-fast judgments.

Barring something major, though, that would take out a key ingredient in the recipe for a prolonged time, I think NFC Championship Game is the marker.

xwalker · Mar 6, 2019

817Gill said:
SJ and JJ have both made it clear in the media that the team needs to take a step forward in order for Garrett to be back. This might all be conjecture but if we take them at their word, what would JG have to do to be welcomed back by the fans? NFCCG appearance, NFC Title, SB appearance, SB win, or nothing at all?

Does it have to do more with how the team looks or how far they go?

Personally, he would have to win a SB for me to feel like he deserves to be back. What do y’all think?

We all want to win the next Super Bowl, but they'll definitely keep him if that happens.

Ranching · Mar 6, 2019

I'd welcome him back as our punt returner.

GenoT · Mar 6, 2019

Yeah, the scenario that already exists.

Jerry promoted a 29yo guy who just completed his first season coaching at any level, who was a QB coach (a position where he worked one-on-one with 3 players) to OC, where, in his second-ever season, he’ll now call all the plays while overseeing an entire NFL offense — per the team owner’s orders.

Jerry isn’t gonna fire Kellen Moore anytime soon, and he won’t fire Garrett due to Moore possibly experiencing growing pains.

If/when KM proves he’s worthy to be HC, then he’ll likely succeed JG.

In the meantime, Jerry won’t bring in an outside HC and force him to take KM as his OC, as he already failed with that approach when he forced Wade Phillips to take Garrett, lol!

Is There Any Scenario You Envision Welcoming Garrett Back as HC?

Well-Known Member

Jerry learned to GM from Pee Wee Herman

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

1st Round Pick

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member