Adderley VS Thornhill VS. Rapp VS. CGJ

bayeslife · Apr 26, 2019

Thornhill is a ball hawk with good instincts, Rapp is a thumper that’s more of a fit for a box safety. Would love either

pacboyX · Apr 26, 2019

Rapp ran a 4.78, Church ran a 4.69 coming out...He won’t get faster...NO I do not want Church 2.0. Trade up for Adderly, Thornhill or Gardner and move on to DT.

Carson · Apr 26, 2019

pacboyX said:
Rapp ran a 4.78, Church ran a 4.69 coming out...He won’t get faster...NO I do not want Church 2.0. Trade up for Adderly, Thornhill or Gardner and move on to DT.

That number is a bit skewed because of his groin injury.

When healthy Rapp is a 4.5 guy

bayeslife said:
Thornhill is a ball hawk with good instincts, Rapp is a thumper that’s more of a fit for a box safety. Would love either

Issue with Thornhill is, they view Woods as their FS. Thornhill can play SS, but they likely move him in the slot or eventual cornerback.

pacboyX · Apr 26, 2019

SeanLee50 said:
That number is a bit skewed because of his groin injury.

When healthy Rapp is a 4.5 guy

Issue with Thornhill is, they view Woods as their FS. Thornhill can play SS, but they likely move him in the slot or eventual cornerback.

Rapp does not have a second gear. Solid box safety but in the NFL nowadays you need speed. Speed does not increase as he gets older. The tape does not show that much speed. Will he upgrade Heath..definitely..but I want more. We have gone too long with mediocre safety play.

Rapps stats dont hold a candle to Thornhill. Trade up and get the man!

Carson · Apr 26, 2019

pacboyX said:
Rapp does not have a second gear. Solid box safety but in the NFL nowadays you need speed. Speed does not increase as he gets older. The tape does not show that much speed. Will he upgrade Heath..definitely..but I want more. We have gone too long with mediocre safety play.

Rapps stats dont hold a candle to Thornhill. Trade up and get the man!

All valid points and I agree with you.

But some people may not want to hear it, but the coaches could be sold on our safeties. Woods, Heath, Iloka and Frazier. Outside of Woods is terrible. But just could be their thinking

jnday · Apr 26, 2019

pacboyX said:
Rapp ran a 4.78, Church ran a 4.69 coming out...He won’t get faster...NO I do not want Church 2.0. Trade up for Adderly, Thornhill or Gardner and move on to DT.

Great defenses are built on speed. I agree with you that another Church is not needed. Rapp is young and he is as fast as he will ever be a this point. He is only going to get slower every year from here on out. Why waste a pick knowing this? That lack of speed will hurt the defense for years to come if they draft Rapp.

Whyjerry · Apr 26, 2019

Mr_437 said:
1) Adderly
2) Thornhill
3) CGJ
4) Rapp

Agree. Rapp scares me. If this was 20 years ago he would look much better.

Titleist · Apr 26, 2019

What are the chances all four of them will be taken by 58? I'm wondering if people think we will need to trade up to secure a good S or if one will drop into our lap

Sandyf · Apr 26, 2019

Deionte Thompson or Juan Thornhill for me, in that order.

Idgit · Apr 26, 2019

Titleist said:
What are the chances all four of them will be taken by 58? I'm wondering if people think we will need to trade up to secure a good S or if one will drop into our lap

One of them will be there. Question is whether it’ll be the one we want. If we really like one, move up. If we don’t, roll the dice but be prepared to go another direction if the board breaks wrong. Most important thing is to pick someone who can play in this league.

Future · Apr 26, 2019

I'd take Rapp off the board at 58, but there's really not too much to differentiate between the other 3. I lean Thornhill.

morasp · Apr 26, 2019

The three players I heard they were focused on were Thornhill, Rapp, and Allen. Deciphering comments for Garrett (safety that can play down or deep) and Stephen (interceptions is what they want from a safety) Thornhill would get the nod.

Adderley VS Thornhill VS. Rapp VS. CGJ

bayeslife

187beatdown

pacboyX

Well-Known Member

Carson

Well-Known Member

pacboyX

Well-Known Member

Carson

Well-Known Member

jnday

Well-Known Member

Whyjerry

Well-Known Member

Titleist

Well-Known Member

Sandyf

Well-Known Member

Idgit

Fattening up

Future

Intramural Legend

morasp

Well-Known Member