Change my mind on Wentz vs Dak

CowboyRoy · Sep 16, 2019

Mookie said:
I feel like I'm living in the Twilight Zone, everyone seems to list him as a Top 7 QB. ***?!

Wentz was tough last night. The kid can ball no doubt.

ShiningStar · Sep 16, 2019

CowboyRoy said:
Wentz was tough last night. The kid can ball no doubt.

its more about his health than his skills, yea hes no joke of a QB overall.

CowboyRoy · Sep 16, 2019

ShiningStar said:
its more about his health than his skills, yea hes no joke of a QB overall.

I agree. The way he plays, I dont think he lasts a full year. Too tough and reckless to be smart about things. He gets killed out there.

nalam · Sep 16, 2019

TheHerd said:
2 Super Bowls makes it believable, even though the D was a big part on it

2 Times SB MVP

ShiningStar · Sep 16, 2019

CowboyRoy said:
I agree. The way he plays, I dont think he lasts a full year. Too tough and reckless to be smart about things. He gets killed out there.

i think thats the main consensus, "will he last a year"

sure there is always the chance but its easier to bet the field

CF74 · Sep 16, 2019

Just get a lobotomy

PUSHfold · Sep 17, 2019

Haha I love change my mind...awesome.
Steven Crowder's the man.

Idgit · Sep 17, 2019

PJTHEDOORS said:
No he won't.

I agree. He’ll get consideration because of the two big games and the family name. But he doesn’t deserve it.

mmohican29 · Sep 17, 2019

armadillooutlaw said:
I'd take Dak over Wentz right now, given their body of work over over three seasons.
When both have performed at extremely high levels, it has been with excellent supporting casts. Wentz in 2017 had a better cast than Dak has had up until MAYBE this year.
We'll see long-term. I think both will be really good for years to come, health permitting.
I do believe Wentz has more physical talent, but Dak has the edge as far as actual results.

Arm talent. But Dak is polishing his craft daily, and has off the charts intangibles.

Look, Dak's the superior QB by every measure. While everyone is waiting for the glass slipper to fall off, his play is bubbling into elite level company.

Everyone keeps laughing, but Dak is actually laying the groundwork for a potential HOF career.

ConstantReboot · Sep 17, 2019

Carson Wince folds under pressure. Once the going gets tough he panics. He can't relax like Dak and take matters into his own hands.

Nav22 · Sep 17, 2019

Keithfansince5 said:
EVerything but the bold is true. The bold is nonsense. Wentz is as likeable a guy as I have seen in the NFL. I like him a lot just can't stand who he plays for. He is a good guy.

Several of his teammates disagree with you.

https://www.phillyvoice.com/carson-...agles-quarterback-as-selfish-not-team-player/

“Sources describing him as “selfish,” “uncompromising,” “egotistical,” one who plays “favorites” and doesn’t like to be “questioned,” one who needs to “practice what he preaches" and fails “to take accountability.”

Numerous sources confirmed Wentz was once verbally attacked by a highly respected teammate for not being “a team guy.”

QuikZ06 · Sep 17, 2019

Nav22 said:
Several of his teammates disagree with you.

https://www.phillyvoice.com/carson-...agles-quarterback-as-selfish-not-team-player/

“Sources describing him as “selfish,” “uncompromising,” “egotistical,” one who plays “favorites” and doesn’t like to be “questioned,” one who needs to “practice what he preaches" and fails “to take accountability.”

Numerous sources confirmed Wentz was once verbally attacked by a highly respected teammate for not being “a team guy.”

What’s funny is I was thinking this on Sunday, his teammates have to hate his attitude. He made a few bad throws and looked like he was getting pissed at receivers. Seems like a guy that doesn’t want to take the blame. I much prefer Daks demeanor at this stage in their careers.

GhostOfPelluer · Sep 17, 2019

Wentz has the stronger arm, but Dak’s decision-making ability makes Carson look like Homer Simpson in a donut shop

NeathBlue · Sep 17, 2019

Eli will definitely get in to the HoF... 2 titles, a big market team and the Manning name will make sure of that, he’ll probably even be first ballot which makes it even worse.
As for Wentz, I think he’s got the talent but he doesn’t have the chemistry with his team that Foles had.
If he can shake the injury bug then things might improve, but if he misses games again this season then the murmurs get louder that they should have traded him and kept Foles... and that’ll just make it harder for him.

Daktozekecoop · Sep 17, 2019

PJTHEDOORS said:
Eli won't be in HOF.

I hope you are right. I don't think Eli is overrated. I rarely hear anyone claim that he is any good. He most definitely does not deserve to be in the hall of fame.

Daktozekecoop · Sep 17, 2019

As for the OP question. Dak all day long.

AmericanCowboy · Sep 17, 2019

Howboutdemcowboys31 said:
As overrated as he is

Eli is the most overrated QB in history. Will be the worst player ever inducted into the HOF

Yup. Not even close. Eli Manning is a below 500 QB for his career and has never done anything spectacular except ride the coattails of two all time great playoff defenses

Oh_Canada · Sep 17, 2019

Wentz is a good qb, but he isn’t going to last in the NFL.
Dak is a boss.

TheHerd · Sep 17, 2019

PJTHEDOORS said:
So. Foles has one, is he a fringe HOF?

Nope. 2 is different. And you don't have to convince me. I'm not voting. I'm with you on this, but tht media votes,plus Eli plays in NY.

Rockport · Sep 17, 2019

Fontaine said:
Eagle’s always get overhyped, never understood it to be honest.

As Colin Cowherd put it, he spends so much time in the tent I thought he was camping

It’s the Eastern US media. They hype everything in that area.

Change my mind on Wentz vs Dak

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

The realist

Well-Known Member

Vet Min Plus

Well-Known Member

Fattening up

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

AmberBeer