Poll: Rank Staubach's, Aikman's & Romo's Pro Bowler Teammates Collective Talent

NumOneQB said:

Romo by a long shot. Make all the excuses you want, he failed miserably in the post season.


I would then put 2.Eightball 3.Staubizzy

Click to expand...

DFWJC said:

Polar opposite.

Romo may have had one decent all-around team, in 2007. But even that team didn't hold up to several of those in the 90s and 70s.
And that team lost to th eventual Super Bowl champs after he did throw the perfect game-winning pass to Crayton with 17 second left, only to see it drop harmlessly in the endzone due to a stopped route.

Anyway, Very few of those 2007 "Pro Bowlers" were legit. Maybe half at best. The game had lost its meaning by then and voting was midseason back then

I would argue that this year's team--from top to bottom--has more talent (especially youthful talent that shouldn't wear down) than the 2007 team.

Click to expand...

Bullflop said:

Looks like he might be hypnotized!!!

Click to expand...

Big_D said:

People put way too much stock in a garbage game and an individual accomplishment. Pro bowl berths don't win championships. Neither does coach of the year or executive of the year. It's crap. Nice for the player, but somehow pro bowls have become more important than playoff wins? LOL It's pretty easy to rank these teams. And the 2007 club wasn't close to either one.

Click to expand...

NeathBlue said:

Did the 07 pro bowl have fans votes counting towards being picked?
If so it would explain why a couple of them made it.
You’re splitting hairs trying to pick either 78 or 93 over the other, they were both exceptional squads.
Should have Charles Hayley on the 93 list as well.

Click to expand...

Shane612 said:

Staubach had some legendary teammates, but Aikman, Smith and Irvin could have won 2 more Championships, if Jimmy didn't leave.

Click to expand...

NumOneQB said:

Sounds like a long list of excuses to me. Eras were different so there is some difficulty comparing players to players. Romo had the most talent around him and did nothing with it. In hindsight, he did have Garrett-top around him in some form as OC or HC through most of his career. We all k wow how mediocre JG has been. I’ll give him that much at least....

Click to expand...

Super_Kazuya said:

Seriously... simply replace the words “Pro Bowler” with “Hall of Famer” and suddenly this question becomes fairly easy to answer.

Click to expand...

DallasEast said:

List of Pro Bowlers

1978 Roger Staubach: Randy White, Cliff Harris, Charlie Waters, Billy Joe DuPree, Tony Dorsett, Tony Hill, Thomas Henderson & Harvey Martin

1993 Troy Aikman: Emmitt Smith, Erik Williams, Mark Stepnoski, Nate Newton, Michael Irvin, Ken Norton, Thomas Everett, Daryl Johnston, Russell Maryland & Jay Novacek

2007 Tony Romo: DeMarcus Ware, Jason Witten, Terrell Owens, Andre Gurode, Flozell Adams, Leonard Davis, Marion Barber, Greg Ellis, Nick Folk, Ken Hamlin, Terence Newman & Roy Williams

Note: Poll option allows for changing of your vote at a later time.

Click to expand...

Gator88 said:

I have to seriously question the knowledge of anybody that puts 2007 in the same ballpark as the other 2, let alone ahead of them.

Click to expand...

Maxmadden said:

Roger and Troy had the benefit of a Superbowl caliber defense.

Click to expand...