Where did Troy say he was wrong? He said Dak is a different guy this year: better footwork; better timing (always had the intangibles).
You want Troy to say he was wrong because that would mean you weren’t. It’s not ok to put words in his mouth to get you there.
Troy was wrong and he always will be if his take doesn't change on QB criterion.
Accuracy is not the primary factor in QB success, talent or rating.
It is is knowing where to go with the football.
Troy was terrible as a rookie and it wasn't because he was inaccurate, it was because he didn't know where to go with the ball.
Tom Brady is not that accurate. His accuracy ratings are actually surprisingly low. But he ALWAYS knows where to go with the ball. P Manning? Same thing.
Processing information and preparedness are key.
Put those behind only clutch/pressure performance, availability and leadership.
Accuracy might be about the 4th most key trait for a successful QB.
Professional WRs have large catch radius. If you get the guy open the ball he can adjust and catch it.
If you throw it into double coverage or to a guy with stone hands, it doesn't likely matter where you place it.
Most QBs go through periods in games where they aren't in sync and throw some bad incompletions. The team punts and they live to figjht another series.
That's not bad but common.