Anonymous Eagles player calls out Carson Wentz

C42 said:

Lmao if he’s outplayed him he’d be ranked ahead of him. Nobody is ranking Mitch Trubisky over Mahomes cause of draft position. Nobody was saying RGIII was better than Wilson after the first year either. It’s a what have you done lately league.

Click to expand...

Nav22 said:

Don’t be dense.

Dak and Wentz’s resumes are “close enough” to where the tie-breaker will, of course, be the fact that Wentz was a #2 overall pick and Dak was a 4th rounder.

Comparing that to Trubisky-Mahomes is absurd and you know it.

It’s only a matter of time before Wentz’s draft status will stop mattering.

Enjoy this while you can. Dak’s been better - math isn’t lying to you.

Oh, and enjoy your L tonight. Dak’s good at beating Philly.

Click to expand...

C42 said:

So all the GMs and execs and players who choose Wentz over Dak, it’s cause in the back of their minds they remember he’s the #2 overall pick?

Lol, okay

Click to expand...

Nav22 said:

Facts are fun. You should learn about them.

I’d love to see which metric YOU use to help you rate QBs, since QBR and Passer Rating are clearly beneath your infinite wisdom.

“Team stuff” doesn’t count either, right?

So how are you rating Dak as an average QB? Is it JUST your “eye test”?????

Click to expand...

Nav22 said:

Yes, of course. What else would it be?

Dak’s stats are better.

Dak’s record is better.

Dak’s a better leader.

Dak’s more clutch.

Dak’s more durable.

None of those are even remotely debatable.

You think GMs who’d still take Wentz despite Wentz being inferior in ALL of these areas aren’t taking his #2 overall pick status into account?

What’s it like needing to lie to yourself like that? It must truly suck.


In any event, Dak will go down as the better QB when it’s all said and done. He’s well on his way and those “poll results” will reflect that soon enough.

“Performance is everything. Potential is nothing.”

-Bill Parcells

Click to expand...

CalPolyTechnique said:

Last three games:

Eagles 2-1
Wentz 6 TD/1 INT
QBR (last 3 games): 84.9, 52.3, 78.1

Cowboys 0-3
Dak 2 TD/4 INTs
QBR: (last 3 games): 75.4, 36.8, 73.3

Click to expand...

C42 said:

Like I said, stats don’t tell the entire story. These GMs, execs, and players know that.

How has Dak done against good/average teams this year?

Click to expand...

Nav22 said:

Fair enough. There’s a metric that has Wentz ahead of Dak for this year.

“Last 3 games”? There’s nothing drastically different about the Eagles in Weeks 1-3 than Weeks 4-6. If you’re going to cherry-pick, there ought to be a good reason for it.

Dak’s QBR is still #1 in the NFL. Wentz is #5.

Dak’s Passer Rating is #6. Wentz is #19.

Click to expand...

Nav22 said:

I didn’t JUST point to stats. Dak has many other attributes that are superior to Wentz.

There’s no “stat” for leadership, but being trashed anonymously 3 times in the last year by your teammates kind of says it all, doesn’t it?

You wish you could dispute something from the list I provided, but you can’t.

Dak is 3-3 this year, just like Wentz. We’ll see what happens tonight.

Click to expand...

CalPolyTechnique said:

Dak’s stellar QBR has the Cowboys 0-3 the last three games, or are we not attributing W/L to Dak’s record when it’s not convenient?

Click to expand...

C42 said:

You didn’t answer my question. How’s he been against good/average teams?

Click to expand...

Nav22 said:

Not good enough.

Still better than Wentz this year and over the course of their careers.

Click to expand...