The worst coaching decision yesterday

SHAMSzy · Nov 11, 2019

Kicking a 57 yard FG on the opening drive instead of pinning them deep or even going for it

Kicking that FG was the worst available option & set us back from the jump. I still can’t believe an NFL coach would opt to kick a 57 yard FG on the opening drive .... even if you make it 3 points is negligible at that point in the game, but the field position is invaluable

That poor decision by Garrett set us back from the jump & one of the worst coaching decisions I’ve seen in my life

phildadon86 · Nov 11, 2019

SHAMSzy said:
Kicking a 57 yard FG on the opening drive instead of pinning them deep or even going for it

Kicking that FG was the worst available option & set us back from the jump. I still can’t believe an NFL coach would opt to kick a 57 yard FG on the opening drive .... even if you make it 3 points is negligible at that point in the game, but the field position is invaluable

That poor decision by Garrett set us back from the jump & one of the worst coaching decisions I’ve seen in my life

Fair catch trumps that one

WillieBeamen · Nov 11, 2019

Na chief

It was stupid as hell but the team had 55 minutes to make up for it.

The fair catch fiasco was 1000x worse. You have him fair catch just to set up a pathetic Hail Mary? :facepalm:

Carson · Nov 11, 2019

WillieBeamen said:
Na chief

It was stupid as hell but the team had 55 minutes to make up for it.

The fair catch fiasco was 1000x worse. You have him fair catch just to set up a pathetic Hail Mary?

EXACTLY!!!

Austin has about 177 punt returns in his career. I give him the option, if you think something is there and can take the least amount of time, you go. If there is nothing, fair catch and conserve time.

We get the ball on the 25-30 there at worst

big dog cowboy · Nov 11, 2019

SHAMSzy said:
Kicking a 57 yard FG on the opening drive instead of pinning them deep or even going for it

phildadon86 said:
Fair catch trumps that one

They both sucked.

SMH moments.

ghst187 · Nov 11, 2019

I’m not sure it mattered on that first drive, whether it was 55 yards or 99 I think Minnesota was gonna score a TD because we were so unprepared for anything they were doing offensively

basstapp · Nov 11, 2019

Austin could have scored on that play. If anything you waste 7 seconds more, but are 20 yards closer.

Manster_Mash · Nov 11, 2019

There is a lot of competition for that honor. Garrett is an over-achiever.

unionjack8 · Nov 11, 2019

Too many of these threads every week detailing decisions just like these.

I swear we have had ten years of this. How is it accepted?

glimmerman · Nov 11, 2019

WillieBeamen said:
Na chief

It was stupid as hell but the team had 55 minutes to make up for it.

The fair catch fiasco was 1000x worse. You have him fair catch just to set up a pathetic Hail Mary?

Austin would have taken that to the house.

Cmac · Nov 11, 2019

Now that's on JG for sure.....trusting Maher is a mistake anyway....instant field position.....Zimmer & his boys were laughing all game looking across the field.

Big_D · Nov 11, 2019

WillieBeamen said:
Na chief

It was stupid as hell but the team had 55 minutes to make up for it.

The fair catch fiasco was 1000x worse. You have him fair catch just to set up a pathetic Hail Mary?

That fair catch?? lol 1 play that could properly sum up the Garrett era. How moronic of a call was that? Sacrificing a few seconds for another 15/20 yards. Just ridiculous. That’s the type of poor decisions we’ve been seeing for a decade so it wasn’t that surprising after you got over the initial shock.

Fletch · Nov 11, 2019

SHAMSzy said:
Kicking a 57 yard FG on the opening drive instead of pinning them deep or even going for it

Kicking that FG was the worst available option & set us back from the jump. I still can’t believe an NFL coach would opt to kick a 57 yard FG on the opening drive .... even if you make it 3 points is negligible at that point in the game, but the field position is invaluable

That poor decision by Garrett set us back from the jump & one of the worst coaching decisions I’ve seen in my life

Wholeheartedly agree. That’s a decision you ONLY make leading up to the half, or when you need points late in the 4th. Maher is not Vinieterri in his early prime. Just a horrible call!!!

Never put your team in that kind of position after the first series.

CyberB0b · Nov 11, 2019

I was fine with the FG. Maher is usually good beyond 50.

gimmesix · Nov 11, 2019

SHAMSzy said:
Kicking a 57 yard FG on the opening drive instead of pinning them deep or even going for it

Kicking that FG was the worst available option & set us back from the jump. I still can’t believe an NFL coach would opt to kick a 57 yard FG on the opening drive .... even if you make it 3 points is negligible at that point in the game, but the field position is invaluable

That poor decision by Garrett set us back from the jump & one of the worst coaching decisions I’ve seen in my life

The Cowboys seem to be in love with the idea of Maher ... that he can kick 60-yard field goals ... and not understand the reality that he's a 70 percent kicker. You don't let a kicker who makes only 3 out of every 4 attempts at best attempt that kick at that point in time. End of the half? Sure. Game on the line? Sure. First drive in a game you know is likely going to be tough for the defense? Absolutely not.

McKDaddy · Nov 11, 2019

On a similar but different note, why do we even have return teams? We never try to return a KO. (Great use of Pollard btw)

We rarely get much on punt returns. Top that off by fair catching a do or die situation. Seriously, we are ahead of the curve of removing returns from the game. NFL just points to us & says,"see, no injuries."

Big_D · Nov 11, 2019

gimmesix said:
The Cowboys seem to be in love with the idea of Maher ... that he can kick 60-yard field goals ... and not understand the reality that he's a 70 percent kicker. You don't let a kicker who makes only 3 out of every 4 attempts at best attempt that kick at that point in time. End of the half? Sure. Game on the line? Sure. First drive in a game you know is likely going to be tough for the defense? Absolutely not.

Just a moronic decision. You got to play field position early. Handing them the ball at midfield, there's no defending the call. It was ridiculous.

boysfanperiod · Nov 11, 2019

SHAMSzy said:
Kicking a 57 yard FG on the opening drive instead of pinning them deep or even going for it

Kicking that FG was the worst available option & set us back from the jump. I still can’t believe an NFL coach would opt to kick a 57 yard FG on the opening drive .... even if you make it 3 points is negligible at that point in the game, but the field position is invaluable

That poor decision by Garrett set us back from the jump & one of the worst coaching decisions I’ve seen in my life

That's the second time we've done that and lost.

John813 · Nov 11, 2019

Our kicker has been "reliable" from 50+ out recently.

They were on the left hash too.

This seems like more of a hindsight complaint.

Hawkeye19 · Nov 11, 2019

WillieBeamen said:
Na chief

It was stupid as hell but the team had 55 minutes to make up for it.

The fair catch fiasco was 1000x worse. You have him fair catch just to set up a pathetic Hail Mary?

Word. Couldn't believe that doozy of a fair catch when he had all that green in front of him. Wow. Just wow.

The worst coaching decision yesterday

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

BoysfanfromNY

Well-Known Member

THE BIG DOG

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

To The Moon

Village Idiot

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member