Fans are already calling McCarthy and his analytics a fraud

Reality · Jan 12, 2020

texbumthelife said:
This board was pretty split on McCarthy day one.

https://cowboyszone.com/threads/do-...mccarthy-as-head-coach-of-the-cowboys.450664/

75% would disagree with you.

InTheZone · Jan 12, 2020

Verdict said:
This board was about 95 percent get rid of Garrett at all costs, anyone but Garrett. The other 5 percent mostly was ok with getting rid of Garrett but they were concerned that Jerry would hire another Campo.

Jerry hires an established coach in McCarthy who has had sustained success in the NFL. Even the haters are saying it was a good hire for the Cowboys.

Now it seems as though 35 percent of this board is calling McCarthy a fraud, his analytics are BS. He’s going to fail, etc.

He hasn’t even moved all of his notebooks in the building, made any moves, or done any coaching yet and he is already labeled a bust. Lol. Man, I swear some of you are BIPOLAR.

I've noticed it too, but I don't think it's anywhere close to 35% percent - probably somewhere along 5% but they're just vocal about it.

Whirlwin · Jan 12, 2020

Reality said:
https://cowboyszone.com/threads/do-...mccarthy-as-head-coach-of-the-cowboys.450664/

75% would disagree with you.

I actually was the 25%. I figured if you couldn’t win with the great Aaron Rodgers. But at least I’m smart enough to know let it play out. Before I can judge because every situation is new

texbumthelife · Jan 12, 2020

Reality said:
https://cowboyszone.com/threads/do-...mccarthy-as-head-coach-of-the-cowboys.450664/

75% would disagree with you.

Touche, never saw that. Just voted. Regardless, my point was that no one is suddenly out of favor with MM. The same people who didn't like it day one don't like it now.

Reality · Jan 12, 2020

Whirlwin said:
I actually was the 25%. I figured if you couldn’t win with the great Aaron Rodgers. But at least I’m smart enough to know let it play out. Before I can judge because every situation is new

Nothing at all wrong with being part of the 25% not for the hire.

My comment was a response to the board being split though.

waldoputty · Jan 12, 2020

Verdict said:
This board was about 95 percent get rid of Garrett at all costs, anyone but Garrett. The other 5 percent mostly was ok with getting rid of Garrett but they were concerned that Jerry would hire another Campo.

Jerry hires an established coach in McCarthy who has had sustained success in the NFL. Even the haters are saying it was a good hire for the Cowboys.

Now it seems as though 35 percent of this board is calling McCarthy a fraud, his analytics are BS. He’s going to fail, etc.

He hasn’t even moved all of his notebooks in the building, made any moves, or done any coaching yet and he is already labeled a bust. Lol. Man, I swear some of you are BIPOLAR.

the op of that analytics fraud thread defended garrett in my garrett is dead celebration thread.

Whirlwin · Jan 12, 2020

texbumthelife said:
Touche, never saw that. Just voted. Regardless, my point was that no one is suddenly out of favor with MM. The same people who didn't like it day one don't like it now.

I definitely didn’t like it on the one. But I am an individual. And I’m willing to change he just has to prove it. Time will tell my cowboy brother

CATCH17 · Jan 12, 2020

Verdict said:
This board was about 95 percent get rid of Garrett at all costs, anyone but Garrett. The other 5 percent mostly was ok with getting rid of Garrett but they were concerned that Jerry would hire another Campo.

Jerry hires an established coach in McCarthy who has had sustained success in the NFL. Even the haters are saying it was a good hire for the Cowboys.

Now it seems as though 35 percent of this board is calling McCarthy a fraud, his analytics are BS. He’s going to fail, etc.

He hasn’t even moved all of his notebooks in the building, made any moves, or done any coaching yet and he is already labeled a bust. Lol. Man, I swear some of you are BIPOLAR.

He’ll at worst be mediocre because of the foundation this team has built.

But I do think a lot of his analytics and stuff like that was just fluff that his agent told him to say so he could rebrand himself from being the stubborn coach who ran bland offenses.

I’m sure we’ll hear the same things about Garrett in the near future as well.

This is a blah hire unless you’re a Cowboy fan because we’re the only fans Pom pom’ing this hire.

I hope it works though. Jerry let him hire his guys. Get it done.

Jake · Jan 12, 2020

Mike McCarthy is the only undefeated head coach in Dallas Cowboys history. :thumbup:

Brooksey · Jan 12, 2020

We're a tough crowd..he's gonna have to earn it. I'll give the guy the benefit of the doubt. so far so good

Whirlwin · Jan 12, 2020

CATCH17 said:
He’ll at worst be mediocre because of the foundation this team has built.

But I do think a lot of his analytics and stuff like that was just fluff that his agent told him to say so he could rebrand himself from being the stubborn coach who ran bland offenses.

8/8, people are just learning and I’ve been saying it for a while. It’s actually a big accomplishment. And today’s NFL. Teams go to the playoffs one or two seasons and then they’re not heard it from again for six or seven. Could be average as long as we have been was actually a huge accomplishment. As much as it was negative because of drafting position. If we had failed once in a while we might’ve been better like a really better

Whirlwin · Jan 12, 2020

brooksey1 said:
We're a tough crowd..he's gonna have to earn it. I'll give the guy the benefit of the doubt. so far so good

That’s my thought also. He’s going to have to prove it. I’m not gonna slam him yet LOLIf we could improve special teams alone where we start the ball would be huge

ScipioCowboy · Jan 12, 2020

That thread was crazy. It’s the fastest I’ve ever seen a coach personally attacked by a fan. I mean, he hasn’t even had time to assemble a staff and meet with players.

CATCH17 · Jan 12, 2020

Whirlwin said:
8/8, people are just learning and I’ve been saying it for a while. It’s actually a big accomplishment. And today’s NFL. Teams go to the playoffs one or two seasons and then they’re not heard it from again for six or seven. Could be average as long as we have been was actually a huge accomplishment. As much as it was negative because of drafting position. If we had failed once in a while we might’ve been better like a really better

I agree.

Complete failure is better then continuous mediocrity. Especially when you skip Free Agency,

ShortRound · Jan 12, 2020

It’s been 7 days, I don’t understand the complaining

Whirlwin · Jan 12, 2020

CATCH17 said:
He’ll at worst be mediocre because of the foundation this team has built.

But I do think a lot of his analytics and stuff like that was just fluff that his agent told him to say so he could rebrand himself from being the stubborn coach who ran bland offenses.

I’m sure we’ll hear the same things about Garrett in the near future as well.

This is a blah hire unless you’re a Cowboy fan because we’re the only fans Pom pom’ing this hire.

I hope it works though. Jerry let him hire his guys. Get it done.

Thanks for understanding the gobble LOL google really messed that up

jchap · Jan 12, 2020

An analytical genius? McCarthy can't even add up calories! /sarcasm

LatinMind · Jan 12, 2020

CATCH17 said:
He’ll at worst be mediocre because of the foundation this team has built.

But I do think a lot of his analytics and stuff like that was just fluff that his agent told him to say so he could rebrand himself from being the stubborn coach who ran bland offenses.

I’m sure we’ll hear the same things about Garrett in the near future as well.

This is a blah hire unless you’re a Cowboy fan because we’re the only fans Pom pom’ing this hire.

I hope it works though. Jerry let him hire his guys. Get it done.

I wouldnt care, all this analytic crap is just that. If you have a smart coach who can call a good play then you will be alright. Use analytics as a tool not the rule. The human element should never be taken out.

black label · Jan 12, 2020

Verdict said:
This board was about 95 percent get rid of Garrett at all costs, anyone but Garrett. The other 5 percent mostly was ok with getting rid of Garrett but they were concerned that Jerry would hire another Campo.

Jerry hires an established coach in McCarthy who has had sustained success in the NFL. Even the haters are saying it was a good hire for the Cowboys.

Now it seems as though 35 percent of this board is calling McCarthy a fraud, his analytics are BS. He’s going to fail, etc.

He hasn’t even moved all of his notebooks in the building, made any moves, or done any coaching yet and he is already labeled a bust. Lol. Man, I swear some of you are BIPOLAR.

SSoup · Jan 12, 2020

When the guy openly admits to lying in his interview to get the job, you can't credibly pitch a fit about fans discussing the extent to which he lied to get the job. Be serious.

Fans are already calling McCarthy and his analytics a fraud

Reality

InTheZone

Well-Known Member

Whirlwin

Cowboy , It’s a way of life.

texbumthelife

Well-Known Member

Reality

waldoputty

Well-Known Member

Whirlwin

Cowboy , It’s a way of life.

CATCH17

1st Round Pick

Jake

Beyond tired of Jerry

Brooksey

Well-Known Member

Whirlwin

Cowboy , It’s a way of life.

Whirlwin

Cowboy , It’s a way of life.

ScipioCowboy

More than meets the eye.

CATCH17

1st Round Pick

ShortRound

Well-Known Member

Whirlwin

Cowboy , It’s a way of life.

jchap

Well-Known Member

LatinMind

iPhotoshop

black label

Well-Known Member

SSoup

Well-Known Member