Green Bay SB win will make the McCarthy's resume slightly irrelevant

basilhayden · Jan 13, 2020

BotchedLobotomy said:
The amount of criticism McCarthy is getting from posters on here before he coaches a single hour for the Cowboys is astounding.

There is one of two things going on with these people.
#1 - The had themselves thoroughly convinced that JJ was going to hire some high profile headline grabbing splashy coach that was going to come in here and turn the NFL on its side. They didn't get that with MM so they hate him for no other reason other than they were wrong.
or
#2 - They thrive on posting negative threads

#3 They actually liked Garrett

gimmesix · Jan 13, 2020

superonyx said:
Anyone who watches the packers and pretends their success is somehow a negative indictment of Mike McCarthy is an idiot.

the Packers have the NFLs 18th ranked offense. The difference in GB is defense and that came from their new GM finally spending money on quality free agents.

Even if that were not the case, it would not make McCarthy getting a Super Bowl victory irrelevant.

Some of us act as if that's an easy accomplishment when there have only been 53 Super Bowl winners. Adjusting for repeats, that's 32 coaches since 1967 who have a Super Bowl victory.

gimmesix · Jan 13, 2020

John813 said:
Almost like saying Barry Switzer made Jimmy Johnson irrelevant after he won a SB two years later.

I

The Packers finally decided to spend money to help their defense. Ole Ted got sent to the pasture and they got a GM who didn't think FA was for the devil

I almost used that example, but decided not to since Johnson had won three Super Bowls before Switzer essentially took over a loaded team.

I think it's fair to doubt that McCarthy can repeat his GB success here for a variety of reasons. I don't think it's fair to diminish his Super Bowl victory.

Diehardblues · Jan 13, 2020

This is Rodgers 5th Championship appearance.

I’d say this speaks more about how the Packers are probably more about #12 than anything else.

CouchCoach · Jan 13, 2020

Diehardblues said:
This is Rodgers 5th Championship appearance.

I’d say this speaks more about how the Packers are probably more about #12 than anything else.

This year, it's all about Smith's and Jones. Adding those bookends on the DL is why they're in the NFCCG, Rodgers hasn't had his typical year.

Under Big Mike, he was a better stat QB but the team was not as good. I don't know who was responsible for those two DE's but that was the FA move of the year along with TEN picking up Tannehill.

blueblood70 · Jan 13, 2020

gimmesix said:
I almost used that example, but decided not to since Johnson had won three Super Bowls before Switzer essentially took over a loaded team.

I think it's fair to doubt that McCarthy can repeat his GB success here for a variety of reasons. I don't think it's fair to diminish his Super Bowl victory.

jimmy won 2 not 3 switzer went to the NFCCG where his players got down 21-0 early and clawed their way into the game e but lost and the following year won a SB..you dont get credit for a sb win if you are no longer the coach or player..

but I agree on the rest you cant take away a sb for some ridiculous reasoning as this thread was started.. many SB wining coaches had great players or great QB..

MM is a SB winning coach, hes been to what 4 NFCCGs, those dont come easy ex see the DC since 1995 lol

Jstopper · Jan 13, 2020

ChronicCowboy said:
McCarthy is such a dud. Who hires the guy that couldn’t win with that Green Bay team?

This greenbay team looks NOTHING like the team he coached roster wise. There are only 2 defensive starters left on that team from McCarthy last year. They went crazy in FA with their new GM this offseason. Nice reach though

foofighters · Jan 13, 2020

Dak_Attack_09 said:
Green Bay SB win will make the McCarthy's resume slightly irrelevant. He has to go minimum 11-5 NFC East champs and playoff run to the NFC championship game, otherwise he should be replaced by Kellen Moore the following season. Jerry has plenty of money to bite the bullet.

Maybe to you and 3 other guys. I doubt anyone else will care. They aren't even in the SB yet either.

zrinkill · Jan 13, 2020

What a stupid thread

garyo1954 · Jan 13, 2020

Dak_Attack_09 said:
Green Bay SB win will make the McCarthy's resume slightly irrelevant. He has to go minimum 11-5 NFC East champs and playoff run to the NFC championship game, otherwise he should be replaced by Kellen Moore the following season. Jerry has plenty of money to bite the bullet.

gimmesix · Jan 13, 2020

blueblood70 said:
jimmy won 2 not 3 switzer went to the NFCCG where his players got down 21-0 early and clawed their way into the game e but lost and the following year won a SB..you dont get credit for a sb win if you are no longer the coach or player..

but I agree on the rest you cant take away a sb for some ridiculous reasoning as this thread was started.. many SB wining coaches had great players or great QB..

MM is a SB winning coach, hes been to what 4 NFCCGs, those dont come easy ex see the DC since 1995 lol

Apparently, my brain glitzed on me on the number of Super Bowl victories. Yes, two for Johnson.

gimmesix · Jan 13, 2020

Jstopper said:
This greenbay team looks NOTHING like the team he coached roster wise. There are only 2 defensive starters left on that team from McCarthy last year. They went crazy in FA with their new GM this offseason. Nice reach though

The only concern for me in this regard is I don't trust this front office to build that kind of defense for McCarthy. I think offensively we take a step forward. Defensively, I just don't know ... it could continue to hold us back.

If I remember correctly, the year GB won the Super Bowl under McCarthy, the Packers had a fairly opportunistic defense. Maybe that's what he is trying to recreate with Nolan.

Loso86 · Jan 13, 2020

Dak_Attack_09 said:
Green Bay SB win will make the McCarthy's resume slightly irrelevant. He has to go minimum 11-5 NFC East champs and playoff run to the NFC championship game, otherwise he should be replaced by Kellen Moore the following season. Jerry has plenty of money to bite the bullet.

Why...could theybjust not have another good coach still great qb and hood team?

Praxit · Jan 13, 2020

.....Rodgers is going to need more than State insurance Vs niners.

>>.

Oneiros · Jan 13, 2020

calicowboy54 · Jan 13, 2020

Dak_Attack_09 said:
Green Bay SB win will make the McCarthy's resume slightly irrelevant. He has to go minimum 11-5 NFC East champs and playoff run to the NFC championship game, otherwise he should be replaced by Kellen Moore the following season. Jerry has plenty of money to bite the bullet.

I argue this point, that team is still heavily employed by players that he Coached or brought in... yes there Offense is doing different things but that defense and offense still have his players he drafted or signed on it.

ultron · Jan 13, 2020

Green Bay is getting blown out again by the 49ers, bet the farm.

garyo1954 · Jan 13, 2020

Praxit said:
.....Rodgers is going to need more than State insurance Vs niners. >>.

Yeah, and the Titans couldn't beat Baltimore is they spotted them 22 points! I heard ya!

CanadianCowboysFan · Jan 13, 2020

Dak_Attack_09 said:
Green Bay SB win will make the McCarthy's resume slightly irrelevant. He has to go minimum 11-5 NFC East champs and playoff run to the NFC championship game, otherwise he should be replaced by Kellen Moore the following season. Jerry has plenty of money to bite the bullet.

does it wipe out his past division wins and SB win too?

Dak_Attack_09 · Jan 13, 2020

CanadianCowboysFan said:
does it wipe out his past division wins and SB win too?

Pretty much if a 1st year head coach wins a SB with Aaron Rodgers. He did tell McCarthy to lose some weight though. :muttley:

Green Bay SB win will make the McCarthy's resume slightly irrelevant

basilhayden

Well-Known Member

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member

CouchCoach

blueblood70

Well-Known Member

Jstopper

Well-Known Member

foofighters

Well-Known Member

zrinkill

Cowboy Fan

garyo1954

Well-Known Member

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life

Loso86

Well-Known Member

Praxit

Well-Known Member

Oneiros

Well-Known Member

calicowboy54

Well-Known Member

ultron

Well-Known Member

garyo1954

Well-Known Member

CanadianCowboysFan

Lightning Rod

Dak_Attack_09

Well-Known Member