Video: Dak Prescott should hold out if franchise tagged

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
66,949
Reaction score
84,344
Amazing how Dak gets blamed entirely for losses but is only a bus driver for wins.......nevermind he's played for a coach and OC almost fans thinks should've been replaced years ago. Our fans:banghead:

Yes.. WE need him to step up in big games.. If he can't we need to be able to sign players who can and not be restricted by a contract that doesn't allow that.

He's closer to Tannehill then he is Mahomes..
 

Hawkeye0202

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,228
Reaction score
42,793
Yes.. WE need him to step up in big games.. If he can't we need to be able to sign players who can and not be restricted by a contract that doesn't allow that.

He's closer to Tannehill then he is Mahomes..

But Catch....you say he's 0-5 against top rank defenses. C'mon.....can't believe you're not taking our poor defense AND coaching into consideration.
 

HungryLion

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,557
Reaction score
60,459
Bingo. If Dak and his agent want things to get ugly. The Cowboys can make them quite ugly.

There are more quarterback options than ever before available in 2020. If Dak listens to a draft bust like Marcus Spears for career advice? He can lose his seat at the table in Dallas. Go and try to find your fame, fortune, and success somewhere else. He will never have it as good as he does with the Cowboys.

I have to question the last sentence.

Money wise, yes he will
Never has it as good as he does with dallas. In regards to endorsements, etc

but better overall? Idk Stash. There’s other franchises out there that are better at running their organizations to actually win football games.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,366
Reaction score
102,293
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I have to question the last sentence.

Money wise, yes he will

That might be the only area, and even that's not a guarantee. Where's he going? What's he getting paid? How long is he getting paid?

Never has it as good as he does with dallas. In regards to endorsements, etc

but better overall? Idk Stash. There’s other franchises out there that are better at running their organizations to actually win football games.

  1. Endorsements
  2. Pieces around him
  3. Notoriety
  4. Visibility
  5. Comfort level
  6. Support staff
  7. State taxes

I'll ask you, what team is lining up to throw the money at him? Who is this "mystery team" that Spears and everyone else seems to think is 'waiting in the wings'?[/QUOTE]
 

Hadenough

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,365
Reaction score
12,615
I don't even know if I'd be sad about Dak holding out. I think he is a great person and I want the best for him, but I just don't think he is good enough. If I'm paying someone 40 million dollars he better have an elite physical trait. Dak doesn't have one of those.
This is how every true Cowboy fan should feel but I would make the number 30 mil and say for 30 mil he better show some premier physical abilities.
 

khiladi

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,783
Reaction score
34,915
Yes.. WE need him to step up in big games.. If he can't we need to be able to sign players who can and not be restricted by a contract that doesn't allow that.

He's closer to Tannehill then he is Mahomes..

the only reason Dak is starting and has 4 years is because of THAT coach and his culture.
 

Bullflop

Cowboys Diehard
Messages
24,589
Reaction score
29,946
I'm certain Stephen will do what he can to get Dak signed to a new contract, if what he's been saying means anything.

There likely wouldn't be too significant of a difference between a new agreement and being franchise tagged, anyhow.

I'd think it wouldn't serve Dak, nor the Cowboys well to hold out. The loss of training and activity would be devastating.
 
Last edited:

HungryLion

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,557
Reaction score
60,459
That might be the only area, and even that's not a guarantee. Where's he going? What's he getting paid? How long is he getting paid?



  1. Endorsements
  2. Pieces around him
  3. Notoriety
  4. Visibility
  5. Comfort level
  6. Support staff
  7. State taxes

I'll ask you, what team is lining up to throw the money at him? Who is this "mystery team" that Spears and everyone else seems to think is 'waiting in the wings'?

I’m not saying there are stash. I just disagree that the cowboys are necessarily the best organization for any player, let alone Dak, to play for. When it comes to actually winning especially.

I don’t think Dak is going to hold out regardless. It’s just more worrying about the contract from the fan base. When I don’t think it’s really in question for the person that matters. Jerry Jones.
 

conner01

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,926
Reaction score
25,831
He’s not about to throw away 28M on the franchise tag to sit out a season. Not happening!
He wouldn’t be
Soon as he holds out he gets paid
The team wants him and are not gonna let him miss camp
I don’t think it gets to that though
I think he will be signed before camp
 

nobody

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,417
Reaction score
18,524
But Catch....you say he's 0-5 against top rank defenses. C'mon.....can't believe you're not taking our poor defense AND coaching into consideration.

I support Dak and think he can get it done, but his play during some parts of this last season has led to some questions.

Poor defense and coaching helped with losses, but if you want to be paid $40 million like an elite QB, then you'd better not average 1.6 TD's and 1.4 Interceptions per game against good defenses. You have to step up and play elite.
Dak played some great ball in some games in 2019. In games where it really mattered, the entire team disappeared. Where was his leadership then? Where was his elite talent then?

I believe in Dak, but not for 20% of the salary cap and not without a little more evidence especially under a new scheme and coaching. If it's 30-35, I can buy that for a short term deal so they don't nuke the cap and give the team a chance to get some talent in key areas to make a run. After that short term deal, then he can play from a position of better or worse strength depending all on his play.

That he didn't gripe about playing out his rookie contract is huge. He should get paid...just not 40 since he didn't play elite when the season was on the line.
 

USArmyVet

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,708
Reaction score
15,031
I agree with Bart Scott.

0-5 against top 10 defenses.. 8 TDs and 7 turnovers..

Pay the man lol.






They need to stop with the whole "...but he threw for almost 5,000 yards" BS. The team finished 8-8 and Dak did NOTHING when the team needed him most. You can blame coaching all you want but the simple fact is that Dak IS NOT a franchise QB and IS NOT worth $30M+.

The team has done NOTHING under Dak so if he doesn;t want a team friendly deal paying hoim respectable money ($23-$26M/year) then apply the Non-Exclusive Franchise tag on him so he can negotiate a deal with another team. If they sign him to a contract and Dallas does not match it, Dallas receives (2) 1st round draft picks in return.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,366
Reaction score
102,293
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I’m not saying there are stash. I just disagree that the cowboys are necessarily the best organization for any player, let alone Dak, to play for. When it comes to actually winning especially.

I never said "any player", I specified Dak Prescott.

I don’t think Dak is going to hold out regardless. It’s just more worrying about the contract from the fan base. When I don’t think it’s really in question for the person that matters. Jerry Jones.

I don't either, but when these people bring up threats and holdouts, I start to consider the team's options as well. He needs them more than they need him.
 

eromeopolk

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,545
Reaction score
4,422
It would be the logical thing to do. I hope we just sign him or let him go free. Why franchise a QB that if you draft a QB in the 1st round would demand a trade ASAP.

The reason the Cowboys are mediocre is because no commitment and leadership at Head Coach or you winning QB. So you loss team chemistry and focus.
 

CouchCoach

Staff member
Messages
41,122
Reaction score
74,901
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I don't think he'll hold out but he's in the same position as Elliott was going into last year. A team that desperately needs him to hold the ship together with no other good alternatives. He wouldn't lose sponsorships for what's considered normal NFL business either. The only place he'd have a negative effect would be with fans but if I'm a player I wouldn't care less about what they think. They're mostly Cro-Magnon drama queens anyway. He would want to uphold his good ol' boy image as the QB but if he gets paid massively, fans will hate him for it anyway, hence my philosophy about fans, lol. That's why Zeke's agent was brilliant. Get the largest contract ever in exchange for "uncomfortable" fans mouthing off on the internet. I'd take that trade.
I disagree on the sponsors, Marcus. QB's are held up to a different light and are the hub of the wheel. Image is critical to them and the team......and the sponsors.

If a team wants to keep their QB, they will not allow it to get to a holdout as that is self-defeating to all parties. Which is why you see them acquiescing to the QB's and paying what they're paying. The damage to the public image of the QB would be total.

Elliott holding out is different, short shelf time on that position, too many get injured and he's just the RB, like Bryant was just the WR and Lawrence just the DE. If Prescott had a shoulder that needed surgery, how do you think that would be viewed as opposed to Lawrence waiting?

In today's NFL, there's the team and there's the QB and they are not handled the same.

There are companies that provide Q Factors to other companies wanting an endorsement as to the "likability" of a spokesperson and evidently Prescott scored highly, higher than more successful QB's. His agent would not risk that holding out over 27.5M, who in the hell could even relate to that? If he officially held out, there would be a hold put on every ad he's on and reportedly, he makes 7M a year just doing that. Do you see Cousins, Goff or Wentz a lot?
 

Ranching

Well-Known Member
Messages
42,848
Reaction score
107,130
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Just draft in the first round.. We'll be fine. QB's are better then ever coming out and Dallas has a rock solid foundation for any QB to step in and be ok.

Just get someone with a little mobility and we'll be fine.
Yeah. Let's start all over again. I've seen 5 superbowls and I've been waiting 25 years for another. What's a few more years? Makes it more fun around here when we suck. Lol
 

USArmyVet

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,708
Reaction score
15,031
Difference between a true Franchise QB and a middle of the road QB:

QB #1
31 Games 1,099 Attempts 724 Completions 65.9 % Comp. 9,412 Yards 76 TD's 18 INT's 108.9 QBR 110 Rushes 500 Yards 4 TD's Team Record as Starter 24 Wins 8 Losses Playoff Record 3 Wins 1 Loss

QB #2
64 Games 2,071 Attempts 1,363 Completions 65.8% Comp. 15,778 Yards 97 TD's 36 INT's 97 QBR 241 Rushes 1,221 Yards 21 TD's Team Record as Starter 40 Wins 24 Losses Playoff Record 0 Wins 2 Losses


QB #1 is Pat Mahomes and QB #2 is Dak Prescott. A QB can run up all the stats they want in garbage games and claim they deserve to be paid as a top franchise QB but the only stat that matters is do they elevate the team to the Super Bowl????? Well, in only is 2nd season as a starer Mahomes has done that whereas Dak in 4 seasons is nothing but a stat compiler.
 

ABQCOWBOY

Regular Joe....
Messages
58,929
Reaction score
27,716
It would be the logical thing to do. I hope we just sign him or let him go free. Why franchise a QB that if you draft a QB in the 1st round would demand a trade ASAP.

The reason the Cowboys are mediocre is because no commitment and leadership at Head Coach or you winning QB. So you loss team chemistry and focus.

What?
 
Top