AB Or Crayton??

[Frozen700]

who would u rather have on the team...4 the third WR? who would be a bigger threat?

AB-has alot of skills and talent......good speed...deep threat

Crayton-great routes...great awarness n concentration...n great hands

i dont kno.....i loved Antonio when he played 4 us..n everytime i watch a SF game i always only look 4 his stats...i still like him

but i also got alot love for crayton....the only thing i dont like about crayton..is him acting foolish on PR....but hes a great reciever..i cant choose...who would u guys rather have tho?

 

[TRUTH87]

AB is more talented than Crayton. But I'm ok with Crayton, I just dont see him ever beeing a big threat. AB I did.

 

[2much2soon]

Crayton by a long shot. Better hands, not a head case.
AB is wasting a lot of physical talent. Crayton is using every ounce of his.

 

[AbeBeta]

Crayton is far better for the 3rd receiver role.

Anyone ever hear him complain?

 

[Frozen700]

Crayton by a long shot. Better hands, not a head case.
AB is wasting a lot of physical talent. Crayton is using every ounce of his.

hmmm maybe soo.....

 

[Dale]

AB is definitely more talented. And if we were to lose a starting receiver for a stretch of time, I'd prefer AB. I think he's more starting material.

Crayton, however, I think is tailor made for that slot receiver position. He embraces the role, runs good routes and is good at picking up first downs. I could see AB pouting about not starting and he wasn't exactly known for the best of route running (in terms of running the right routes).

 

[GLIDINGJJ]

Been there done that. AB has all the talent one can imagine. However, the game is more then just talent. You can't disrespect your coach and AB did that. Even TO wasn't that stupid. I think a lot of what TO does is an act. I think AB is what he is. TO's team mates for the most part have loved him. I don't think you can say the same about AB. All that said, I think AB is still a stud. However, I question whether he would play the supporting type role Crayton has been willing to play with the Cowboys this year.

 

[kapolani]

I think AB has more talent.

But, Crayton has that "fire in the gut" and has his head screwed on correctly.

 

[burmafrd]

AB has 40 catches for 773 yds and 3 tds
PC has 32 catches for 477 yds and 3 tds
Patrick is our #3 and AB is SF's #2 or maybe co #1 with Battle
If PC was a #2 he would have a lot more catches.
Not to mention a better attitude and better team mate. No contest

 

[Jimz31]

I like them both as well and also look for AB's stats.

 

[2much2soon]

There was a story posted on here, when AB was in Dallas, about how he had as many or more trophies for academics than athletics.
There has to be something going on with the guy, probably undiagnosed, for him to not be able to put it all together. He seems like he has everything needed to be wildly successful in the NFL.
As it is, he is on his 3rd team and looking like he will bounce around a few more teams before he is through with nothing more than a relatively average career. Relative to what many(including me) thought he would be.

 

[burmafrd]

million dollar body and ten cent head.

 

[jrumann59]

There was a story posted on here, when AB was in Dallas, about how he had as many or more trophies for academics than athletics.
There has to be something going on with the guy, probably undiagnosed, for him to not be able to put it all together. He seems like he has everything needed to be wildly successful in the NFL.
As it is, he is on his 3rd team and looking like he will bounce around a few more teams before he is through with nothing more than a relatively average career. Relative to what many(including me) thought he would be.

What is up with SF as of late being the nurturing grounds for headcase WR. TO, LLoyd, Stokes, now Bryant, it must be the NFL half way house for soon to be Divas.

 

[fjones]

Watch how he blocks when he is in sealing off the line so runs can get to the outside... I think he does an excellent job of this...

 

[Doomsday101]

I think Crayton fits the role very well and is vastly under rated. AB too high maintenace and is a sloppy rout runner

 

[conner01]

no question i would take crayton. what people tend to forget is the jersey thing was not why ab was sent packing. twice during games ab refused to leave the field when his subsitute came in. once we had to use a time out. thats why ab is gone, not because of the jersey.ab is a starter and crayton is out 3rd option with two very,very good wr's in front of him