After 127 starts, Romo/Prescott by the numbers

[Verdict]

I don’t think Romo ever had a legit OL. Jerry let Romo run for his life. I think that’s an apples to oranges comparison on that factor

 

[diamonddelts]

Ha


You thought u cooked with that one…

You thought you saw one.

 

[OGSixshooter]

I've always said...six in one hand, 1/2 dozen in the other.

 

[erod]

Romo had epic performances in critical games at important moments of the season. Dak hasn't yet. Period.

Until that changes beyond just early season successes and garbage time stats late in the season, Romo will continue to be far superior.

Both certainly have been hampered by Jerry's incompetence, lack of integrity and circus act just the same.

Romo is done. Dak is not. There is time, but it's ticking fast.

 

[erod]

I don’t think Romo ever had a legit OL. Jerry let Romo run for his life. I think that’s an apples to oranges comparison on that factor

He dang sure did in 2014. Great line. Dez caught it.

But he was broken after so many years without a good line that he couldn't make any more runs at it

 

[Chasing6]

I've shown this before on the board comparing their numbers. Romo was really turning into a good veteran QB by the end and putting up some of these same numbers Dak is at this point in his career. They both have same two issues though --- Playoff Chokers (which I would probably give Romo the edge on playing better), and Can Their Body Hold Up? (Which I probably give Dak the edge on staying healthier longer).

And they both did not have a KC D that only gave up 17 points a game.

 

[diamonddelts]

Romo had epic performances in critical games at important moments of the season. Dak hasn't yet. Period.

Utter and complete bullfeces. Romo is well known as one of the biggest chokers of all time in big moments. A walking pick waiting to happen at the worst possible moment. Losing the ball in the Seattle playoff game.

Nonfactor in Minnesota playoff game. Backbreaking pick against the top ranked Broncos in prime time. Pick 6 in a win and get in game against the Eagles. I could go on.

You all need to stop with the constant lies and revisionist history. I've been tough on Dak when he plays bad and I give him credit when he plays well. Neither Dak or Romo were made for the moment during big games in the playoffs. Only difference is Dak's career is not over yet. Romo's career with his highs and all time choke sessions are done. His chapter is closed.

 

[diamonddelts]

Despite having a reputation as a "choker," some of Tony Romo's worst moments were marked by an unfortunate pattern of costly turnovers in high-pressure games, often with the Cowboys' season on the line. These episodes, particularly in the postseason, cemented his image for many critics.

Postseason meltdowns

2007 NFC Wild Card Game vs. Seattle Seahawks: In perhaps the most famous "choke" of his career, Romo fumbled the snap for a game-winning 19-yard field goal with just over a minute left in the game. After regaining possession, he attempted to run for the end zone but was tackled inches short, sealing the 21–20 loss.

2008 NFC Divisional Playoffs vs. New York Giants: With the Cowboys holding the #1 seed, Romo threw an interception with 16 seconds left on the clock while trailing by four points. The turnover sealed the Giants' victory and sent the Cowboys home with a disappointing one-and-done playoff exit.

2010 NFC Divisional Playoffs vs. Minnesota Vikings: The Cowboys offense, led by Romo, delivered a lackluster performance in a 34–3 blowout loss. Romo committed a key interception and two fumbles that contributed to the one-sided defeat.

Regular season collapses

2008 Week 17 vs. Philadelphia Eagles: In a winner-take-all game to secure a playoff spot, Romo and the Cowboys were embarrassed in a 44–6 rout. Romo threw an interception and lost two fumbles, including one that was returned for a touchdown.

2011 Week 4 vs. Detroit Lions: After building a 24–0 halftime lead, Romo unraveled in the second half. He threw two costly pick-sixes, helping the undefeated Lions mount a comeback and win the game 34–30.

2012 Week 17 vs. Washington Commanders: In another season-finale game with a playoff spot on the line, Romo threw three interceptions in a 28–18 loss. The loss marked the third consecutive season the Cowboys missed the playoffs under Romo.

2013 Week 15 vs. Green Bay Packers: With the Cowboys holding a 36–24 lead in the fourth quarter, Romo threw two interceptions, including a game-sealing pick, allowing the Packers to win 37–36.

 

[SoupcanSam]

You forgot the most important stat.

Superbowls:
Romo 0, Prescott 0

 

[NDGAEDE]

They really are similar.

Written off in the draft, took advantage of their opportunity and never gave it up, prodigious offensive production despite lack of talent around them, marred by injuries and bad playoff performances. Let's hope Dak can finish the end of his career better than Romo.

 

[plymkr]

Teams around them? Both were hampered at various stages by rosters constructed by Jerry and Stephen. That's why there are only four total playoff wins combined between them.

Both were also hampered by Jason Garrett. Which I guess is a symptom of the bigger problem of being hampered by Jerry and Stephen.

 

[acr731]

Bro, Dak plays in a league right now where you start with the ball on the 40 yard line if the K kicks it too short into the landing zone.

Romo’s entire career, a touchback started on the 20.

Regardless of the “era discussion”, Romo played under what many would call the “worst coach in cowboys history” Jason Garrett. Why isnt that considered in these comparisons?


I know why….

They're trying to get Dak fitted for his HOF jacket with only 2 career playoff wins under his belt. Just think of the possibilities if Dak could only play the Jets and Giants every week.

 

[DFWJC]

I don’t think Romo ever had a legit OL. Jerry let Romo run for his life. I think that’s an apples to oranges comparison on that factor

The line finally was for real in 2014
It was also decent in his QB infancy (06 and 07)

But some of his lines were as bad as anyone can imagine. And he paid the price with a shortened career

 

[WillieBeamen]

Lie to me and tell me Dak is capable of this. Factoring in opponent and venue…

 

[diamonddelts]

Lie to me and tell me Dak is capable of this. Factoring in opponent and venue…

Romo clutch!

 

[Cmac]

Clearly romo was better


“The same QB” is a lazy analysis when you factor in era, eye test, and the teams they had around them

Clearly???......Hi WillieBeamen.

 

[pete026]

All these Romo/Dak threads do is expose hate.

Can't for the life of me figure out the fascination in comparing the two QBs or discussing a QB who retired almost 10 years ago? I can understand Dak threads, as obnoxiously repetitive as some are, because he is the present QB. It is the nature of forums and it happens with pretty much every standing QB. But then again, I also don't get the trolling thing either so that probably answers my own question.

 

[12+88=7]

All these Romo/Dak threads do is expose hate.

Can't for the life of me figure out the fascination in comparing the two QBs or discussing a QB who retired almost 10 years ago? I can understand Dak threads, as obnoxiously repetitive as some are, because he is the present QB. It is the nature of forums and it happens with pretty much every standing QB. But then again, I also don't get the trolling thing either so that probably answers my own question.

I created the thread because each QB now has exactly 127 starts each. There would be no apples to oranges comparison numbers wise. Any comparison before last week or after would have some bias.

 

[pete026]

I created the thread because each QB now has exactly 127 starts each. There would be no apples to oranges comparison numbers wise. Any comparison before last week or after would have some bias.

There will always be bias because of the circumstances between the two and Romo's love/hate relationship with Cowboys fans.

FWIW I wasn't making the comment to this thread only. These comparisons between the two or the Romo appreciation threads show up frequently and just end up with bickering between those opposing sides. I guess some people enjoy arguing the same topic, ad nauseam.

 

[DallasInDC]

WINS: Romo 78, Prescott 78
LOSSES: Romo 49, Prescott 48
TIES: Romo 0, Prescott 1
PASS ATT: Romo 4,335, Prescott 4,354
COMPLETIONS: Romo 2,829, Prescott 2,919
COMPLETION %: Romo 65.3, Prescott 67.0
PASSING YARDS: Romo 34,183, Prescott 32,793
PASSING TOUCHDOWNS: Romo 248, Prescott 223
INTERCEPTIONS: Romo 117, Prescott 85
1ST DOWNS: Romo 1,659, Prescott 1,599
YARDS PER PASS ATTEMPT: Romo 7.9, Prescott 7.5
QB RATE: Romo 97.1, Prescott 98.3
SACKS: Romo 248, Prescott 263
4TH QT COMEBACKS: Romo 24, Prescott 17
GAME WINNING DRIVES: Romo 29, Prescott 24

PLAYOFF STARTS: Romo 6, Prescott 7
WINS: Romo 2, Prescott 2
LOSSES Romo 4, Prescott 5


Their stats are very similar across the board.

I just saw where someone posted that when you add rushing yards and TDs Romo had 34,803 yards and 253 TDs and Dak had 34,781 yards and 253 TD. No matter what you say, their careers are identical to this point. Arguing over who was better is really an argument on whether you have 6 eggs or a half dozen.