ALL THE RAGE: Wade vs. Rocky Balboa?!?

Messages
132
Reaction score
3
The Cowboys went the distance, but the journey sure was rocky. In overtime, they edged the Chiefs, 26-20, in the least publicly convincing win since Bush beat Gore. As then, the outcome has polarized the country, leaving experts and enthusiasts to reveal their glasses: half-empty or fully rose-colored. Consciously or not, Dallas fans, no matter where they reside, now live in a blue state, grateful for the win, yet fearful of the future. Sad.

Of course, it didn't have to be this way. The team could have met expectations, whether reasonable or not, and trounced the Kansas City squad that previously had shown so little life the game was previewed as the Cowboys' triumphant weekend at Bernie's. But Dallas failed to bury their opponents, instead intent on self-destruction; a muffed punt and bungled snap gave KC an early and panic-inducing ten point lead. The 'boys response to this disastrous start could be analyzed as indicative of the remainder of the season.

So, what have we learned?

First, what we haven't: Reflexive evaluations of single-game performances are pointless. Yes, Miles Austin had a record-setting day. He caught ten balls (and more tackles) for 250 yards receiving... and two touchdowns that established the late lead, then won the game. However, note he also dropped other passes that could have negated the need for his fifth quarter heroics. He is still a work in progress, not the second coming of Bob Hayes. Tony Romo posted good numbers yet still has Miles to thank and miles to go before I sleep. Let's skip the weekly flip-flop between anointing and finger-pointing. The quarterback's progress will only be determined at (post?) season's end.

Instead, let's consider the demeanor of two key figures, Wade Phillips and Jay Ratliff. Their differences are as telling as the final score. They model the superlative extremes of leadership, the much ballyhooed intangible too often ascribed to the loudest and/or most charismatic. Neither the coach nor the nose tackle meet this base criteria, but their behaviors mark the distinction between being a character and having character. Jay Ratliff is as solid an individual as he is a player. Considered under-sized for his defensive role, Ratliff has proven last year's Pro Bowl selection was neither a popularity contest nor a fluke. Ratliff's seemingly unshakable self-confidence fuels his refusal to be double-teamed, doubted or defeated. Rather than rally the troops histrionically, he lets his play set the standard. It has all season. He may have only had four tackles yesterday, but his block of Ryan Succop's fourth-quarter field goal attempt was testament to his talent and determination, a model for his teammates. Vaulting the narrow gap between two blockers, he swatted down the potential game-changer as if furious the Chiefs would even dare think of taking the lead again. More tellingly, in his post-game comments, Ratliff deflected credit as thoroughly as he had the kick. "You've got a guy like Igor as big and strong as he is and Spears doing the same thing, getting low, it just opened up a path for me." Say what he will, it is clear watching the replay: Ratliff single-handedly altered the course of the afternoon. Had the Chiefs scored then, the Cowboys may have deflated, as aware as the fans of their meltdowns versus the Giants and the Broncos. Ratliff's effort allowed Austin to shine as the day's lone star of Texas.

On the other hand and on the sideline, Wade Phillips continues to demonstrate why he is unfit for his nominal title as Head Coach. He is simply playing the role and doing so poorly. One could argue this is a consequence of Jerry Jones's puppetry, but even if the owner is pulling some strings, Phillips' cornpone act is more wooden than Pinocchio's, pre-wish. Hi-diddle-dee-dee-yee-ha, folks. Wade ignores sloppy play during games and excuses it after the fact, wishing upon his "stars" as if they were all as sage and capricious as Jiminy Cricket. Granted, not all coaches need spout fire, but sporting a pulse seems a minimal requirement. I am positive that every single Dallas fan gnashed teeth, clenched fists and shouted epithets after the defense accrued four offsides penalties in a single drive... and Marion Barber remained in the backfield when clearly hampered and Tashard Choice was having a better day... and Alan Ball enabled the Chiefs to convert on 3rd and 26. Don't get me wrong. Phillips didn't remain calm. (That could be perceived as leadership of a Landry-esque sort.) Worse, Phillips didn't react at all. If ever the answer on Jeopardy is "Nothing," the question should be: What Would Wade Do? Now there's a bumper sticker for the uninspired.

What Wade can't muster and Jay thrives on, is rage. Ratliff looks back in anger and avenges his teammates' failures on the next play. Wade seems content just to have a job... which is somewhat understandable given how many remind he should be unemployed. However, the coach should not and can not be satisfied. If the owner won't fire him, Wade owes it to everyone else to get fired up. Bench Bobby Carpenter. Move Crayton to the slot. Tell Garrett to dumb it down and dial up a few plays for Martellus. Get involved. Get angry.

In the face of personal adversity, I have questioned my own strength and considered withdrawal. (Run away. Run away!) It is easy for Fatigue to triumph in Crisis. Sleeplessness, self-doubt and sloppy performance can overwhelm Ego. I know. In these times of financial hardship and individual malaise, my fight-or-flight mechanism malfunctions, swinging wildly between the two preservational options. Unchecked, I can become hermetic or hysteric. In retreat, I am certain to lose all. In combat, though, Anger may propel me to unanticipated reward/s.

Victory is impossible if we refuse to compete and highly unlikely if we passively accept the possibility or repercussions of defeat. It is time for all of us to follow Ratliff's lead or, better yet, adopt Rocky Balboa's attitude. In his climactic rematch with Clubber Lang, (see: ROCKY III) the southpaw takes a beating all the while taunting his opponent: "You're not so bad. You're not so bad. You're nothing." The pounding worries Apollo Creed, now in Rocky's corner, until Paulie explains his brother-in-law's strategy: "He's not getting killed, he's getting mad."

You've taken enough body blows and upper cuts. Get mad, Cowboys. Get mad.


(Note that this is part five of an ongoing series. To read Lessons 1-4, please visit: www.thewarrenreport.com)
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
Wade Phillips reminds of the whimpy kid on the playground waiting for the next beating.

He comes across, on the sideline anyway, as someone who has no control of anything so why try and do something other than stand there and face the inevitable. Get mad, Wade, get mad!
 

juck

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,246
Reaction score
244
Wade is a buffoon. Red is right behind him. Rat is the man.
 
Messages
132
Reaction score
3
juck;3011310 said:
Wade is a buffoon. Red is right behind him. Rat is the man.

I'm with you, Juck. Wade's too dumb to know better. Jason's too "smart" to recognize he's a fool. Jay is just right: wise enough to be pissed off.
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
TheWarrenReport;3011338 said:
I'm with you, Juck. Wade's too dumb to know better. Jason's too "smart" to recognize he's a fool. Jay is just right: wise enough to be pissed off.

I'd like to say that Wade is too old to coach -- No football for old men? -- but Tom Coughlin is proof that age is irrelevant. Lovie Smith is not far behind.
 

poke

the older I get the better I was
Messages
2,585
Reaction score
17
i dont know Wade Phillips personally.

i am guessing none of ya'll know Wade Phillips personally.

i do know Wade played and coached Texas High School Football.
i do know i never met a Texas High School Football coach who wouldnt/couldnt get mad as hell.

what we see on TV doesnt tell us the whole story.

if you dont like him thats your choice but dont pretend that any of us know
more about football than he does.
 
Messages
132
Reaction score
3
Zimmy Lives;3011351 said:
I'd like to say that Wade is too old to coach -- No football for old men? -- but Tom Coughlin is proof that age is irrelevant. Lovie Smith is not far behind.

The only benefit of age is experience. And, if you refuse to learn from it, that ain't no advantage. Too bad Wade's such a terrible student of his own history.
 

baj1dallas

New Member
Messages
6,556
Reaction score
1
poke;3011356 said:
if you dont like him thats your choice but dont pretend that any of us know
more about football than he does.

yea I refuse to be one of those who is foaming at the mouth for the coach to publicly call out his own players through the media.

OTOH there has to be something done about the undisciplined play and if it continues through the next month of the season, you have to eventually blame the head coach (or the owner).
 

MachPilot

Member
Messages
66
Reaction score
0
It is no surprise that Wade is an absolute coaching liability. I'm just not convinced that JG isnt one as well and that BOTH of them need to go.

My undisputed issue with this team is coaching. Simple.

Doc
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
poke;3011356 said:
i dont know Wade Phillips personally.

i am guessing none of ya'll know Wade Phillips personally.

i do know Wade played and coached Texas High School Football.
i do know i never met a Texas High School Football coach who wouldnt/couldnt get mad as hell.

what we see on TV doesnt tell us the whole story.

if you dont like him thats your choice but dont pretend that any of us know
more about football than he does.

Bum, is that you?
 
Messages
132
Reaction score
3
poke;3011356 said:
if you dont like him thats your choice but dont pretend that any of us know
more about football than he does.

If none of us pretended to know more about football than the players or coaches, this site wouldn't exist. Right? :dance3:
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
TheWarrenReport;3011393 said:
If none of us pretended to know more about football than the players or coaches, this site wouldn't exist. Right? :dance3:

AND, Mr. Phillips received the benefit of the doubt when he said things would change at the end of last year. So far, nothing has changed so it's difficult to believe that he is saying/doing things in private that will change the performance on the field.
 
Messages
132
Reaction score
3
Zimmy Lives;3011413 said:
AND, Mr. Phillips received the benefit of the doubt when he said things would change at the end of last year. So far, nothing has changed so it's difficult to believe that he is saying/doing things in private that will change the performance on the field.

Thanks, Zimmy. That's all we have: the results. There is no discernible proof that Wade has altered his approach or earned the respect of his players. Perhaps he does get mad in his own way, but to no consequential effect. Sometimes getting mad isn't a matter of raising one's voice, but surely indications of dissatisfaction are necessary and appropriate. No one seems to fear Phillips' disapproval... and that marks the death of a leader, no matter his high school coaching background.
 
Messages
132
Reaction score
3
MachPilot;3011377 said:
It is no surprise that Wade is an absolute coaching liability. I'm just not convinced that JG isnt one as well and that BOTH of them need to go.

My undisputed issue with this team is coaching. Simple.

Doc

So here's a question: Should ANY member of the current coaching staff be retained? For consistency's sake? Hudson Houck? Ray Sherman? Anyone?
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
TheWarrenReport;3011529 said:
So here's a question: Should ANY member of the current coaching staff be retained? For consistency's sake? Hudson Houck? Ray Sherman? Anyone?

I really like Sherman, DeCamilis, and Herrin (LBs) but after that I'm not sure. I would like to think the d-line coach and RBs coaches are doing a good job but I don't know their names.

If it was up to me, I'd give Sherman another shot as HC.
 
Messages
132
Reaction score
3
Zimmy Lives;3011753 said:
If it was up to me, I'd give Sherman another shot as HC.

Sherman would certainly be my choice for interim coach... if we were to get so lucky. He seems to have the respect of the players and the requisite fire in the belly.
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
TheWarrenReport;3011765 said:
Sherman would certainly be my choice for interim coach... if we were to get so lucky. He seems to have the respect of the players and the requisite fire in the belly.

Agreed.

I'm not sure why Sherman did not suceed as HC in the past but he sure seems to have the right tools for the job.
 
Messages
132
Reaction score
3
Zimmy Lives;3011773 said:
Agreed.

I'm not sure why Sherman did not suceed as HC in the past but he sure seems to have the right tools for the job.

Was he ever a head coach? I thought his 21 years in the NFL were purely as an assistant...
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
TheWarrenReport;3011832 said:
Was he ever a head coach? I thought his 21 years in the NFL were purely as an assistant...

You're right, he has not been a HC. I do know that he's been an OC before but I've always wondered why no one gave him a shot as the HC.
 

MachPilot

Member
Messages
66
Reaction score
0
Warren,

To be honest the only coach I feel that should remain is Sherman. He is respected semmingly by his players and that if anything is a valuable asset.

Provided a new head coach comes in, dont they usually gut the exsisting coaching heirarchy and replace them with their "own people."

Its what we do in the hospital...its still a business in the end.

Doc
 
Top