Anyone care to guess who the highest rated QB in football is?

[The30YardSlant]

Believe it or not....

1 David Carr HOU 865 111 81 7 2 53 108.9
2 Damon Huard KC 481 66 47 3 0 37 106.9
3 Donovan McNabb PHI 960 113 69 7 1 60 105.3
4 Chad Pennington NYJ 1015 122 82 6 2 71 102.3
5 Rex Grossman CHI 1061 125 78 8 3 49 100.8
6 Peyton Manning IND 1112 140 86 6 1 41 97.7
7 Philip Rivers SD 488 68 46 3 1 38 96.9
8 Eli Manning NYG 893 113 75 8 5 37 95.5
9 Marc Bulger STL 1039 141 84 5 0 49 94.3
10 Mark Brunell WAS 950 118 77 4 2 74 94.2

 

[Chuck 54]

I told you guys last week that he had a 120+ rating after 3 games despite being sacked 9 times in the first two games.

This week when they won was actually not a good week for him overall.

I am shocked to see Brunnell at #10...dayum...even with his last two weeks, I wouldn't have thought he'd overcome that horrendous start.

 

[Dave_in-NC]

Imagine what he could do on a NFL team?

 

[Gordon]

He's playing well...

With that said, he had a "monster" game against the Colts but he compiled basically all those stats down 3-4 TDs, playing against a vanilla defense.

 

[dbair1967]

Believe it or not....

1 David Carr HOU 865 111 81 7 2 53 108.9
2 Damon Huard KC 481 66 47 3 0 37 106.9
3 Donovan McNabb PHI 960 113 69 7 1 60 105.3
4 Chad Pennington NYJ 1015 122 82 6 2 71 102.3
5 Rex Grossman CHI 1061 125 78 8 3 49 100.8
6 Peyton Manning IND 1112 140 86 6 1 41 97.7
7 Philip Rivers SD 488 68 46 3 1 38 96.9
8 Eli Manning NYG 893 113 75 8 5 37 95.5
9 Marc Bulger STL 1039 141 84 5 0 49 94.3
10 Mark Brunell WAS 950 118 77 4 2 74 94.2

more proof of stats being for losers and being misleading...Carr is nowhere near the best QB in football, nor is he playing at the kind of level his rating suggests...

David

 

[CanadianCowboysFan]

more proof of stats being for losers and being misleading...Carr is nowhere near the best QB in football, nor is he playing at the kind of level his rating suggests...

David

 

[Tuna Helper]

more proof of stats being for losers and being misleading...Carr is nowhere near the best QB in football, nor is he playing at the kind of level his rating suggests...

David

He has lost a fumble in every single game this year. Where does that show up in his rating? His rating is high because he racks up yards in garbage time during a blowout, against opposing teams that are playing prevent defense.

 

[theogt]

QB rating is dependent upon large sample sizes. Small data sets tend to have peculiar results.

 

[big dog cowboy]

more proof of stats being for losers and being misleading...Carr is nowhere near the best QB in football, nor is he playing at the kind of level his rating suggests...

David

Playing catchup and throwing into prevent defenses that allow you a high completion rate might have something to do with his high rating. I would suggest that should he finish the season the highest rated QB in the league he won't go to the pro bowl.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

I am shocked to see Brunnell at #10...dayum...even with his last two weeks, I wouldn't have thought he'd overcome that horrendous start.

throwing 3 TDs in a game can do wonders

where does Bledsoe rank?

 

[The30YardSlant]

throwing 3 TDs in a game can do wonders

where does Bledsoe rank?

22nd

 

[Bob Sacamano]

22nd

that's right, I forgot the Jax game