Best WR in the NFC East?

[CATCH17]

Who is the best in our division?

For as much heat as Roy Williams is taking i'd say he is the best with TO and Plax now gone.

 

[WoodysGirl]

Until proven otherwise, I'd say Santana Moss.

Roy has to do it in the NFC East to be considered the best in the NFC East.

 

[GoBoys41]

Why the hell does he need to do it in the NFC East? You mean to tell me if an NFC East team trades for Randy Moss or Anquan Boldin, they don't immediately become the best receiver in the NFC East? That's just silly.
​

 

[Mansta54]

RW is new to the East but I'd still take him over Moss and all the other recievers in the div.

 

[Bleu Star]

Until proven otherwise, I'd say Santana Moss.

Roy has to do it in the NFC East to be considered the best in the NFC East.

co-signed.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

none impress me

 

[WoodysGirl]

Why the hell does he need to do it in the NFC East? You mean to tell me if an NFC East team trades for Randy Moss or Anquan Boldin, they don't immediately become the best receiver in the NFC East? That's just silly.​

Cuz I said so...

Those other guys aren't in the East so they don't count.

For all the legitimate reasons why Roy didn't produce last year, the fact is that he didn't produce. And that lack of production along with how Moss has consistently terrorized the 'boys since he joined the Skins make me think Moss is the best WR in the East.

Moss was a questionable acquisition by the Skins, but he's proven to be a good receiver for them. I want Roy to prove the same thing.

 

[Bleu Star]

none impress me

I agree with this too. Santana Moss is the least unimpressive amongst a slew of unimpressive NFCE WRs.

 

[slick325]

Until proven otherwise, I'd say Santana Moss.

Roy has to do it in the NFC East to be considered the best in the NFC East.

Agreed.

 

[Mansta54]

RW has always impressed me. Tall, good football speed, and catches everything in sight with his HANDS....

 

[silverbear]

Who is the best in our division?

Miles Austin... he's gonna catch 100 this year, just watch...

 

[GoBoys41]

If Moss is a legitimately better receiver than RW, which is a valid argument, then say so. But don't say it's Moss because Roy Williams hasn't proven it "in the NFC East". On that note, I still think RW has the most ability out of all of the NFCE receivers, but Moss wins this because he's been better over the course of his career than Roy.

 

[Mansta54]

Miles Austin... he's gonna catch 100 this year, just watch...

Don't know about the 100 catches but I do believe he's gonna be extremely impressive.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

I agree with this too. Santana Moss is the least unimpressive amongst a slew of unimpressive NFCE WRs.

he was great that 1st year with the Skins, but he's been pretty average the rest of the way

hopefully Roy has the opposite direction, 1st year sucks, but he puts up a slew of good seasons afterwards

 

[WoodysGirl]

If Moss is a legitimately better receiver than RW, which is a valid argument, then say so. But don't say it's Moss because Roy Williams hasn't proven it "in the NFC East". On that note, I still think RW has the most ability out of all of the NFCE receivers, but Moss wins this because he's been better over the course of his career than Roy.

I said what I meant. Moss is the best WR in the East.

I won't consider Roy until he produces in the East.

 

[TX_Yid]

Roy Williams has the potential, but for now it's Santana Moss.

Imagine what he might have done had the Commanders had a decent QB for the last few years.

 

[Mansta54]

I said what I meant. Moss is the best WR in the East.

I won't consider Roy until he produces in the East.

So "IF" Randy Moss was traded to the Eagles, would you still consider SM as the best in the east cause RM wasn't productive yet? Just curious!!

 

[CATCH17]

Until proven otherwise, I'd say Santana Moss.

Roy has to do it in the NFC East to be considered the best in the NFC East.

I sorta agree.

I just wouldn't take Moss over him. But I get what you are saying.

 

[Danny White]

Santana Moss.

From what I saw from Roy Williams last year, I'd say DeSean Jackson is better too. I was really hoping we'd draft him.

 

[WoodysGirl]

So IF Randy Moss was traded to the Eagles, would you still consider SM as the best in the east cause RM wasn't productive yet? Just curious!!

I consider it two different scenarios.
If it was after he was in NE before he came here, then I'd go with Randy. But if it was after he came from Oakland, then I might still go with Santana. Randy was a major dog in Oakland.

My opinion on Roy is based on what Roy did in Dallas last year...not all the other years in Detroit. If Randy came here last year and sucked it up like Roy did, then I'd prolly put Santana ahead of him, too.