Biggest draft misses for Dallas that could've altered history since 95

The Quest for Six

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,825
Reaction score
19,277
In 2005, we drafted Demarcus Ware over Aaron Rodgers.

Obviously Ware was an awesome player. But to see how things would have been with Rodgers at QB would be very interesting.

You forgot that Spears was taken at 20 because Dallas had two draft first round draft picks, Rodgers wasn't taken until 24th overall, so you could have had Ware and Rodgers.......
 

Zekeats

theranchsucks
Messages
12,831
Reaction score
15,209
None could have altered history.
The Cowboys leadership has failed this team, andno matter who they brought into this circus, they would have been stopped from achieving and turned into a circus freak.
The talent here has been exceptional. Jerry has pee'd away hundreds of millions of dollars and wasted 21 years of our lives.
Now everyone recognizes that this franchise is a well paying joke.
They're not here to win. They are here for a payday.
And the talent is now sub par.
Agreed I almost added that at the end. Still zero real gm and hc
 

perrykemp

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,491
Reaction score
9,226
You forgot that Spears was taken at 20 because Dallas had two draft first round draft picks, Rodgers wasn't taken until 24th overall, so you could have had Ware and Rodgers.......

Supposedly the Packers had targeted Spears. Rodgers was their consolidation prize...
 

DoctorChicken

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,656
Reaction score
16,902
You forgot that Spears was taken at 20 because Dallas had two draft first round draft picks, Rodgers wasn't taken until 24th overall, so you could have had Ware and Rodgers.......

Had it been the case, it would have given us -

Ware
Rodgers
Marion Barber
Jay Ratliff

That’d easily be one of the best drafts ever, for any team.

I’m a big Romo fan, always have been. But the decision to bet on him becoming a good QB was an absurd one.
 

cowboys1981

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,490
Reaction score
4,456
Even if we drafted the players mentioned above, it's not like we had a competent coaching staff that would've groomed them right.
 

nyc-cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,077
Reaction score
10,674
1. Randy Moss WR
Dallas still had the triplets in their prime, a very good offensive line and a not too shabby defense. Maybe Deion sticks around a little longer too so the secondary doesn't fall apart either. I honestly think we challenge for a ring the next 3 seasons with Moss who was such a game changer. Honestly in his prime he was by far the greatest WR.

2. Chris Johnson RB
Another generational talent. You put this guy behind Romo and on the field with Owens and Austin look out!. His speed wouldve been perfect for Dallas and I think we wouldve been way better from 2008-2012ish. We had some great teams that wouldve taken the next step with adding CJ and minus Felix.

Do you have any like mine where at the time you knew they drafted the wrong guy and left a game/team changer on the board?
You want draft misses - just look up who Jerry drafted in the years between Jimmy and Bill...
 

DB_Cooper

RubyRidge
Messages
547
Reaction score
823
No, you @BAT and @DB_Cooper are wrong...

"
Dallas CowboysEdit
Smith was selected by the Dallas Cowboys in the second round (36th overall) of the 1992 NFL Draft. He missed the first four games after he broke his right fibula during the Dallas Blue-White Scrimmage on July 19. After missing ample time during the season, he was listed as the fourth wide receiver on the Dallas Cowboys' depth chart, behind Michael Irvin, Alvin Harper, and Kelvin Martin. On October 11, he made his professional regular season debut during a 27–0 victory over the Seattle Seahawks. In a Week 16 matchup against the Atlanta Falcons, Smith had the highlight of his rookie year, tackling Deion Sanders during a punt return in a 41–17 victory. He played in just seven games as a special-teamer, without registering a reception. The Cowboys finished first in the NFC East, with a 13–3 record. On January 10, 1993, he appeared in his first career playoff game during the Cowboys' 34–10 win over the Philadelphia Eagles, playing on special teams. Smith earned the first ring of his career as a rookie, after the Cowboys went on to Super Bowl XXVII and defeated the Buffalo Bills 52–17.

In 1993, he was leading the team in pre-season (13) and receiving yards (197), while competing for the role as the third wide receiver that was left open with the departure in free agency of Kelvin Martin, behind Irvin and Harper. On August 21, Smith began feeling a pain in his abdominal area and brought it to the attention of two trainers and the team doctor, J.D. Zamarano, and was given Pepto Bismol, Maalox, and Tagamet. He played in the next preseason game and caught a touchdown reception, and was waved back in by a coach after taking himself out from taking a hit to the abdominal area that worsened the pain. Over the next few days, he repeatedly brought the pain to the attention of the trainers and wasn't given adequate care or the correct diagnosis. He asked to be directed to a doctor and was told to see the team doctor who gave him a checkup and took him to see the team surgeon, who finally diagnosed him with appendicitis. On August 24, 1993, he underwent an emergency appendectomy. The following day, the surgeon released him from the hospital, notwithstanding a 102.5 °F (39.2 °C) fever. On August 27, Smith was readmitted to the hospital after waking up in severe pain, vomiting and with a bloated stomach, because of a severe post-surgical infection that was nearly fatal. He went into emergency surgery for an ileostomy, in which a portion of his intestine was dissected and removed, with an external bag then fitted to collect his fecal matter, forcing Smith to miss the entire season, including Super Bowl XXVIII.[2] On October 2, the Cowboys placed him on the non-football illness list and opted not to pay his entire $350,000 salary for the 1993 season, as well as his insurance, pension, and free agent credits, instead making Smith an offer of $100,000 and no credits, which he declined.[3] The NFL Players Association filed a grievance with the Cowboys on Smith's behalf, alleging that he was due his full salary, which he won after going through arbitration.[4]

On July 11, 1994, he was waived after refusing to take a pay cut.

Philadelphia EaglesEdit
On July 19, 1994, he was signed as a free agent by the Philadelphia Eagles but was eventually released on August 30.[5]

Jacksonville JaguarsEdit
On February 28, 1995, Smith was signed by the expansion Jacksonville Jaguars after a tryout.[6] He made the team after head coach Tom Coughlin saw his talents.[7] He competed with Desmond Howard, Ernest Givens, Willie Jackson, Cedric Tillman, and Curtis Marsh throughout training camp for a job as a starting wide receiver. Head coach Tom Coughlin named him the fifth wide receiver on the depth chart behind Howard, Givens, Jackson, and Tillman. He finished the season leading the Jaguars in kickoff returns.

The next year, he became a starter after Andre Rison was released following the 11th game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. He would emerge as a dominant receiver..."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Smith_(wide_receiver)

As you can see, the NFL said it correctly...as did I. Jimmy Smith was cut "waived" by the Cowboys on July 11, 1994. The Eagles signed him days later on July 19, 1994, but they cut him a month later on August 30, 1994, thus Jimmy Smith never actually made it to a Regular Season to legally ever be considered a Philadelphia Eagle. Jimmy had to wait until February of 1995 until the Jacksonville Jaguars came around and offered him a job. The rest was history...

PS: What a terrible and ****** thing Jerry and the Cowboys front office did to treat Jimmy Smith that way due to an bad appendix that required emergency surgery. That was cold blood awful and so wrong. Karma came back and definitely bit then in the arse. Jimmy Smith made sure of that.
Guess I was wrong. I thought it was the expansion draft. Thanks for the research.
 

ChronicCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,844
Reaction score
14,310
Only one that matters is Moss. We’d have at least 1 more Super Bowl if we had drafted him. We ended up wasting 3 high draft picks trying to replace Irvin with the Galloway and McKnight trades when we could have just drafted Moss.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
No, you @BAT and @DB_Cooper are wrong...

"
Dallas CowboysEdit
Smith was selected by the Dallas Cowboys in the second round (36th overall) of the 1992 NFL Draft. He missed the first four games after he broke his right fibula during the Dallas Blue-White Scrimmage on July 19. After missing ample time during the season, he was listed as the fourth wide receiver on the Dallas Cowboys' depth chart, behind Michael Irvin, Alvin Harper, and Kelvin Martin. On October 11, he made his professional regular season debut during a 27–0 victory over the Seattle Seahawks. In a Week 16 matchup against the Atlanta Falcons, Smith had the highlight of his rookie year, tackling Deion Sanders during a punt return in a 41–17 victory. He played in just seven games as a special-teamer, without registering a reception. The Cowboys finished first in the NFC East, with a 13–3 record. On January 10, 1993, he appeared in his first career playoff game during the Cowboys' 34–10 win over the Philadelphia Eagles, playing on special teams. Smith earned the first ring of his career as a rookie, after the Cowboys went on to Super Bowl XXVII and defeated the Buffalo Bills 52–17.

In 1993, he was leading the team in pre-season (13) and receiving yards (197), while competing for the role as the third wide receiver that was left open with the departure in free agency of Kelvin Martin, behind Irvin and Harper. On August 21, Smith began feeling a pain in his abdominal area and brought it to the attention of two trainers and the team doctor, J.D. Zamarano, and was given Pepto Bismol, Maalox, and Tagamet. He played in the next preseason game and caught a touchdown reception, and was waved back in by a coach after taking himself out from taking a hit to the abdominal area that worsened the pain. Over the next few days, he repeatedly brought the pain to the attention of the trainers and wasn't given adequate care or the correct diagnosis. He asked to be directed to a doctor and was told to see the team doctor who gave him a checkup and took him to see the team surgeon, who finally diagnosed him with appendicitis. On August 24, 1993, he underwent an emergency appendectomy. The following day, the surgeon released him from the hospital, notwithstanding a 102.5 °F (39.2 °C) fever. On August 27, Smith was readmitted to the hospital after waking up in severe pain, vomiting and with a bloated stomach, because of a severe post-surgical infection that was nearly fatal. He went into emergency surgery for an ileostomy, in which a portion of his intestine was dissected and removed, with an external bag then fitted to collect his fecal matter, forcing Smith to miss the entire season, including Super Bowl XXVIII.[2] On October 2, the Cowboys placed him on the non-football illness list and opted not to pay his entire $350,000 salary for the 1993 season, as well as his insurance, pension, and free agent credits, instead making Smith an offer of $100,000 and no credits, which he declined.[3] The NFL Players Association filed a grievance with the Cowboys on Smith's behalf, alleging that he was due his full salary, which he won after going through arbitration.[4]

On July 11, 1994, he was waived after refusing to take a pay cut.

Philadelphia EaglesEdit
On July 19, 1994, he was signed as a free agent by the Philadelphia Eagles but was eventually released on August 30.[5]

Jacksonville JaguarsEdit
On February 28, 1995, Smith was signed by the expansion Jacksonville Jaguars after a tryout.[6] He made the team after head coach Tom Coughlin saw his talents.[7] He competed with Desmond Howard, Ernest Givens, Willie Jackson, Cedric Tillman, and Curtis Marsh throughout training camp for a job as a starting wide receiver. Head coach Tom Coughlin named him the fifth wide receiver on the depth chart behind Howard, Givens, Jackson, and Tillman. He finished the season leading the Jaguars in kickoff returns.

The next year, he became a starter after Andre Rison was released following the 11th game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. He would emerge as a dominant receiver..."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Smith_(wide_receiver)

As you can see, the NFL said it correctly...as did I. Jimmy Smith was cut "waived" by the Cowboys on July 11, 1994. The Eagles signed him days later on July 19, 1994, but they cut him a month later on August 30, 1994, thus Jimmy Smith never actually made it to a Regular Season to legally ever be considered a Philadelphia Eagle. Jimmy had to wait until February of 1995 until the Jacksonville Jaguars came around and offered him a job. The rest was history...

PS: What a terrible and ****** thing Jerry and the Cowboys front office did to treat Jimmy Smith that way due to an bad appendix that required emergency surgery. That was cold blood awful and so wrong. Karma came back and definitely bit then in the arse. Jimmy Smith made sure of that.

Not "legally" a Philadelphia Eagle?

May not have played a season with Eagles but he was signed and cut by the Eagles, between being drafted and cut by Cowboys then signing with Jags.

Legal or not.
 

America's Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
33,205
Reaction score
46,696
Not "legally" a Philadelphia Eagle?

May not have played a season with Eagles but he was signed and cut by the Eagles, between being drafted and cut by Cowboys then signing with Jags.

Legal or not.
No stats or even 1 game collected in 1994 as a Philadelphia Eagle, thus not an Eagle. Never made it to their actual 53 man roster or even their practice squad. What is so hard to understand about that?
 

HowardC

Romo was elite
Messages
3,953
Reaction score
5,461
At first it looked like a fine decision. After Julius Jones came back from injury, midway through the season, he came firing out of the gate. He looked like the real deal (IMO). Then he suddenly just fell off a cliff the next season and never did seem to find his stride again, unfortunately.
It was crazy how quickly he went from stud to dud.
 

HowardC

Romo was elite
Messages
3,953
Reaction score
5,461
Drafting Gavin Escobar 15 picks before Travis Kelce.

Also imagine if we had Fletcher Cox all these years.
This. I was SOOOOO angry when they traded up to get that BUM claibust. Fletcher Cox was right there waiting. They could've had Cox and Wagner, 2 All-Pros but picked a guy who scored single digits on the Wonderlic and shows up injured to camp.
 

Brax

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,476
Reaction score
7,190
In 2005, we drafted Demarcus Ware over Aaron Rodgers.

Obviously Ware was an awesome player. But to see how things would have been with Rodgers at QB would be very interesting.
They could of drafted Ware and Rodgers instead some guy named Speers was drafted.
 

jujoboys

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,591
Reaction score
2,846
1. Randy Moss WR
Dallas still had the triplets in their prime, a very good offensive line and a not too shabby defense. Maybe Deion sticks around a little longer too so the secondary doesn't fall apart either. I honestly think we challenge for a ring the next 3 seasons with Moss who was such a game changer. Honestly in his prime he was by far the greatest WR.

2. Chris Johnson RB
Another generational talent. You put this guy behind Romo and on the field with Owens and Austin look out!. His speed wouldve been perfect for Dallas and I think we wouldve been way better from 2008-2012ish. We had some great teams that wouldve taken the next step with adding CJ and minus Felix.

Do you have any like mine where at the time you knew they drafted the wrong guy and left a game/team changer on the board?

When we drafted Jaylon Smith instead of Chris Jones. I was screaming for Chris Jones when we were on the clock.
 

RonWashington

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,981
Reaction score
6,425
2017 - TJ Watt

GOt some bum named taco charlton instead

2012 - Luke Kuechly, we got Mo Claiborne



Guys like Brady James & Witten and I believe UDFA from Eastern Illinois Romo all came on when Parcells got here. I can’t help but think if Parcells hand picked his own replacement on the field then went upstairs as the man in charge we might have SB trophy 6 in the glass case.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
Guys like Brady James & Witten and I believe UDFA from Eastern Illinois Romo all came on when Parcells got here. I can’t help but think if Parcells hand picked his own replacement on the field then went upstairs as the man in charge we might have SB trophy 6 in the glass case.

Sean Payton is reason Romo was a Cowboy, he stood on the table for him.
 

ghosttown cowboy

Wyoming's #1 boys fan
Messages
1,438
Reaction score
859
Passed up on:

WR Jimmy Smith (drafted 36th spot (2nd round) by Cowboys in 1992, cut him in 1994) picked up by Jaguars, became one of the NFL's best WRs ever (top 24 all time in yards receiving, higher than Michael Irvin).
LB Derrick Brooks
WR Randy Moss
RB Priest Holmes (no one even drafted him through 7 rounds)
RB Steven Jackson
DT JJ Watt
LB Bobby Wagner
LB Luke Kuechly
LB/Edge TJ Watt

I remember the board melting down when we passed on Steven Jackson and picked up Julius Jones instead...
 
Top