News: BTB: Cowboys Stephen Jones Recognizes Pass Rush Deficiency, Could They Spend Big In Free...

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I completely disagree with Halprin here.

I think he's way off base. First, I don't think either of the top two names he mentions, Olivier Vernon or Malik Jackson are legitimate options for Dallas anyway. I fully expect Vernon to re-up or be franchise tagged by Miami, and Jackson has already been offered $10 million per year from Denver! Anyone think Dallas could or would compete with that for an interior defensive lineman?

And Bruce Irvin is a 245 lb role player for the Seahawks who averages about 5.5 sacks a year! Is that the guy you want to pony up for in free agency???

The more I look at any of these supposed 'alternatives', the more it makes me want to stick with 'the devil I know' in Greg Hardy.
 

LittleD

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,848
Reaction score
6,086
I completely disagree with Halprin here.

I think he's way off base. First, I don't think either of the top two names he mentions, Olivier Vernon or Malik Jackson are legitimate options for Dallas anyway. I fully expect Vernon to re-up or be franchise tagged by Miami, and Jackson has already been offered $10 million per year from Denver! Anyone think Dallas could or would compete with that for an interior defensive lineman?

And Bruce Irvin is a 245 lb role player for the Seahawks who averages about 5.5 sacks a year! Is that the guy you want to pony up for in free agency???

The more I look at any of these supposed 'alternatives', the more it makes me want to stick with 'the devil I know' in Greg Hardy.

I would take Super Mario in a heartbeat over Hardy...Har...Har...!
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I would take Super Mario in a heartbeat over Hardy...Har...Har...!

You do that! And get ready to pay roughly double the price.

For a guy who is 31 compared to Hardy's 27 who had less sacks, despite playing in 15 games to Hardy's 12.

We know where your opinion comes from and it has nothing to do with on-field performance.
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
I completely disagree with Halprin here.

I think he's way off base. First, I don't think either of the top two names he mentions, Olivier Vernon or Malik Jackson are legitimate options for Dallas anyway. I fully expect Vernon to re-up or be franchise tagged by Miami, and Jackson has already been offered $10 million per year from Denver! Anyone think Dallas could or would compete with that for an interior defensive lineman?

And Bruce Irvin is a 245 lb role player for the Seahawks who averages about 5.5 sacks a year! Is that the guy you want to pony up for in free agency???

The more I look at any of these supposed 'alternatives', the more it makes me want to stick with 'the devil I know' in Greg Hardy.

Vernon is the only FA DE the Cowboys should be considering but, I agree, he probably will be franchised. The guy is legit, though, and could help the Cowboy immensely.
 

LittleD

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,848
Reaction score
6,086
You do that! And get ready to pay roughly double the price.

For a guy who is 31 compared to Hardy's 27 who had less sacks, despite playing in 15 games to Hardy's 12.

We know where your opinion comes from and it has nothing to do with on-field performance.

True...True. With Mario and Bosa on board and moving DL to the other side, we will fare well enough.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Vernon is the only FA DE the Cowboys should be considering but, I agree, he probably will be franchised. The guy is legit, though, and could help the Cowboy immensely.

But he would cost an absolute fortune too, even if he was available. Defensive tackles are getting $10 million right now, even average ones! The top defensive end in free agency would likely command $15 million per year or more. I don't see this team being able to afford that.
 

superonyx

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,478
Reaction score
15,836
Our pass rush issues are not that different from our offensive issues. We have a scheme that relies on winning one on one match ups in order to succeed. It wouldn't matter if we had the best 2 DE's in the entire league over the last 20 years. The League is too good. Teams will just leave a guy back to double and neutralize them anyway. The reason Denver and Carolina and Seattle get so much pressure on the QB isn't because these teams have the best pass rushers. It's because they have coaches that put guys in position to succeed. Von Miller would probably end up with 6 sacks on this team. We would line him up at DE and tell him to go win the one on one matchup. Denver knows when and how to send him and how to disguise the pressure so the Offense doesn't know who is coming and when it's coming.

This strategy to line up and win one on one match ups will never allow us to have the type of defense Jerry and Co want.
 

LittleD

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,848
Reaction score
6,086
Ugh! Bosa! Insult to injury! Not only do you want to overpay a declining player in Williams, now you want to waste the #4 overall pick and an opportunity at a quarterback of the future for a lesser player!

Just...no.

That's right. I don't see any way we spend a #4 on someone who will sit for at least 2 years. Makes no sense when
you want to get Romo & Witten to a championship game. I don't think Stephen will want to do that either. Garrett
is going to want a player on the field cause this might be his last campaign.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Our pass rush issues are not that different from our offensive issues. We have a scheme that relies on winning one on one match ups in order to succeed. It wouldn't matter if we had the best 2 DE's in the entire league over the last 20 years. The League is too good. Teams will just leave a guy back to double and neutralize them anyway. The reason Denver and Carolina and Seattle get so much pressure on the QB isn't because these teams have the best pass rushers. It's because they have coaches that put guys in position to succeed. Von Miller would probably end up with 6 sacks on this team. We would line him up at DE and tell him to go win the one on one matchup. Denver knows when and how to send him and how to disguise the pressure so the Offense doesn't know who is coming and when it's coming.

This strategy to line up and win one on one match ups will never allow us to have the type of defense Jerry and Co want.

Yep. Carolina can somehow lose an obvious talent in Greg Hardy and still finish 6th in the league with 44 sacks while Dallas can add Hardy and Gregory, and get an improved Demarcus Lawrence and still muster only 31 sacks, good for 25th in the league.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,664
Reaction score
86,203
I completely disagree with Halprin here.

I think he's way off base. First, I don't think either of the top two names he mentions, Olivier Vernon or Malik Jackson are legitimate options for Dallas anyway. I fully expect Vernon to re-up or be franchise tagged by Miami, and Jackson has already been offered $10 million per year from Denver! Anyone think Dallas could or would compete with that for an interior defensive lineman?

And Bruce Irvin is a 245 lb role player for the Seahawks who averages about 5.5 sacks a year! Is that the guy you want to pony up for in free agency???

The more I look at any of these supposed 'alternatives', the more it makes me want to stick with 'the devil I know' in Greg Hardy.


I agree. Greg Hardy is the guy if he comes at a value price.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,664
Reaction score
86,203
Ugh! Bosa! Insult to injury! Not only do you want to overpay a declining player in Williams, now you want to waste the #4 overall pick and an opportunity at a quarterback of the future for a lesser player!

Just...no.


I think if they want to move Lawrence to Right End then they may look at Bosa more :(.
 

LittleD

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,848
Reaction score
6,086
Ugh! Bosa! Insult to injury! Not only do you want to overpay a declining player in Williams, now you want to waste the #4 overall pick and an opportunity at a quarterback of the future for a lesser player!

Just...no.

That's what everyone said about Jared Allen & Demarcus Ware before they had pretty good seasons too?
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
That's right. I don't see any way we spend a #4 on someone who will sit for at least 2 years. Makes no sense when
you want to get Romo & Witten to a championship game. I don't think Stephen will want to do that either.

No, what "makes no sense" is naively thinking that any player you get at #4 will do that. It's this same 'one player', 'quick fix' mentality that keeps this team spinning its' wheels at .500 for the past 5 years.

Garrett
is going to want a player on the field cause this might be his last campaign.

If that's the case, fire him now because he's putting his own self interests ahead of what's in the best long-term interests for the organization. Any front office person who would put themselves ahead of the team shouldn't be here and any coach willing to make decisions based on that needs to go.
 

LittleD

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,848
Reaction score
6,086
No, what "makes no sense" is naively thinking that any player you get at #4 will do that. It's this same 'one player', 'quick fix' mentality that keeps this team spinning its' wheels at .500 for the past 5 years.



If that's the case, fire him now because he's putting his own self interests ahead of what's in the best long-term interests for the organization. Any front office person who would put themselves ahead of the team shouldn't be here and any coach willing to make decisions based on that needs to go.

Jerry, himself, has said it many times... He's going all in to get Romo and Witten to a championship.
That sounds like this is a short time horizon play and Jerry wants one more day in the sunshine.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
That's what everyone said about Jared Allen & Demarcus Ware before they had pretty good seasons too?
That's what everyone said about Jared Allen & Demarcus Ware before they had pretty good seasons too?

So 2 sacks and being traded for a bag of chips is a "pretty good season" for Jared Allen? Even he knew he was finished and retired as soon as he could. And nobody was saying Ware was no longer a good player.

You should stop burying yourself any further and move on.
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
But he would cost an absolute fortune too, even if he was available. Defensive tackles are getting $10 million right now, even average ones! The top defensive end in free agency would likely command $15 million per year or more. I don't see this team being able to afford that.

I agree. This is why I think FA is not a real option, specifically to fill the need at DE. Like it or not, I think Jerry will sell out and go d-lineman at #4 and #34 and hope they can get four quality starters on the field at one time.
 
Top