Cowboys Free Agency Situation not dire, but not pretty

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
The Cowboys linebacker situation going into the offseason looked like it could become a strength of this team.

I think we all figured Carter would be a hard re-sign, and he was. Tampa gave him 4 years, 5 million per year, a lot more than he was worth/earned.

Durant also got a lot more than expected. I wouldn't have paid Durant more than 2 million a year, and Atlanta gave him 3.6 million per year. Simply weren't going to over pay for him.

Unfortunately these two situations have put us in a very precarious situation. We haven't re-sign McClain yet, and at the moment we have an injury prone Sean Lee and a sophomore Hitchens.... That isn't a good place to be right now, and it looks like re-signing McClain will probably cost us 5-6 million per year. They really should have re-signed Durant during the year while he was injured. Surprised that he made that much of an impression with Atlanta in the small amount of time he played this year. I think both Atlanta and Tampa will regret their decisions, but that doesn't help us much.

We're now in a position where linebacker is likely a weakness, and unfortunately this also stems from the Dez Bryant situation. A situation I knew was going to be difficult, but if they were going to be this difficult the Cowboys should have made plans to trade him. No way they should have a short commitment with him with the franchise tag. Makes no sense cap wise or future wise. It prevents us from being competitive this year, and doesn't help us be competitive in the future. It does us no favors.

With the amount of holes that we have on this team, defense in particular, we have to be a lot more aggressive than this. And this would have been a great year to show up in the NFC. We'll be lucky if we can come out of this with Lee-McClain-Hitchens now. Carr hasn't taken a pay cut, and yet we didn't make a move to get Cromartie who was willing to come for pretty cheap (according to reports, 6 million per year). Surprised we haven't reached out to Tillman either.

We've done nothing to make one of the worst defensive lines in the NFL even close to manageable, and anyone who thinks we'll get away with just drafting some linemen has fooled themselves.

If we downgrade from Murray to Spiller and we don't make significant investments on the defensive side of the ball in free agency, we shouldn't expect this team to go much further in the playoffs than they did last year. And worse, we'll be in an even worse position next year with Romo a year older, and Dez likely a free agent unless we tag him two years in a row, which will ultimately hurt our salary cap next year....

It's still early, but so far this has been a mismanaged off season, starting mostly with not re-signing any players during the regular season.

People are looking at it wrong if you ask me. The bad contracts are not the overpays, they are bad players. A bad contract can be a 10m player like Carr, a 5m player or a 1m player or a draft pick. If Durant was our best choice at LB, is 3.6m really too much? Same with Carter.

Murray earned way more than 8m last year. If he is our best choice at RB just pay him. I think the FO is trying to get too cute with these deals. Not every contract has to be a steal. It's about picking the right players. Just like the draft. Sometimes its better to trade back and get TFred and sometimes its better to trade up and get DLaw.
 

BrAinPaiNt

Mike Smith aka Backwoods Sexy
Staff member
Messages
78,651
Reaction score
42,990
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
SPEND IT JERRY !!!
PMPwpWrGFLu80.gif

LOL
 

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"
Staff member
Messages
47,997
Reaction score
27,917
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Carter played in 13 games plus the playoffs. He lost some snaps early in the season when they were experimenting with where to play him. It isn't fair grouping Carter and Durant and comparing them to one player. Carter played a pretty full season last year. So did McClain (13 regular season games but nicked up in the playoffs) and Hitchens (fully healthy in all 18 games). Yeah, most of our injuries were with Durant and Lee. And McClain had to shake some rust off since we just picked him up off the street.

I wouldn't have resigned Durant either. He's nearing 30, has never played a full season, and has a pretty low ceiling. Carter's ceiling is much higher, he's younger, and he's been healthier. Carter's issues had to do with adjusting to a new defense and issues with the coaching staff not trusting his ability to process/read a play. I think McClain will be much better next year after shaking the rust off this year. McClain is really a gem. Supremely athletic, high football IQ, passionate when on the field, and a great talent. There's a reason he was so highly regarded coming out of college. He has All Pro potential. Just like Sean Lee. Carter has more Pro Bowl potential. But McClain also has issues. He's got a few screws lose. He can lose it at any minute.

Carter played 500 snaps.

I like Carter, but he ain't worth $5 mil per season.
 

Galian Beast

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
7,457
People are looking at it wrong if you ask me. The bad contracts are not the overpays, they are bad players. A bad contract can be a 10m player like Carr, a 5m player or a 1m player or a draft pick. If Durant was our best choice at LB, is 3.6m really too much? Same with Carter.

Murray earned way more than 8m last year. If he is our best choice at RB just pay him. I think the FO is trying to get too cute with these deals. Not every contract has to be a steal. It's about picking the right players. Just like the draft. Sometimes its better to trade back and get TFred and sometimes its better to trade up and get DLaw.

I'd rather slightly over pay a guy than settle for the same defense we have. I don't think people realize how bad it was, and that we just lost 2 of the best players from that defense, and about to lose a third.

I love how people resort to straw man arguments. There is a difference between not signing big name guys and signing no one.

As of right now the offense and defense have both gotten worse, and the draft isn't going to put us over the top. That's an issue.

As for last year, people were right to flip out over the lack of investment in the defensive line, as it certainly cost us the playoff game against Green Bay. Relying on Mincey and Lawrence was a poor bet, and it didn't pay off. Mincey was a nice depth signing, but he shouldn't have been a starter, at least not on the weak side.

We've kept our secondary entirely the way it was too, which is unthinkable. Carr not taking a pre opening day pay cut, must mean he is getting cut at the Cowboy's convenience, but the lack of a replacement for him is questionable.
 

kTXe

On To The Next One
Messages
1,546
Reaction score
94
Carter wasn't even a full time starter last year....

He also didn't retire midway through his rookie deal and make numerous off-the-field blunders. Carter also ended the year on a high note while McClain was repeatedly banged up. I just don't see someone giving McClain a Carter-type deal given serious concerns about McClain's long-term reliability. I also get the sense that McClain would love to stay in Dallas and perhaps give us a bit of a discount.
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
I'd rather slightly over pay a guy than settle for the same defense we have. I don't think people realize how bad it was, and that we just lost 2 of the best players from that defense, and about to lose a third.

I love how people resort to straw man arguments. There is a difference between not signing big name guys and signing no one.

As of right now the offense and defense have both gotten worse, and the draft isn't going to put us over the top. That's an issue.

As for last year, people were right to flip out over the lack of investment in the defensive line, as it certainly cost us the playoff game against Green Bay. Relying on Mincey and Lawrence was a poor bet, and it didn't pay off. Mincey was a nice depth signing, but he shouldn't have been a starter, at least not on the weak side.

We've kept our secondary entirely the way it was too, which is unthinkable. Carr not taking a pre opening day pay cut, must mean he is getting cut at the Cowboy's convenience, but the lack of a replacement for him is questionable.

We aren't even being mentioned in most of these deals. We may be doing work behind the scenes, but it appears that we just passing on a lot of talent because of the cost. All these other teams can't be completely wrong in their evaluations.
 

Galian Beast

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
7,457
What a lot of people still don't realize is that to compete this year, it will take a lot more than the draft. Seattle built their super bowl through the draft and free agency.
 

Silver N Blue

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,342
Reaction score
8,982
Don't panic, it isn't any worse than last year at this same time. Ware gone, Hatcher gone, LB position still looked bleak, even with Lee healthy. Durant coming off injuries, DL worse shape than it is now.
romo back totally up in the air after surgery. OL still had ??? Marks except LT & C.

People whining about Garrett and the coaching staff, Callahan and Kiffin, then Marinelli and
Linehan....yes they whined a lot.

We were in salary cap hell as usual according to many. We didn't signed anyone day one. People whined about Mo & Carr at CB as well as Church & Wilcox a S.

as someone said during last season....R.E.L.A.X.

Last year the team was 8-8 not 12-4 expectations should be higher from the fan base all the way to JJ so some disappointment is warranted IMO..I didn't expect a big name but someone in the 3-5 spot ranking at dl, DT, cb, s, and lb would be nice by now.
 

Risen Star

Likes Collector
Messages
89,411
Reaction score
212,318
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I think Carter has more of a chance to be worth his contract than Durant. Who was vastly overrated by this fan base.

Carter, when he's right, is a very good player.
 

Galian Beast

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
7,457
I think Carter has more of a chance to be worth his contract than Durant. Who was vastly overrated by this fan base.

Carter, when he's right, is a very good player.

Carter is wildly inconsistent. That's why I would have paid him about 3 million a year, maybe 3.5.... but 5 million a year? Nope... Durant will at the very least have to stay healthy to warrant his contract. That's a big question. Not sure why they bit that hard on him.
 

Galian Beast

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
7,457
Not starters yet but solid contributors. Our depth has taken major hits..

Our depth? We have 1 confirmed starter from our linebacker corps, and he has injury concerns.... The next "Starter" is a sophomore. That isn't a good situation to be in.
 

mmohican29

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,481
Reaction score
6,401
[quotewasn'tboyvic, post: 6014047, member: 22796"]Yep. you 100% get it man.[/quote]

No it wasn't.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,193
Reaction score
64,699
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I think Carter has more of a chance to be worth his contract than Durant. Who was vastly overrated by this fan base.

Carter, when he's right, is a very good player.
He was a non-starter in weeks 12 through 16 while Hitchens was a starter.

The Cowboys could not pay him 5M per to backup Hitchens.
 
Top