Current top 10 qbs in order

[Howboutdemcowboys31]

Bored on the bye week. Sorry if I offend the Romo haters.

1- Peyton Manning
2- Andrew Rodgers
3- Drew Brees
4- Tom Brady
5- Andrew Luck
6- Tony Romo
7- Russel Wilson
8- Mathew Stafford
9- Phillip Rivers
10- Big Ben

 

[JoeyBoy718]

I think you missed the thread about his 3rd down rating this season. Haha #6? And Tom Brady has like a 70 passer rating this season with a 50% completion percentage. Are you talking about this season or all-time?

 

[Howboutdemcowboys31]

I think you missed the thread about his 3rd down rating this season. Haha #6? And Tom Brady has like a 70 passer rating this season with a 50% completion percentage. Are you talking about this season or all-time?

The order I would want them on my team starting week 11. I know Brady has had a meh year but I still trust him more than anyone under his name

 

[JoeyBoy718]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Drew Brees
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Tom Brady
5. Phillip Rivers
6. Andrew Luck
7. Russell Wilson
8. Cam Newton
9. Matthew Stafford
10. Tony Romo

 

[dstovall5]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Drew Brees
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Tom Brady
5. Phillip Rivers
6. Andrew Luck
7. Russell Wilson
8. Cam Newton
9. Matthew Stafford
10. Tony Romo

For this year? Lol.

 

[JoeyBoy718]

For this year? Lol.

How is that funny?

Peyton is 8-1 with a 121.0 passer rating.
Brees is 7-2 with a 108.9 pr.
Rodgers is 5-3 (or is it 5-2?) with a 108.0 pr.
Brady is 7-2 with a 82.7 pr.
Rivers is 4-5 (in the best division in football) with a 105.9 pr.
Luck is 7-3 (and beat the Broncos, 49ers, Seahawks) with a 87.0 pr.
Wilson is 9-1 with a 101.8 pr.
Newton is 6-3 with a 88.3 pr.
Stafford is 6-3 with a 94.1 pr.

 

[dstovall5]

How is that funny?

Peyton is 8-1 with a 121.0 passer rating.
Brees is 7-2 with a 108.9 pr.
Rodgers is 5-3 (or is it 5-2?) with a 108.0 pr.
Brady is 7-2 with a 82.7 pr.
Rivers is 4-5 (in the best division in football) with a 105.9 pr.
Luck is 7-3 (and beat the Broncos, 49ers, Seahawks) with a 87.0 pr.
Wilson is 9-1 with a 101.8 pr.
Newton is 6-3 with a 88.3 pr.
Stafford is 6-3 with a 94.1 pr.

I'ved watched Brady quiet a bit this year, and he's been very inaccurate. Yes his inexperienced WRs have some to do with that, but he is missing throws he usually makes. Top 10? Maybe, but definitely not top 4.

As for Wilson/Newton those guys are basically game managers (nothing wrong that) and are protected by their coaches, running game, and stellar defense. I just think they're overrated is all. Also, if you think Romo can be inaccurate at times, you should watch some of Luck's recent games, talk about missing wide open WRs.

Not a bad list though, all those guys are still very good QBs.

 

[JoeyBoy718]

I'ved watched Brady quiet a bit this year, and he's been very inaccurate. Yes his inexperienced WRs have some to do with that, but he is missing throws he usually makes. Top 10? Maybe, but definitely not top 4.

As for Wilson/Newton those guys are basically game managers (nothing wrong that) and are protected by their coaches, running game, and stellar defense. I just think they're overrated is all. Also, if you think Romo can be inaccurate at times, you should watch some of Luck's recent games, talk about missing wide open WRs.

Not a bad list though, all those guys are still very good QBs.

I kinda agree with you about Wilson. Anyone with a 101.8 passer rating on a 9-1 would usually be at the top of my list. But he does have the benefit of a great team, running game, defense, coach. However, I can't totally agree on Newton. He had one of the greatest rookie seasons of all time on a team that had absolutely no one. He had a slight sophomore (but not really) and he was overshadowed by the rookie class of Luck, RG3, Wilson (and if you want to include Kaepernick). But Newton has been putting up monster numbers since he came on the league. And his team isn't nearly as talented as Wilson's. Newton has been slept on since the end of his rookie year.

 

[Howboutdemcowboys31]

Me I don't trust killa Cam and his horrible attitude-ego

 

[theSHOW]

nfc east rank

Romo
Foles
Griffen
Manning

 

[HappyOnions]

If we're talking who I would want on this team RIGHT NOW...

1. Aaron Rodgers (healthy)
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Tom Brady
5. Andrew Luck
6. Cam Newton
7. Matt Stafford
8. Russell Wilson
9. Alex Smith
10. Eli Manning (He'll throw jump balls to Dez all day without hesitation)

Throw all the stats out the window, Romo is not playing good football right now. Way too conservative, and way too inaccurate.

 

[DFWJC]

How is that funny?

Peyton is 8-1 with a 121.0 passer rating.
Brees is 7-2 with a 108.9 pr.
Rodgers is 5-3 (or is it 5-2?) with a 108.0 pr.
Brady is 7-2 with a 82.7 pr.
Rivers is 4-5 (in the best division in football) with a 105.9 pr.
Luck is 7-3 (and beat the Broncos, 49ers, Seahawks) with a 87.0 pr.
Wilson is 9-1 with a 101.8 pr.
Newton is 6-3 with a 88.3 pr.
Stafford is 6-3 with a 94.1 pr.

Just an FYI,
Newton is not 6-3, his team is....this is not golf

 

[DFWJC]

If we're talking who I would want on this team RIGHT NOW...

1. Aaron Rodgers (healthy)
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Tom Brady
5. Andrew Luck
6. Cam Newton
7. Matt Stafford
8. Russell Wilson
9. Alex Smith
10. Eli Manning (He'll throw jump balls to Dez all day without hesitation)

Throw all the stats out the window, Romo is not playing good football right now. Way too conservative, and way too inaccurate.

This right now, this season.
Eli Manning is not even top 20

 

[dstovall5]

If we're going by which QB has performed better overall this year, then I'd go -

1.) Peyton Manning (Having the greatest QB season in NFL history)
-
-
2.) Drew Brees (Throws a mean deep ball)
3.) Aaron Rodgers (Arrogant, but still great)
-
4.) Philip Rivers (He's back ... for now)
-
5.) Mathew Stafford (A cannon arm + the best WR in the NFL = dangerous)
6.) Tony Romo (Having a great year besides the NO/WAS game - people over react)
-
-
7.) Andrew Luck (The best passer out of the young-ins, and he's also very stocky/durable)
8.) Russel Wilson (Game manager, though young and coming on strong)
9.) Ben Roethlisberger (He's currently getting the Romo treatment from his supporting cast)
10.) Tom Brady (Has been dealing with inexperienced WRs/accuracy problems, but still Brady)
10a.) Matt Ryan (Losing Steven Jackson, Julio Jones, and Roddy White must suck, I feel your pain)
10b.) Cam Newton (Game manager, though young and coming on strong as well)
10c.) Andy Dalton ( An inconsistent passer, but he still has great potential and is playing well)

I'm sure a lot will disagree with my list, especially where Romo is ranked, but ohh well.

 

[zack]

If we're talking who I would want on this team RIGHT NOW...

1. Aaron Rodgers (healthy)
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Tom Brady
5. Andrew Luck
6. Cam Newton
7. Matt Stafford
8. Russell Wilson
9. Alex Smith
10. Eli Manning (He'll throw jump balls to Dez all day without hesitation)

Throw all the stats out the window, Romo is not playing good football right now. Way too conservative, and way too inaccurate.

You mean Eli will throw jump balls to the other team more often than he will to Dez.

I don't get the Cam love at all. He is wildly inaccurate. If you watched the game against SF, he was throwing the ball high and all over the place. Plus the guy is a baby, drama queen.

 

[JoeyBoy718]

Just an FYI,
Newton is not 6-3, his team is....this is not golf

But Russell Wilson is 9-1?

 

[DFWJC]

But Russell Wilson is 9-1?

All of them...I just picked one

 

[hra8700]

Tier 1:
Manning
Brees
Rodgers
Brady

Tier 2:
Rivers
Luck
Stafford
Rothlisberger

Tier 3:
Ryan
Romo
Eli
Flacco

Tier 4:
Cutler
Russel wilson
Rg3
Kaepernick

 

[JoeyBoy718]

All of them...I just picked one

I just found it funny you singled out Newton. Okay, if you're saying it goes for all of them, I can agree with you.

 

[hra8700]

Tier 1:
Manning
Brees
Rodgers
Brady

Tier 2:
Rivers
Luck
Stafford
Rothlisberger

Tier 3:
Ryan
Romo
Eli
Flacco

Tier 4:
Cutler
Russel wilson
Rg3
Kaepernick

Sorry, stafford should be in tier 3 along with maybe cutler too