Dallas Cowboys are NFL’s Version of New York Yankees

Gryphon

Merge Ahead
Messages
3,407
Reaction score
31
by Ben Grimaldi

Truth be told, I’m a New York Yankees and a Dallas Cowboys fan. It’s why I can examine both teams and reach the reasonable conclusion that both teams have very similar characteristics and say the Cowboys are the NFL’s version of the Yankees.

The obvious thing they have in common is that both teams are among the most hated in their respective sport. No teams are loved, or hated, more than the Cowboys and Yankees, but that’s not the point I’m going to make.

Both teams, the Cowboys and Yankees, are linked by the way they have constructed their teams recently. The Yankees have held onto a few of their core players, despite their age, and have overpaid for a many of their current stars. The Yankees have also chosen to play with the players they have succeeded with in the past rather than move on with new players. Much of that has to do with their limited salary restraints of the past few seasons and New York is trying to avoid paying too much in luxury tax.

Does any of that sound familiar to Cowboys fans? Dallas has been limited this offseason by what they can do because of the salary cap and they have continued to move forward with older players, rather than rebuild. Looking at the Cowboys, they gave new contracts to Tony Romo, Jason Witten and Jay Ratliff into their 30′s, and could possibly be reaching a new deal with a player about to be 30 in Anthony Spencer.

The Cowboys have also overspent on plenty of their players, much like the Yankees have done with Alex Rodriguez, C.C. Sabathia, Mark Teixeira and others. For every A-Rod or Sabathia, there’s a Miles Austin or Jay Ratliff on the Cowboys roster. Both teams overspend to keep their players for fear of the unknown without them.

They are also alike in that both teams keep pushing the future a year or two at a time. The Yankees are operating like they just need to play out the next two years with their core of older players before their contracts run out so they can reload with their, or any other teams, young talent come 2015. By that time the Andy Pettitte’s, Derek Jeter’s and Ichiro’s of the Yankees will be gone and they will be bringing up young stars like Melky Mesa, Gary Sanchez and any other star on the free agent market.

The Cowboys are doing the same thing, just in a slightly different way. Dallas is trying to get the best they have out of their best players for the next few years before they have to move. It’s why Tony Romo’s contract is structured in a way for the Cowboys to continue to restructure his deal when the team needs to get more cap space. The Cowboys know in the NFL you can only go as far as your quarterback takes you and rather than rebuild with a new quarterback, the Cowboys are squeezing everything they can out of Romo, and this core group of Cowboys, before rebuilding the entire thing.

Read more at http://www.rantsports.com/nfl/2013/...sion-of-new-york-yankees/?1xXxS3Uyka0TmCqL.99
 

JBS

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,385
Reaction score
23,824
No. I don't agree.

Dumb article
 

Titleist

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,807
Reaction score
2,408
The Yankees consistently make the playoffs and are competitive in them. We don't do anything of that level. Bad comparison.
 

The Natural

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,205
Reaction score
18,969
Atleast Yankee fans under 23 have seen their team win something
 

Boyzmamacita

CowBabe Up!!!
Messages
29,047
Reaction score
64,100
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
The Yankees have had recent success. I wish the Cowboys were more like the Yankees in that way.
 

StarBoyz83

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,434
Reaction score
11,978
They are exactly the yankess when it comes to fans love and hate. But Yankees are always contenders and winners dallas is not.
 

Fizziksman

BanditHiro
Messages
5,126
Reaction score
3,523
i wish we were able to spend the kind of money the yanks do for players :(
 

muck4doo

Least-Known Member
Messages
3,877
Reaction score
2,190
Someone doesn't know the difference between the NFL and MLB.
 

erod

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,705
Reaction score
60,327
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
At this point, the Cowboys are more like the Dodgers or the Knicks.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,982
Reaction score
48,729
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
No salary cap in baseball.
The Yankees can spend howver they please. But they have worse contracts than Dallas does overall.
 

Nova

Ntegrase96
Messages
10,699
Reaction score
12,659
I think level of success is irrelevant for the comparison. The Packers have the most championships overall but no one is going to make that comparison because it just isn't even close... they are not nearly the polarizing figure the Yankees are.


Level of success for the Yankees cannot be compared to the Cowboys because of the difference in sports. Is there any doubt that the Cowboys would be in the playoffs every year if they were able to go out and drop huge contracts on the FAs like MLB allows.

Adrian Peterson would be our RB. Calvin Johnson would be our WR. So on and so forth. And the money would keep compounding because of the success.
 

FootballFan1

Member
Messages
307
Reaction score
15
The Yankees bought their team - and not always a success story.

In the NFL, we all live under the cap, which I support greatly.

No one should be able to "buy" a team, and then hope for the best.

I am glad we have the cap in the NFL, and allow all teams to succeed if given the right circumstances. Like that a bunch.

Who wins the SB next year?? Anyone can if they can get their act together. It is what makes the NFL the only sport (in my opinion) that is worthwhile watching.

Cap = equality, if you can get your act together. Liking that. And fairness.

Do not see the comparison here. All NFL teams live under the cap. It is what you do with that cap that makes the difference. The Yanks just buy their teams, sometimes without much success. Who won the World Series last year?? Honestly I do not even know, and could care less.
 

forever22

Member
Messages
369
Reaction score
0
I always made the comparison between Jerry J. and George S. They both have the passion and will to put the best team out there every year. No, a lot of owners don't, before you say it. There are teams who still have not been to the SB, after all these years. Be glad Jerry wasn't one who didn't try everything he could to put a championship team together. Yes, like George, his heart is bigger than his brain at times, but I'd rather that, than one who didn't try hard. How many Kraft's are out there?

I've always hated the phrase "buying" a team. What, the other teams players play for free? If it was such a big deal, then why isn't the highest paid team winning every year. They don't. One of the reasons they have the highest salary is because they have and had a lot of WS winners to pay for - you don't get them cheap. A lot of teams dump winning players and that's their choice. The Marlins dumped the whole team after they won. A lot of owners just pocketed the money, from the luxary tax, that they were supposed to use on players contracts. I see so many fans whine about it, yet there are no rules broken. Same was said about Jerry, in the beginning and with the Niners. I don't see any fans from those teams willing to give up the trophy's, because their team had more money to spend. Deal with it or buy your own team

Try and keep a team together after winning a couple SB's. If the players aren't under contract already, good luck. A few may restructure but don't count on that too often and that only buys you time. It's not like they are just giving up their money
 

cowboyfan4life2

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,207
Reaction score
3,429
forever22;5045332 said:
I always made the comparison between Jerry J. and George S. They both have the passion and will to put the best team out there every year. No, a lot of owners don't, before you say it. There are teams who still have not been to the SB, after all these years. Be glad Jerry wasn't one who didn't try everything he could to put a championship team together. Yes, like George, his heart is bigger than his brain at times, but I'd rather that, than one who didn't try hard. How many Kraft's are out there?

I've always hated the phrase "buying" a team. What, the other teams players play for free? If it was such a big deal, then why isn't the highest paid team winning every year. They don't. One of the reasons they have the highest salary is because they have and had a lot of WS winners to pay for - you don't get them cheap. A lot of teams dump winning players and that's their choice. The Marlins dumped the whole team after they won. A lot of owners just pocketed the money, from the luxary tax, that they were supposed to use on players contracts. I see so many fans whine about it, yet there are no rules broken. Same was said about Jerry, in the beginning and with the Niners. I don't see any fans from those teams willing to give up the trophy's, because their team had more money to spend. Deal with it or buy your own team

Try and keep a team together after winning a couple SB's. If the players aren't under contract already, good luck. A few may restructure but don't count on that too often and that only buys you time. It's not like they are just giving up their money


I really don't think jerry has anywhere near the passion to win that Steinbrenner had. Winning was second to breathing in steinbrenners mind, he would move heaven and earth to put a winning product on the field. If winning was so important to jerry, why is he sticking with a coach like garrett, when there are sb winning coaches out there? I think money is jerrys main concern, with winning coming 2nd.
 

IAmLegend

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,622
Reaction score
10,110
Except that the Yankees are actually good and competitive year in and year out.. Big difference. I'm a fan of both, but they couldn't be more different in that regard. They're only the same in the sense that they're the most popular team in their league, having both the most fans and the most haters. Similar to the Lakers in the NBA.
 

Ratmatt

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,024
Reaction score
124
C.C.Sabathia is the wrong guy to bring up in the argument.That guy has been nothing but good and dependable for the Yankees.
 

cowboyfan4life2

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,207
Reaction score
3,429
Ratmatt;5045363 said:
C.C.Sabathia is the wrong guy to bring up in the argument.That guy has been nothing but good and dependable for the Yankees.

He has been great, and texiera has been better than people give him credit for. A better example if you are looking to knock the yankees, are all of those questionable pitchers they brought in a few years ago. The carl pavanos, kevin brown and jarrett wright.
 

RastaRocket

Sanka, Ya Dead Mon? Ya Mon.
Messages
6,300
Reaction score
652
DFWJC;5045031 said:
No salary cap in baseball.
The Yankees can spend howver they please. But they have worse contracts than Dallas does overall.

Exactly. I think this article had some valid points but overall it really isn't comparable. Also, I feel like this team is finally developing a young core around Romo. Not so much for the Yankees. We have a pretty solid mix of veteran and youth core players with a lack of depth. But overall, we are getting younger.

Where is C&LF when you need the expert opinion of a Cowboys, Yankees, Lakers fan?
 

noshame

I'm not dead yet......
Messages
14,950
Reaction score
13,438
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
George and Jerry are similar, except George bought talent, Jerry buys.....:bang2:
 
Top