DMN: Ranking the Cowboys’ 53-man roster: Numbers 20-11

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Ranking the Cowboys’ 53-man roster: Numbers 20-11
http://0.gravatar.com/avatar/23c5110466ed7c234a985a645c542863?s=52&d=http%3A%2F%2Fres.***BANNED-URL***%2Fresources%2Fimages%2FSD-logo-50.jpg%3Fs%3D52&r=G
Jon Machota Email jmachota@***BANNED-URL***
Published: January 22, 2015 11:01 pm
http://cowboysblog.***BANNED-URL***/files/2015/01/461342654_41661011-1.jpg
Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images
Cowboys receiver Cole Beasley.


Only two installments remain. Here is the fourth part of my Cowboys roster rankings for the 2014 season, numbers 11-20.

20.) Doug Free, RT. As good as the Cowboys offensive line was in 2014, they were at their absolute best when Free was on the field. The leader in the offensive line room started 11 games and received positive grades for nine of them from the folks at Pro Football Focus.

19.) Henry Melton, DT. Melton bet on himself with the contract he signed a year ago. If he returned to his Pro Bowl form, the club could exercise their option, keeping him on the roster for the next three seasons. Melton played at a high level for roughly half the season, recording five sacks in 16 games. But did the Cowboys see enough to keep him around?

18.) J.J. Wilcox, S. Wilcox continued to show improvement in his second year, finishing with 74 tackles during the regular season, fourth-most on the team. He also intercepted a career-high three passes, most of any defensive back on the roster.

17.) Brandon Carr, CB. No Cowboy defender has been criticized more than Carr these last two seasons. But every game, Carr is out there defending the other team’s top wide receiver. Even though he finished without an interception for the first time in his career, he played some of his best ball down the stretch.

16.) Cole Beasley, WR. Beasley played his best football during the last six games and it carried over into the playoffs. The 5-8 receiver averaged nearly 50 yards per game to go along with four touchdowns during those final six contests. In the playoffs, he hauled in more passes than Dez Bryant.

15.) Anthony Hitchens, LB. No Cowboys draft pick was more criticized than when Dallas selected Hitchens in the fourth round. But the rookie looked like a good investment when Sean Lee went down. He now looks like a great investment after seeing how he became one of the team’s best defenders.

14.) Terrance Williams, WR. One of Williams’ best attributes is his patience. He was the forgotten man for six games. But when teams continued to double Dez Bryant, Williams made the most of his opportunities. There was no better example than the two playoff games. Williams caught four passes for 130 yards and three touchdowns.

13.) Barry Church, S. Like J.J. Wilcox, Church continues to improve at the other starting safety spot. He’ll probably never be the type of defensive back to intercept five or six passes in a season, but he’s always around the ball making plays.

12.) Rolando McClain, LB. If he would’ve stayed healthy, McClain probably would’ve cracked the top five. The defense just played on another level when McClain was right. It would be very interesting to see what a healthy McClain looked like next to a healthy Sean Lee next season.

11.) Dan Bailey, K. The most accurate kicker in NFL history was very good again for the Cowboys, converting 25 of his 29 field goal attempts during the season, which included a career-long 56-yarder. The only knock on Bailey was that he missed two of his three postseason attempts, one from 41 yards and the other from 50.

Cowboys coaching staff gets early look at free agents at Pro Bowl; three to consider
  • Bruce Carter among many linebacker questions the Cowboys face prior to NFL Draft
  • Focus on his rushes and you miss much of DeMarco Murray's value to Cowboys
  • Bob Sturm's 2015 NFL Draft profile: What I see in Alvin 'Bud' Dupree, DE/OLB, Kentucky

http://cowboysblog.***BANNED-URL***/2015/01/ranking-the-cowboys-53-man-roster-numbers-20-11.html/
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Click here for numbers 53-41.

Click here for numbers 40-31.

Click here for numbers 30-21.

Monday morning for numbers 1-10 @ DMN
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,901
Reaction score
112,897
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
17.) Brandon Carr, CB. No Cowboy defender has been criticized more than Carr these last two seasons. But every game, Carr is out there defending the other team’s top wide receiver. Even though he finished without an interception for the first time in his career, he played some of his best ball down the stretch.

Far to much credit being placed on "played some of his best ball down the stretch" for me. There is a reason for all the criticism the last 2 years and he was being paid to cover other teams #1. A lot of sugar coating trying to justify putting Carr at #17.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Far to much credit being placed on "played some of his best ball down the stretch" for me. There is a reason for all the criticism the last 2 years and he was being paid to cover other teams #1. A lot of sugar coating trying to justify putting Carr at #17.

Never been a Carr fan. I like him playing press coverage though. I think he can be upgraded.
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,901
Reaction score
112,897
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Never been a Carr fan. I like him playing press coverage though. I think he can be upgraded.

Loved him when he was in KC. Of course we get all those games here so I saw him play every week. I even mentioned how much I wish he were a Cowboy. When we signed him I thought we were in tall cotton. I KNOW he can be upgraded. Watching him chase WR's down the field each week gets damn old.
 

Clarkson

Wonderboyromo
Messages
2,677
Reaction score
1,599
I think we're going to be really good again next year. The defense may not be as hopeless as we think. It's possible at any time for Lee and/or Durant to have healthy seasons and some upgrades are going to come. Let's go.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,709
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Far to much credit being placed on "played some of his best ball down the stretch" for me. There is a reason for all the criticism the last 2 years and he was being paid to cover other teams #1. A lot of sugar coating trying to justify putting Carr at #17.

These types of rankings are always destined to fail.

Bernadeau at #50 might get offers to start with another team. Cam Lawrence at #40 might not even make the 53 on another team.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
These types of rankings are always destined to fail.

Bernadeau at #50 might get offers to start with another team. Cam Lawrence at #40 might not even make the 53 on another team.

Yeah. But anything Cowboys is good for the offseason.
 

JoeyBoy718

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,715
Reaction score
12,709
So who hasn't been mentioned yet?

Romo
Murray
Dez
Witten
Frederick
Smith
Martin
Crawford
Scandrick
Mincey

That's 10

My guess is:

10. Mincey
9. Witten
8. Crawford
7. Scandrick
6. Frederick
5. Smith
4. Murray
3. Bryant
2. Martin
1. Romo
 

pacboyX

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,032
Reaction score
780
Ranking the Cowboys’ 53-man roster: Numbers 20-11
http://0.gravatar.com/avatar/23c5110466ed7c234a985a645c542863?s=52&d=http%3A%2F%2Fres.***BANNED-URL***%2Fresources%2Fimages%2FSD-logo-50.jpg%3Fs%3D52&r=G
Jon Machota Email jmachota@***BANNED-URL***
Published: January 22, 2015 11:01 pm
http://cowboysblog.***BANNED-URL***/files/2015/01/461342654_41661011-1.jpg
Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images
Cowboys receiver Cole Beasley.


Only two installments remain. Here is the fourth part of my Cowboys roster rankings for the 2014 season, numbers 11-20.

20.) Doug Free, RT. As good as the Cowboys offensive line was in 2014, they were at their absolute best when Free was on the field. The leader in the offensive line room started 11 games and received positive grades for nine of them from the folks at Pro Football Focus.

19.) Henry Melton, DT. Melton bet on himself with the contract he signed a year ago. If he returned to his Pro Bowl form, the club could exercise their option, keeping him on the roster for the next three seasons. Melton played at a high level for roughly half the season, recording five sacks in 16 games. But did the Cowboys see enough to keep him around?

18.) J.J. Wilcox, S. Wilcox continued to show improvement in his second year, finishing with 74 tackles during the regular season, fourth-most on the team. He also intercepted a career-high three passes, most of any defensive back on the roster.

17.) Brandon Carr, CB. No Cowboy defender has been criticized more than Carr these last two seasons. But every game, Carr is out there defending the other team’s top wide receiver. Even though he finished without an interception for the first time in his career, he played some of his best ball down the stretch.

16.) Cole Beasley, WR. Beasley played his best football during the last six games and it carried over into the playoffs. The 5-8 receiver averaged nearly 50 yards per game to go along with four touchdowns during those final six contests. In the playoffs, he hauled in more passes than Dez Bryant.

15.) Anthony Hitchens, LB. No Cowboys draft pick was more criticized than when Dallas selected Hitchens in the fourth round. But the rookie looked like a good investment when Sean Lee went down. He now looks like a great investment after seeing how he became one of the team’s best defenders.

14.) Terrance Williams, WR. One of Williams’ best attributes is his patience. He was the forgotten man for six games. But when teams continued to double Dez Bryant, Williams made the most of his opportunities. There was no better example than the two playoff games. Williams caught four passes for 130 yards and three touchdowns.

13.) Barry Church, S. Like J.J. Wilcox, Church continues to improve at the other starting safety spot. He’ll probably never be the type of defensive back to intercept five or six passes in a season, but he’s always around the ball making plays.

12.) Rolando McClain, LB. If he would’ve stayed healthy, McClain probably would’ve cracked the top five. The defense just played on another level when McClain was right. It would be very interesting to see what a healthy McClain looked like next to a healthy Sean Lee next season.

11.) Dan Bailey, K. The most accurate kicker in NFL history was very good again for the Cowboys, converting 25 of his 29 field goal attempts during the season, which included a career-long 56-yarder. The only knock on Bailey was that he missed two of his three postseason attempts, one from 41 yards and the other from 50.

Cowboys coaching staff gets early look at free agents at Pro Bowl; three to consider
  • Bruce Carter among many linebacker questions the Cowboys face prior to NFL Draft
  • Focus on his rushes and you miss much of DeMarco Murray's value to Cowboys
  • Bob Sturm's 2015 NFL Draft profile: What I see in Alvin 'Bud' Dupree, DE/OLB, Kentucky
http://cowboysblog.***BANNED-URL***/2015/01/ranking-the-cowboys-53-man-roster-numbers-20-11.html/

Barry Church..13th?...can we please upgrade talent on team
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Barry Church..13th?...can we please upgrade talent on team

LOL. I suspect they would if they could. Barry is a solid guy. He's just not a ball hawk nor stellar pass defender. He's average to a bit better. If they keep hitting on talent and can manage the cap better then we'll continue to improve. Eventually safety will get addressed. This is Wilcox's third year. I suspect he may continue to improve and he has some tools. He may be part of the answer.
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,901
Reaction score
112,897
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Is this said optimistically? :)

No. I don't think the Cowboys FO puts much priority on that position. I don't know if it was the quick burnout of RW31 or what happened to give us the mindset we currently have. I've been screaming for a ball hawk safety for years. I don't know why we seem to get SS instead in a pass happy league. Makes no damn sense to me at all. Especially when I see our pass rushers miss the QB by half a step consistently.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
No. I don't think the Cowboys FO puts much priority on that position. I don't know if it was the quick burnout of RW31 or what happened to give us the mindset we currently have. I've been screaming for a ball hawk safety for years. I don't know why we seem to get SS instead in a pass happy league. Makes no damn sense to me at all. Especially when I see our pass rushers miss the QB by half a step consistently.

I agree. I think Wilcox might be that guy but I'm far from certain. They are likely going to let that play out. But I don't think you let a FA, if you can afford it, or a highly rated S slip by you in the draft either. As long as they can tackle and defend the pass then two safeties like that on the field together are a good thing.
 

Arkyvarminter

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,501
Reaction score
1,904
Far to much credit being placed on "played some of his best ball down the stretch" for me. There is a reason for all the criticism the last 2 years and he was being paid to cover other teams #1. A lot of sugar coating trying to justify putting Carr at #17.

That may be true but with absolutely zero pass rush Deion wouldn't look super either.......
 

pacboyX

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,032
Reaction score
780
LOL. I suspect they would if they could. Barry is a solid guy. He's just not a ball hawk nor stellar pass defender. He's average to a bit better. If they keep hitting on talent and can manage the cap better then we'll continue to improve. Eventually safety will get addressed. This is Wilcox's third year. I suspect he may continue to improve and he has some tools. He may be part of the answer.

I definetly think Wilcox is part of answer, he really is a replacement for Church. Eventually it may get addressed but eventually may prevent a super bowl.
 

Manwiththeplan

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,268
Reaction score
7,763
Far to much credit being placed on "played some of his best ball down the stretch" for me. There is a reason for all the criticism the last 2 years and he was being paid to cover other teams #1. A lot of sugar coating trying to justify putting Carr at #17.

I agree. His good play down the stretch was a welcomed surprise, but there is no way I think we're getting 16 games and hopefully more of similar play
 
Top