viman96
Thread Killer
- Messages
- 21,555
- Reaction score
- 22,657
Article way too long to post. I only include the NFCE rankings so follow the link below to see all the rankings.
http://www.profootballweekly.com/2010/01/04/ranking-the-defensive-coordinators
Not much info on the specifics of how they ranked but here is what they said:
Using considerable feedback from league sources and talent evaluators and a special formula devised by PFW that takes into account numerous variables — including the effect of injuries on each team — PFW presents the following rankings of the league's 2009 defensive coordinators. PFW will break down the league's top offensive coordinators a week from now.
A few points worth making before launching into the rankings:
* Defensive coordinators, as best showcased in Pittsburgh, are often only as good as their players. When DE Aaron Smith and SS Troy Polamalu are not on the field due to injuries, the best coordinating job in the world cannot replace their talent and contributions to the defense, and their extended absences were factored when evaluating the job that Dick LeBeau did without them.
* Some coordinators who are learning behind strong, defensive-minded head coaches were downgraded because they have not had the training wheels taken off (Mike Pettine of the Jets, Ken Flajole of the Rams, Chuck Cecil of the Titans).
* There are other coordinators adversely affected by over-involved head coaches who have disrupted their play-calling rhythm.
Coordinators are ranked from top to bottom, with insiders' comments on each. All quotes were obtained from pro personnel evaluators on the condition of anonymity. Additional responsibilities of coordinators are indicated in parentheses where applicable.
1. Sean McDermott / Eagles — Despite suffering some major injuries at middle linebacker and having to get by with long-in-the-tooth Jeremiah Trotter, the Eagles' defense has remained very formidable. SCOUT'S TAKE: "(McDermott) is a rising star, now. I think a lot of people expected the Eagles to fall off after (former defensive coordinator) Jimmy Johnson passed away, but this kid clearly paid attention. He was with Jimmy 10 years, sitting at the corner of the table eating crumbs and absorbing it all. In some ways — with how creatively he finds ways to bring pressure — I think he might be better than (Johnson). He's got a great feel (for play-calling)."
15. Greg Blache / Commanders — Blache has been one of the few bright spots in a dysfunctional franchise. SCOUT'S TAKE: "He quietly has done a very good job. When you watch them play, you don't realize a lot of times that they are in as many games as they are, just because you hear so much about their offensive futility. But they make a lot of plays defensively and fly to the ball. That defense is what has kept them from being blown out of a bunch of games."
17. Wade Phillips (head coach) / Cowboys — After taking over the defense last season and letting go of Brian Stewart, the Cowboys have been without a coordinator in title, clearly showing that it is Phillips' job. SCOUT'S TAKE: "Guys play hard for Wade — you have to respect that. He's got a good situation not worrying about the offense at all and just running the 'D.' "
30. Bill Sheridan / Giants — Hired to maintain systematic continuity, Sheridan disappointed in his first year in his new role. Changes could be on the way in New York after the Giants struggled on a number of levels. SCOUT'S TAKE: "Red-zone struggles have been a major problem, and some of their most talented players (Osi Umenyiora) have become frustrated by a lack of playing time. 'Spags' (former D-coordinator Steve Spagnuolo) was a players' coach, and Sheridan has had a difficult time getting players to respond the same way."
http://www.profootballweekly.com/2010/01/04/ranking-the-defensive-coordinators
Not much info on the specifics of how they ranked but here is what they said:
Using considerable feedback from league sources and talent evaluators and a special formula devised by PFW that takes into account numerous variables — including the effect of injuries on each team — PFW presents the following rankings of the league's 2009 defensive coordinators. PFW will break down the league's top offensive coordinators a week from now.
A few points worth making before launching into the rankings:
* Defensive coordinators, as best showcased in Pittsburgh, are often only as good as their players. When DE Aaron Smith and SS Troy Polamalu are not on the field due to injuries, the best coordinating job in the world cannot replace their talent and contributions to the defense, and their extended absences were factored when evaluating the job that Dick LeBeau did without them.
* Some coordinators who are learning behind strong, defensive-minded head coaches were downgraded because they have not had the training wheels taken off (Mike Pettine of the Jets, Ken Flajole of the Rams, Chuck Cecil of the Titans).
* There are other coordinators adversely affected by over-involved head coaches who have disrupted their play-calling rhythm.
Coordinators are ranked from top to bottom, with insiders' comments on each. All quotes were obtained from pro personnel evaluators on the condition of anonymity. Additional responsibilities of coordinators are indicated in parentheses where applicable.
1. Sean McDermott / Eagles — Despite suffering some major injuries at middle linebacker and having to get by with long-in-the-tooth Jeremiah Trotter, the Eagles' defense has remained very formidable. SCOUT'S TAKE: "(McDermott) is a rising star, now. I think a lot of people expected the Eagles to fall off after (former defensive coordinator) Jimmy Johnson passed away, but this kid clearly paid attention. He was with Jimmy 10 years, sitting at the corner of the table eating crumbs and absorbing it all. In some ways — with how creatively he finds ways to bring pressure — I think he might be better than (Johnson). He's got a great feel (for play-calling)."
15. Greg Blache / Commanders — Blache has been one of the few bright spots in a dysfunctional franchise. SCOUT'S TAKE: "He quietly has done a very good job. When you watch them play, you don't realize a lot of times that they are in as many games as they are, just because you hear so much about their offensive futility. But they make a lot of plays defensively and fly to the ball. That defense is what has kept them from being blown out of a bunch of games."
17. Wade Phillips (head coach) / Cowboys — After taking over the defense last season and letting go of Brian Stewart, the Cowboys have been without a coordinator in title, clearly showing that it is Phillips' job. SCOUT'S TAKE: "Guys play hard for Wade — you have to respect that. He's got a good situation not worrying about the offense at all and just running the 'D.' "
30. Bill Sheridan / Giants — Hired to maintain systematic continuity, Sheridan disappointed in his first year in his new role. Changes could be on the way in New York after the Giants struggled on a number of levels. SCOUT'S TAKE: "Red-zone struggles have been a major problem, and some of their most talented players (Osi Umenyiora) have become frustrated by a lack of playing time. 'Spags' (former D-coordinator Steve Spagnuolo) was a players' coach, and Sheridan has had a difficult time getting players to respond the same way."
