Either way, the guy was right. The Cowboys did offer their second round pick for Earl Thomas. Seattle turned it down.
So you're questioning team reporters but giving credence to what your friends are saying? I think there's your first problem right there.
The Saints struggles have always been on the defensive side of the ball, when Payton has had a good defensive coordinator to handle that side of the ball, he's won. Even when the team's record overall wasn't good, his offense's are still ranked among the league's best.
And let's not forget, if the refs were able to do their jobs, he may have had another Super Bowl this year.