ES: Want a good laugh? Here's another. ES Ranking of NFC East QBs

[Bleu Star]

http://www.extremeskins.com/forums/showthread.php?t=182100

For the record my ranking goes like this.

1. Romo
2. Campbell
3. Bledsoe
4. McNabb

 

[BrassCowboy]

one guy at the skins had it right...

1. Romo
2. McNabb
3. Eli
4. Campbell


not a homer when I say that right now McNabb is close to a tie with Romo for that #1 spot right now, but I believe Romo has not even hit his peak yet so Romo > McNabb

 

[stealth]

mcnabb is a joke of a QB he chokes when it matters and is hurt so much its stupid. sometimes he looks amazing and sometimes he stinks. I would take a consistant ok QB over that roller coaster of a qb any day of the week.

 

[cobra]

Why on earth would rate Campbell anything but last?

He has only played in one game, and it was a poor game.

He got almost half his yards and a touchdown at slop time when the game was over and the Bucs were in prevent.

The other 95% of the game was as spare it comes.

Campbell hasn't shown ANYTHING at all. He dinked and dumped most of the game.

He should be dead last on anyone's list until he shows SOMETHING.

 

[JohnsKey19]

Look - I love Tony Romo, what he's done to this point AND what he can possibly do in the future but McNabb has to be #1. He's a proven perrenial Pro Bowl performer and his team's offense is virtually guaranteed to be high-powered when he is healthy.

After that it's pretty simple - Romo followed by Eli Manning. Manning to this point hasn't proven anything over 2 years but inconsistent play.

Campbell cant possibly be ranked(good or bad) after 1 game.

 

[dbair1967]

http://www.extremeskins.com/forums/showthread.php?t=182100

For the record my ranking goes like this.

1. Romo
2. Campbell
3. Bledsoe
4. McNabb

I'm surprised they didnt say Campbell was far and away the best

I mean, all 52 other players on their roster are superior to everyone elses too

David

 

[Bleu Star]

Look - I love Tony Romo, what he's done to this point AND what he can possibly do in the future but McNabb has to be #1. He's a proven perrenial Pro Bowl performer and his team's offense is virtually guaranteed to be high-powered when he is healthy.

After that it's pretty simple - Romo followed by Eli Manning. Manning to this point hasn't proven anything over 2 years but inconsistent play.

Campbell cant possibly be ranked(good or bad) after 1 game.

Are you serious? Are we rating QBs based upon past achievements or based upon what they can do if you put them in the game today and said go get it? We did the "past achievements" thing with Bledsoe to start this season and we all know how that turned out.

If we're rating on past achievements for QBs still in the game I would go this way.

1. McNabb
2. Bledsoe
3. Garcia
4. Romo

I believe the poll was "best qbs in the game today". Mcnabb hasn't shown me much without TO around to throw to. Sure, he can run and does more with less where it pertains to those 2nd rate WRs in Philly. However, at the end of the day, would you rather have Romo or McNabb at the helm? That should be an easy answer.

 

[ROMOSAPIEN9]

I just added my 2 cents in that little thread....

Assuming all are healthy, here's my list....

1: Romo
2: Romo playing left handed.
3: Field
4: Garcia

TeeHee

 

[Bleu Star]

Originally Posted by Dan454
Assuming all are healthy, here's my list....

1: Romo
2: Romo playing left handed.
3: Field
4: Garcia