- Messages
- 79,281
- Reaction score
- 45,648
Dave (SLC, UT): The primary focus of the national media has been directed towards the Eagles new options on defense. Who will step up and fill the leadership vacuum left by Dawkins' departure? Do you see the defense regressing or progressing this season?
Matt Mosley: Dave, welcome to today's chat. I'm going to take care of the early crowd. I predict we'll be at 500 people by 12:45 ET, but who's counting?
I think Dawkins was a superb leader. But I also think Quintin Mikell has been waiting to break out in his shadows. There are enough solid guys like Trent Cole, Bradley, Gocong etc. to still have some solid leadership on that side of the ball. Dawkins will certainly be missed, but I don't think you'll see the team fall apart or anything with him not around.
Matt (Dallas, JJ Pearce Grad): Mosley, I love the blog, one of my few bookmarked pages. Where do you think the Baylor Bears finish in the Big 12 South this year? Also, how well do they have to do to steal some TCU thunder?
Matt Mosley: Matt, I'll get this in quickly since my editors will likely stricken it from the record! I think Baylor wins six games and goes to its first bowl game since I was in school (1995). TCU has a great program, but they'll remain in the shadow of the mighty Big 12 -- and they'll continue to pout about being left out of the conference. Next time, make sure the state's governor and lt. governor hold a degree from your school. Worked for us.
Sanjay (Da Iladel, PA): Is the Giants massively upgraded front 7 vs. the Eagles massively upgraded O-line the best matchup to look forward to in the division this year?
Matt Mosley: Sanjay, I think that's a great one. I can't wait to see how Jason Peters deals with the Tucks and Umenyioras of the world.
Yatin (LA): Love the blog, Matt. What's the latest on both the physical health as well as the psyche of big Shawn Andrews? That dude is a difference-maker if he can stay on the field.
Matt Mosley: I understand he's doing well. The question remains, "How much does he like playing football?" When he's focused, he's a pretty dominating player. It's hard to make any projections when a player has dealt with depression issues. Let's hope he's received the help he needs. From all I've heard, that's certainly the case.
Dave (scranton pa): Colt Brennan looked superb in the preseason last year. His form seemed perfect and he made all the right decisions. He is a late round pick, but numerous qbs have made it in the nfl from being late rounders. Why doesn't he get a shot if there are questions about Campbell?
Matt Mosley: It's pretty easy to look good in the preseason. He's going up against second and third-teamers. You can't watch that and immediately elevate a guy to starting status. Colt Brennan needs to battle for the backup spot before he can even think about first team. The Colt Brennan for starter campaign may be the most absurd thing I've come across -- and that's saying something.
Kerry (DC): Mike Williams down 70 pounds in a couple months....can he still be a factor at RT?
Matt Mosley: I'll say it again. If Mike Williams ends up starting at RT, it will be an indictment against Vinny Cerrato and Co. The guy hasn't played a down in the league since '05. I don't care if he's lost 200 pounds. He shouldn't be starting for a decent team.
Jason: (Calgary, AB): Matt, did Sheldon Brown make it to the mandatory session today? Any thoughts on where this goes? I think k Brown is undervalued league-wide so the Eagles wouldn?t get much in return but I?d hate to see any locker room nonsense derail a team? Would the two Browns (Sheldon and Reggie) get anything of value? Am I looking through rose (or green) colored glasses to think that Sheldon?s a top (albeit older) starting CB and Reggie?s a solid #2 WR?
Matt Mosley: You have to remain patient with situations like this one. Brown overplayed his hand -- and that probably led to the Hobbs trade. The Eagles will bid their time and see if another team has injuries in training camp. If a team loses a starter, Brown's value would go up. And don't worry about him derailing anything. Did Lito Sheppard derail the '08 campaign?
Kerry (DC): Matt....I didn't ask if he could start. I asked if he could be "a factor" when the inevitable injuries hit the O Line...
Matt Mosley: sure
Jake (VA Beach): How much of a blow is a injury like Sintim's to not only him, but all rookies?
Matt Mosley: Jake, it's obviously a setback for the kid but I'm not sure how it affects "all rookies." The Giants wanted him to be in he mix on special teams and to be able to learn everything. you can't do that on the sideline. explain what you mean by "blow to all rookies."
Matt (VT): Much has been made about the steps Reese & Co. have taken to shore up the Giants' defensive line. What kind of progressions do you expect to see from the younger players in the secondary, especially Ross, Phillips and Thomas?
Matt Mosley: I think Phillips is poised to have a breakout season. I'm talking seven or eight INTs and a ton of plays. I have him going to the Pro Bowl. Ross and Thomas should be fine, but Phillips is my breakout guy.
Mike (Bloomsburg): Mosley, why do you have such a problem with using Orakpo in different positions? If players have ability to do mulitple things shouldn't Blache take adventage?
Matt Mosley: Mike, I like seeing players do what they do best. Orakpo was an elite pass rusher at Texas. He didn't play on his feet. The Commanders want to move him to a foreign position to him (SAM) on first and second down) and then move him up to the line in passing situations. If he's playing outside linebacker in the 3-4, I have no problem with it. But he's playing the SAM in a 4-3. Makes no sense to me, and there are personnel guys around the league who are happy to back me up.
Sean (Philly): Is Peters definitely playing Left, or could Andrews end up playing the left side?
Matt Mosley: You don't pay a man that type of money to play RT
Dave (scranton pa): Best rookie performance in the beast this season?
Matt Mosley: Nicks
Corey (Newark, DE): During the first weeks of training camp, of course there will be big name cuts. Do you see any big names yet thats on the hot box? And Do you think the Eagles will land one of those cut big name players for verteran support?
Matt Mosley: Eagles might be interested in Ellis once the Cows cut him.
John (Newtown PA): Who do you think will return punts for the Eagles this year. Maclin or DeSean Jackson?
Matt Mosley: I think Maclin will get first dibs since he won't initially start on offense.
Chris (NJ): What is your opinion of Bill Simmons?
Matt Mosley: He's fantastic
Todd (Ft. Worth, TX): You say Williams starting for the 'Skins at RT is a bad thing, but he was a legitimate starter before two injury-plagued years. He wasn't worth the #4 overall, but if he is motivated, and healthy, he could start. Not much different between him and the "incredible Bulk" who went on to be a legitimate starting guard for the Colts for a few years. Would you change your statement if he started and was actually good at RT? Are you told to make bold statements instead of thoughtful ones? (I know it doesn't sound like it, but I do enjoy the blog and your work on local radio here in town).
Matt Mosley: Todd, thanks for reading -- and listening. I'm not trying to make some type of "bold statement." Just simply stating my opinion on the matter. Mike Williams ate himself out of the league. And yes, he had some injuries. I just think it's a really bad sign for the Skins if he's the starter. And if he plays well at RT, then I'll be the first one to admit I was wrong. it's tough when my neighbors are coming after me!! 
Esan (TX): How bout Texas A&M? No one seems to be talkin bout them and they could be a team coming up under the radar. Your take on that Matt?
Matt Mosley: There's a reason no one's talking about them. The Ags forgot how to recruit East Texas -- and it's killing the program. I'd rather see them back at full strength. It's no fun beating a team by 30 points at Floyd Casey. Ok, it's a little fun...OK, it's the most amazing thing in the world. But I wish no harm on the Ags.
Kevin (Albuquerque, NM): Love the blog! We know football games are won in the trenches, so can you rank the top beast offensive and defensive lines?
Matt Mosley: Thanks, Kev.
O-lines:
1. Giants
2. Eagles
3. Cowboys
4. Skins
D-lines:
1. Giants
2. Commanders
3. Eagles
4. Cowboys
Dave (scranton pa): Which player in the beast do you think can have a "comeback" type of season. Flying under the radar to have a breakout year? Despite the fact he will most likely be replaced as a starter, i think Kevin Curtis could be that player. Moving him to the slot perhaps, with those two quick young wideouts Curtis could be left open. When he is healthy he is an impressive player.
Matt Mosley: Dave, I always like your questions. I think Westbrook will have a huge season after sort of a down year (by his standards). Having someone like McCoy could help him in a big way. When's the last time the Eagles had a backup RB that teams feared? I guess Buckhalter had his moments, but it's been awhile.
Joe (CT): Curious how much of getting off the line can be taught. I ask because of Barden for the Giants. His big knock is getting off the line. Is this something that he can drastically improve over a couple years? He just seems like he could be a force if he learns that one thing. Thank you
Matt Mosley: Joe, there are some tricks to the trade. Michael Irvin was unbelievable at it. He was like a great boxer at the line of scrimmage. He would do a hand slap that would have guys bleeding from their forearms. It's one thing that T.O. doesn't do very well. Press coverage really bothers him. We'll see if Barden can learn to do it. It's a huge part of being a WR at this level. Watch the Panthers' steve smith at the line.
Marc ( City of Brotherly Love): You gotta be kidding. The NYG have a better offensive line than the Eagles? The Eagles have at least 2 Pro Bowlers on theirs? Think you a bit off there Matt.
Matt Mosley: Joe, there are some tricks to the trade. Michael Irvin was unbelievable at it. He was like a great boxer at the line of scrimmage. He would do a hand slap that would have guys bleeding from their forearms. It's one thing that T.O. doesn't do very well. Press coverage really bothers him. We'll see if Barden can learn to do it. It's a huge part of being a WR at this level. Watch the Panthers' steve smith at the line.
Marc ( City of Brotherly Love): You gotta be kidding. The NYG have a better offensive line than the Eagles? The Eagles have at least 2 Pro Bowlers on theirs? Think you a bit off on that one Matt.
Matt Mosley: I had a long answer and it disappeared on me. But here's the gist: Peters is coming off a down year, although I think he'll be excellent. Andrews essentially missed the entire '08 season. The Eagles aren't exactly high on Jackson at center. And let's not act like Stacy Andrews is the second coming of Munoz -- or insert your guard of choice (Allen for me)...The Giants have a formidable group. Snee's become one of the best guards in the game. Diehl's very reliable. I'll stick with the Giants
Brendon (Rochester): Who starts at CB alongside Newman for the Boys....Scandrick or Jenkins? I'd say give the number one pick a shot, but if Scandricks better he's better.
Matt Mosley: Scandrick does such a good job moving inside in the nickel that he almost needs to specialize there. So let's go ahead and say Newman and Jenkins start, with Scandrick coming in to play the slot.
Ahmed (Queens, NY): Love your blog Matt! I still don't trust Eli late in the season. Do you think he is still maturing into the league? or is this the best we're seeing from him? Thanks.
Matt Mosley: I think he's still improving. I don't think the Giants were prepared for life without Plax -- especially Manning. Think about the bomb that Hixon dropped against the Eagles. Could that have been a different game if the Giants get a TD there? You bet it could've. it's alarming that he played those last four or five games without completing passes to his WRs for TDs, but now he'll have a full offseason with Smith, Hixon, Moss, Nicks, etc. I think he'll come back strong. Wouldn't surprise me if he had an MVP-type season.
andy (manahawkin N.J.): who starts along side moss this year randle el (i hope not ) or one of last years second rounders
Matt Mosley: I think they're pulling for Devin Thomas.
Nick (Sandy Hook): Those D-Line rankings seem a bit suspect to me - I know Haynesworth is good, but are the Commanders really better off than the Eagles? I'd take Trent Cole over Andre Carter any day, and the Eagles have a whole lot more depth. I'd at least call it a tie.
Matt Mosley: OK, tie sounds fine to me.
Mike ( Philly): Now that you've had a few weeks to see the teams in OTAs and what not, what do you see the BEAST teams records looking like so far?
Matt Mosley: Giants (13-3)
Eagles (11-5)
Cowboys (9-7)
Commanders (8-8)
ACwithFT Tahoe, CA: I know it's early to project this, but right now, do you see Danny Ware or Andrew Brown taking the 3rd RB spot for the Giants? Do you see either of those guys giving Bradshaw serious competition for the number 2 job?
Matt Mosley: I could see Brown pushing for that No. 2 spot. Jerry Reese is in love with the kid. Ware has some ability, but the team doesn't seem to completely trust him. The same could be said for Bradshaw.
Justin (Boston): Hamlin or Sensabaugh at SS for the Boys?
Matt Mosley: No question about it, Sensabaugh starts
Marc ( City of Brotherly Love): First coach to get fired in the NFC Beast? Will it be Jim Zorn or Wade Phillips? I think both Andy Ried and Tom Coughlin are pretty safe. Also how long will Tony Romo's leash be if he "chokes" another playoff game? Thanks Matt
Matt Mosley: Oops, you accidentally got an extra question in, Marc. I think Zorn and Phillips are on equal footing, which is to say very shaky. Other two are solid. Romo received a guaranteed $30 mil in '07. He's not going anywhere.
Sanjay (Da Iladel, PA): Eagles have a comp at center between Nick Cole and Jamaal Jackson. Cole had a great year last year. This group is massive and athletic
Matt Mosley: I think I accidentally called Jackson "Brown" a few moments ago when discussing the center position. I always do that because of the guy from the Saints. Anyway, I agree that Cole could challenge jackson. Andy Reid admitted as much during the recent owners' meeting.
Kevin (Albuquerque, NM): I am stil skeptical about the Greg Ellis cap move. Not only does it take away a veteran leader from the locker room and weaken the depth at olb, but releasing him would risk one of the Beast teams picking him up as a pass-rush specialist. Your thoughts?
Matt Mosley: Hey, if they don't want him playing for a division rival, then don't release him. Ellis has complained about his role on the team for four straight offseasons. I think Jerry Jones is honestly sort of sick of it. He can talk about the cap, but the truth is that Ellis was upset again by the Cowboys drafting pass rushers. For some reason, Ellis seems to think the team should wait until he's 35 before thinking about replacements. I hammer the Cowboys quite a bit, but I don't have a problem with them cutting ties with Ellis.
Brett (Philly): Love the blog Matt... What do you see Maclin contributing in the passing game this year for the Birds? I know he came from a spread offense at Mizzou, but is that really going to hinder his development in the pros? The guy seems like a freak on the field from the highlights I've seen!
Matt Mosley: I think the transition might be a little tougher for him than someone like Jackson. Maclin had a lot of options on his routes. He could sort of read and react on 10 and 12-yard routes. He'll have to be much more precise at this level. I don't think he'll be quite as productive as Jackson was in his rookie season.
Larry (Charlotte,NC): If the Cowboys have a great season, will Wade Phillips be resigned?
Matt Mosley: Was that a play on words, Larry? I think this is Wade's final season with anything short of an NFC title game appearance.
Larry (Charlotte,NC): Would Bill Cower be a good fit for the Cowboys if he decides to coach next year?
Matt Mosley: He'd want more power than Jerry Jones is willing to concede. Mike Holmgren is the more likely choice.
Pete (NYC): got your ratings on the o line/d line.. what about linebackers/secondary?
Matt Mosley: Secondary
1. Giants
2. Eagles
3. Cowboys
4. Commanders
Matt (Denver): How about Shanahan to the Boys?
Matt Mosley: Holmgren is the name. Keep it handy
Marc ( City of Brotherly Love): If somehow someway the Cowboys make the playoffs and Romo "chokes" again? Will Jerry still stick with him in an uncapped year?
Matt Mosley: yep
Ryan (Cleveland TN) [via mobile]: with both their star recievers gone which Manning brother will have the best season?
Matt Mosley: Ryan, thanks for showing up early today. I like to reward folks in our first 10 questions -- especially the ones who avoid expletives. This will be the Year of Eli in the NFL. You heard it here first -- unless you've been reading the guy who writes for the Giants' Web site.
Dave Scranton Pa: Rate the qbs. Top 4 qbs and then top 4 qb corps
Matt Mosley: QBs
1. Eli Manning
2. Donovan McNabb
3. Tony Romo
4. Jason Campbell
And I just noticed that Romo's lurking on this chat, so be kind.
pat (jtown) [via mobile]: who will emerge as the gmens best wide reciever by the end of the season.
Matt Mosley: That would be steve smith. Thanks for showing up early, Pat.
David(Charlotte, NC): Should the Commanders pursue Greg Ellis? Do you know of an interest he is generating? Wouldnt he be a good fit for the Skins?
Matt Mosley: He'd be a great fit. Stick him in there with the rest of the 30-and-over crowd. :
Haze (Pittsburgh): Since the hands down best WR just left the division, who do you think is the new No. 1?
Matt Mosley: Santana Moss
Chris (Missouri): I just dont see Eli having that good of a year, especially when you look at the last 4 games of last year without plax, he didnt throw a touchdown pass. Not only that, they got rid of amani toomer and their number 1 - Steve Smith, and their number 2 a rookie, I just dont think he has the weapons, or really the skill to have a good season
Matt Mosley: I know it's early June, but we have to do better than 250 questions. Let's give it one more go next Tuesday before I head out on vacation. And stop hating on the Giants' receivers. Steve Smith and Hixon will get you off to a solid start -- and Nicks will emerge as a big-time playmaker midway through the season. You guys have been wonderful. Hope to see you soon. keep reading The Beast blog -- and listening to 103.3 ESPN (XM Radio 141).
I think Dawkins was a superb leader. But I also think Quintin Mikell has been waiting to break out in his shadows. There are enough solid guys like Trent Cole, Bradley, Gocong etc. to still have some solid leadership on that side of the ball. Dawkins will certainly be missed, but I don't think you'll see the team fall apart or anything with him not around.
Matt (Dallas, JJ Pearce Grad): Mosley, I love the blog, one of my few bookmarked pages. Where do you think the Baylor Bears finish in the Big 12 South this year? Also, how well do they have to do to steal some TCU thunder?
Sanjay (Da Iladel, PA): Is the Giants massively upgraded front 7 vs. the Eagles massively upgraded O-line the best matchup to look forward to in the division this year?
Yatin (LA): Love the blog, Matt. What's the latest on both the physical health as well as the psyche of big Shawn Andrews? That dude is a difference-maker if he can stay on the field.
Dave (scranton pa): Colt Brennan looked superb in the preseason last year. His form seemed perfect and he made all the right decisions. He is a late round pick, but numerous qbs have made it in the nfl from being late rounders. Why doesn't he get a shot if there are questions about Campbell?
Kerry (DC): Mike Williams down 70 pounds in a couple months....can he still be a factor at RT?
Jason: (Calgary, AB): Matt, did Sheldon Brown make it to the mandatory session today? Any thoughts on where this goes? I think k Brown is undervalued league-wide so the Eagles wouldn?t get much in return but I?d hate to see any locker room nonsense derail a team? Would the two Browns (Sheldon and Reggie) get anything of value? Am I looking through rose (or green) colored glasses to think that Sheldon?s a top (albeit older) starting CB and Reggie?s a solid #2 WR?
Kerry (DC): Matt....I didn't ask if he could start. I asked if he could be "a factor" when the inevitable injuries hit the O Line...
Jake (VA Beach): How much of a blow is a injury like Sintim's to not only him, but all rookies?
Matt (VT): Much has been made about the steps Reese & Co. have taken to shore up the Giants' defensive line. What kind of progressions do you expect to see from the younger players in the secondary, especially Ross, Phillips and Thomas?
Mike (Bloomsburg): Mosley, why do you have such a problem with using Orakpo in different positions? If players have ability to do mulitple things shouldn't Blache take adventage?
Sean (Philly): Is Peters definitely playing Left, or could Andrews end up playing the left side?
Dave (scranton pa): Best rookie performance in the beast this season?
Corey (Newark, DE): During the first weeks of training camp, of course there will be big name cuts. Do you see any big names yet thats on the hot box? And Do you think the Eagles will land one of those cut big name players for verteran support?
John (Newtown PA): Who do you think will return punts for the Eagles this year. Maclin or DeSean Jackson?
Chris (NJ): What is your opinion of Bill Simmons?
Todd (Ft. Worth, TX): You say Williams starting for the 'Skins at RT is a bad thing, but he was a legitimate starter before two injury-plagued years. He wasn't worth the #4 overall, but if he is motivated, and healthy, he could start. Not much different between him and the "incredible Bulk" who went on to be a legitimate starting guard for the Colts for a few years. Would you change your statement if he started and was actually good at RT? Are you told to make bold statements instead of thoughtful ones? (I know it doesn't sound like it, but I do enjoy the blog and your work on local radio here in town).
Esan (TX): How bout Texas A&M? No one seems to be talkin bout them and they could be a team coming up under the radar. Your take on that Matt?
Kevin (Albuquerque, NM): Love the blog! We know football games are won in the trenches, so can you rank the top beast offensive and defensive lines?
O-lines:
1. Giants
2. Eagles
3. Cowboys
4. Skins
D-lines:
1. Giants
2. Commanders
3. Eagles
4. Cowboys
Dave (scranton pa): Which player in the beast do you think can have a "comeback" type of season. Flying under the radar to have a breakout year? Despite the fact he will most likely be replaced as a starter, i think Kevin Curtis could be that player. Moving him to the slot perhaps, with those two quick young wideouts Curtis could be left open. When he is healthy he is an impressive player.
Joe (CT): Curious how much of getting off the line can be taught. I ask because of Barden for the Giants. His big knock is getting off the line. Is this something that he can drastically improve over a couple years? He just seems like he could be a force if he learns that one thing. Thank you
Marc ( City of Brotherly Love): You gotta be kidding. The NYG have a better offensive line than the Eagles? The Eagles have at least 2 Pro Bowlers on theirs? Think you a bit off there Matt.
Marc ( City of Brotherly Love): You gotta be kidding. The NYG have a better offensive line than the Eagles? The Eagles have at least 2 Pro Bowlers on theirs? Think you a bit off on that one Matt.
Brendon (Rochester): Who starts at CB alongside Newman for the Boys....Scandrick or Jenkins? I'd say give the number one pick a shot, but if Scandricks better he's better.
Ahmed (Queens, NY): Love your blog Matt! I still don't trust Eli late in the season. Do you think he is still maturing into the league? or is this the best we're seeing from him? Thanks.
andy (manahawkin N.J.): who starts along side moss this year randle el (i hope not ) or one of last years second rounders
Nick (Sandy Hook): Those D-Line rankings seem a bit suspect to me - I know Haynesworth is good, but are the Commanders really better off than the Eagles? I'd take Trent Cole over Andre Carter any day, and the Eagles have a whole lot more depth. I'd at least call it a tie.
Mike ( Philly): Now that you've had a few weeks to see the teams in OTAs and what not, what do you see the BEAST teams records looking like so far?
Eagles (11-5)
Cowboys (9-7)
Commanders (8-8)
ACwithFT Tahoe, CA: I know it's early to project this, but right now, do you see Danny Ware or Andrew Brown taking the 3rd RB spot for the Giants? Do you see either of those guys giving Bradshaw serious competition for the number 2 job?
Justin (Boston): Hamlin or Sensabaugh at SS for the Boys?
Marc ( City of Brotherly Love): First coach to get fired in the NFC Beast? Will it be Jim Zorn or Wade Phillips? I think both Andy Ried and Tom Coughlin are pretty safe. Also how long will Tony Romo's leash be if he "chokes" another playoff game? Thanks Matt
Sanjay (Da Iladel, PA): Eagles have a comp at center between Nick Cole and Jamaal Jackson. Cole had a great year last year. This group is massive and athletic
Kevin (Albuquerque, NM): I am stil skeptical about the Greg Ellis cap move. Not only does it take away a veteran leader from the locker room and weaken the depth at olb, but releasing him would risk one of the Beast teams picking him up as a pass-rush specialist. Your thoughts?
Brett (Philly): Love the blog Matt... What do you see Maclin contributing in the passing game this year for the Birds? I know he came from a spread offense at Mizzou, but is that really going to hinder his development in the pros? The guy seems like a freak on the field from the highlights I've seen!
Larry (Charlotte,NC): If the Cowboys have a great season, will Wade Phillips be resigned?
Larry (Charlotte,NC): Would Bill Cower be a good fit for the Cowboys if he decides to coach next year?
Pete (NYC): got your ratings on the o line/d line.. what about linebackers/secondary?
1. Giants
2. Eagles
3. Cowboys
4. Commanders
Matt (Denver): How about Shanahan to the Boys?
Marc ( City of Brotherly Love): If somehow someway the Cowboys make the playoffs and Romo "chokes" again? Will Jerry still stick with him in an uncapped year?
Ryan (Cleveland TN) [via mobile]: with both their star recievers gone which Manning brother will have the best season?
Dave Scranton Pa: Rate the qbs. Top 4 qbs and then top 4 qb corps
1. Eli Manning
2. Donovan McNabb
3. Tony Romo
4. Jason Campbell
And I just noticed that Romo's lurking on this chat, so be kind.
pat (jtown) [via mobile]: who will emerge as the gmens best wide reciever by the end of the season.
David(Charlotte, NC): Should the Commanders pursue Greg Ellis? Do you know of an interest he is generating? Wouldnt he be a good fit for the Skins?
: Haze (Pittsburgh): Since the hands down best WR just left the division, who do you think is the new No. 1?
Chris (Missouri): I just dont see Eli having that good of a year, especially when you look at the last 4 games of last year without plax, he didnt throw a touchdown pass. Not only that, they got rid of amani toomer and their number 1 - Steve Smith, and their number 2 a rookie, I just dont think he has the weapons, or really the skill to have a good season
