ESPN Watkins: Is Charles Haley a Hall of Famer?

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,281
Reaction score
45,652
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Nov 28 5:31PM CT
By Calvin Watkins

The Pro Football Hall of Fame Selection Committee released the 25 semifinalists for the Class of 2010 on Saturday.

One Cowboys legend appears to be a lock, running back Emmitt Smith, the all-time leading rusher. Check that, he is a lock. Another person who is almost guaranteed entry is former 49ers wide receiver Jerry Rice, the all-time leader in receiving touchdowns, catches and yards.

But there is another former 49ers and Cowboys player on the list that has a shot, and that's defensive end Charles Haley, the only man in NFL history with five Super Bowl rings.

The list will be reduced to 15 in January and the final vote will be in February.

The big question is will Haley make it?

"He's a legitimate candidate," said Dave Goldberg, a Hall of Fame voter, a long-time NFL writer who retired from Associated Press and now works for AOL Fanhouse. "The reason he hasn't been up before was he was a bad guy, not a good teammate. I'd like to see him get debated, he won't make it this year."

Goldberg said he would vote for Haley if he gets to the final 15.

Just exchanged text messages with Houston Chronicle NFL/Houston Texans' beat writer John McClain and this is what he had to say regarding Haley: "I'm voting for [Richard] Dent before Haley. I don't think both will get in the same year. I think Dent is long overdue. I don't think two defensive ends will get in the same year 'cause I think so many skill position players will make it."
 

TellerMorrow34

BraveHeartFan
Messages
28,358
Reaction score
5,076
Yes he is. I can't believe media people continue to even ask that as if it's a real question.
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
Is a five time pro bowler who was one of the most high profile players on 5 super bowl teams a HOFer?

I cant believe it's really even debated.
 

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
21,555
Reaction score
22,657
IMO Haley is a LOCK. 5 SB rings on teams that he was a difference maker. It is a joke it is even being asked.
 

jem88

Active Member
Messages
2,698
Reaction score
1
WoodysGirl;3108801 said:
Nov 28 5:31PM CT
By Calvin Watkins

The Pro Football Hall of Fame Selection Committee released the 25 semifinalists for the Class of 2010 on Saturday.

One Cowboys legend appears to be a lock, running back Emmitt Smith, the all-time leading rusher. Check that, he is a lock. Another person who is almost guaranteed entry is former 49ers wide receiver Jerry Rice, the all-time leader in receiving touchdowns, catches and yards.
There's no 'almost' when it comes to Rice and the HOF.
 

Seven

Messenger to the football Gods
Messages
19,301
Reaction score
9,892
trickblue;3108804 said:
yes...

[/threadclose]

Trick............. Shows up when necessary and speaks the truth.
 

Chief

"Friggin Joke Monkey"
Messages
8,543
Reaction score
4
jem88;3108829 said:
There's no 'almost' when it comes to Rice and the HOF.

:laugh2:

Someone needs to tap Calvin on the shoulder and assure him that Rice will get in.

What a joke.

Oh, and forget about Haley's mobile playground in his pants. He's a hall of famer.

Maybe his bronze should be of his *****.
 

cowboyjoe

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,433
Reaction score
753
WoodysGirl;3108801 said:
Nov 28 5:31PM CT
By Calvin Watkins

The Pro Football Hall of Fame Selection Committee released the 25 semifinalists for the Class of 2010 on Saturday.

One Cowboys legend appears to be a lock, running back Emmitt Smith, the all-time leading rusher. Check that, he is a lock. Another person who is almost guaranteed entry is former 49ers wide receiver Jerry Rice, the all-time leader in receiving touchdowns, catches and yards.

But there is another former 49ers and Cowboys player on the list that has a shot, and that's defensive end Charles Haley, the only man in NFL history with five Super Bowl rings.

The list will be reduced to 15 in January and the final vote will be in February.

The big question is will Haley make it?

"He's a legitimate candidate," said Dave Goldberg, a Hall of Fame voter, a long-time NFL writer who retired from Associated Press and now works for AOL Fanhouse. "The reason he hasn't been up before was he was a bad guy, not a good teammate. I'd like to see him get debated, he won't make it this year."

Goldberg said he would vote for Haley if he gets to the final 15.

Just exchanged text messages with Houston Chronicle NFL/Houston Texans' beat writer John McClain and this is what he had to say regarding Haley: "I'm voting for [Richard] Dent before Haley. I don't think both will get in the same year. I think Dent is long overdue. I don't think two defensive ends will get in the same year 'cause I think so many skill position players will make it."

Most evidently, if Lawrence Taylor who was MVP as a defensive player in the NFL and just won what 2 superbowls? And Charles Haley was defensive player too, with 5 superbowls, then Charles Haley should be in the Hall of Fame too.
 

adbutcher

K9NME
Messages
12,287
Reaction score
2,910
Chief;3109022 said:
:laugh2:

Someone needs to tap Calvin on the shoulder and assure him that Rice will get in.

What a joke.

Oh, and forget about Haley's mobile playground in his pants. He's a hall of famer.

Maybe his bronze should be of his *****.

I cannot believe I entered this thread. I had my fill of stupidity, I should be good for the week.
 

RoadRunner

New Member
Messages
2,809
Reaction score
0
WoodysGirl;3108801 said:
Nov 28 5:31PM CT
By Calvin Watkins

The Pro Football Hall of Fame Selection Committee released the 25 semifinalists for the Class of 2010 on Saturday.

One Cowboys legend appears to be a lock, running back Emmitt Smith, the all-time leading rusher. Check that, he is a lock. Another person who is almost guaranteed entry is former 49ers wide receiver Jerry Rice, the all-time leader in receiving touchdowns, catches and yards.

Time for me to nitpick - he only credits Smith as all time rushing leader, but makes sure to point out that Rice is leader in tds, catches and yards. Hey Watkins, Smith is leader in rushes, yards and tds. He is to running backs as Rice is to receivers. Don't forget that. Also, you need to give the two props for all the rings they have.
 

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
speedkilz88;3108899 said:
Haley should be a lock. Somehow Fred Dean made it.

Yeah, I agree with McClain on Dent. Seems like if you're a Niner or a Steeler, you can make it by just lacing your shoes




YAKUZA
 
Top