First Take: trade scenario: Cowboys trade Prescott & 17th pick to Dolphins

[lk8701]

I like the trade if it's for Tua. I agree with Max and Ryan Clark.

 

[baltcowboy]

I like the trade if it's for Tua. I agree with Max and Ryan Clark.

This trade sucks for the Cowboys. It’s actually a steal for Miami. They get to keep their 3 first round picks. This would be low risk for them. The only way we win this trade is if Tua or Herbert become Mahomes.

 

[unionjack8]

Its gonna cost 5 and 18

 

[Stash]

 

[kiheikiwi]

Nope, not doing it.

 

[aria]

Why on earth would any team in a position to draft a top QB rookie prospect trade for a QB (barring AR, Wilson and one or two others) who wants to be paid as the highest and is due for a contract? A lot of winning teams try and build around a rookie qb while they’re still on a rookie contract, not the other way around. Mahomes, Goff and Wentz come to mind.

 

[PAPPYDOG]

I like the trade if it's for Tua. I agree with Max and Ryan Clark.

No one wants Dak for that price.
Not even the sucky fins...

 

[baltcowboy]

Its gonna cost 5 and 18

That’s the only way the Cowboys might even listen. I would keep the 17th pick, take the 18th and also get the extra second round pick. I would want three first round picks for the Cowboys.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

I like the trade if it's for Tua. I agree with Max and Ryan Clark.

I don't want Tua. he reminds me of Mariotta. we all complain about Dak having been surrounded with talent and he was the beneficiary, yet Tua was surrounded by some of the most talented players on a single team in history of NCAA. how many first roudn WRs? TEs? Linemen and running backs did he play with?. so I am not sold on Tua. he is smallish, doesn't wow you with any single thing. has no signature anything......successful college player, who is injury prone now....

if this scenario happens, then I would try and trade up one spot with Commanders and take Chase Young, who plays the same position as Montez Sweat who Commanders traded up and drafted last year.....you start to build the defense with some high level talent...defense wins championships. now, behind our OL, Stafford may have some success and MC is pretty familiar with him given his years at GB....

now, that would be awesome!

 

[RodeoJake]

No way, no how. We give up a proven QB to move up 12 places in the draft? I don't think even Jerry is that nuts.

 

[John813]

Miami passes on that deal.

I follow them and they have been set on sinking or swimming off a 2020 draft QB.

 

[JBS]

Dak and 17 for 5?

You can miss my

On top of that..there is no guarantee Tua is even there at 5..now you lose dak, 17, and have no qb..

Great trade, idiot

 

[Risen Star]

Wait we get the 5th pick too? I thought we were just sending them 17 to take Prescott.

 

[JoeKing]

Miami is not going to make that trade unless they are allowed to work a deal with Dak in advance. Not happening.

 

[PJTHEDOORS]

Dallas would laugh at that lame offer.

 

[America's Cowboy]

I like the trade if it's for Tua. I agree with Max and Ryan Clark.

You can't trade Dak in time for the draft if he has refused to sign his tag offer!!!!

 

[RodeoJake]

Wait we get the 5th pick too? I thought we were just sending them 17 to take Prescott.

Just when I was beginning to think Dak Attack was your alter ego.

 

[cowboy_ron]

Why would Miami want to trade for a QB that makes poor decisions, defies authority, and thinks he should be the highest paid player in the NFL?

 

[Oz-of-Cowboy-Country]

There aren't any real good QB's in this draft IMO. Should wait until next year to replace Dak if that's what they want to do.

 

[DeaconMoss]

If we can get Herbert at 5 and Fitzmagic and we swap picks at 17 - 18 ..... sold.

If Tua is the one there at 5, not sure Id take it.