Fox Sports Best QBs 2025

[Hawkeye0202]

Many will disagree with Dak as the top 10, and I wouldn't argue, but I think the OP is giving him a pass for the 2024 season, excluding the playoffs. I think he's assuming a healthy Dak, alone, could return to 2023 form with Pickens' addition.

Hornable mentions........Stafford, Purdy, Love, Stroud, Murray, and Nix

 

[MarcusRock]

This thread has been untouched for 2.5 hours. Y'all are losing your touch. Commence Dakking and anti-Dakking. Here, I'll start:

"See? Most people out there see Dak as a Top 10 QB. He's good."​

​

"Oh yeah? Remember when y'all used to brag that he was Top 5. That arc is headed downward, sucka!"​

​

Coogs: "Post of y'all's lives!"​

 

[Johannes44]

This thread has been untouched for 2.5 hours. Y'all are losing your touch. Commence Dakking and anti-Dakking.

Honestly, it doesn't matter. You can rank him anywhere on the scale. It won't take away from the reality that Dak Prescott sucks as a QB.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Judging by the honorable mentions, I am convinced that networks are pressured to put a Cowboys QB in the top 10 just for engagement purposes.

That's why you no skills Dak at 10 with 4 other QBs who are clearly better than him as honorable mentions.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

to help the anti Dak crowd, here is a list just check the boxes.

1. he laid an egg against GB and his playoff performance.
2. he is beneficiary of a great team around him.
3. he single handedly lost the GB game, the Rams game and the two SF games.
4. we beat seattle because Russell didn't play well and tampa wasn't a good team.
5. he can't read a defense.
6. deer look on the side line.
7. highest paid player shouldn't be ranked 10th. he can't carry the team he has to be carried.
8. he is a one legged QB at this time
9. can't run anymore and no one fears his arm
10. interceptions, interceptions, interceptions
11. Rush

please add to the list and we can just put the numbers in the comments instead of regurgigating everything 10 times over. I will create a list for the pros.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Judging by the honorable mentions, I am convinced that networks are pressured to put a Cowboys QB in the top 10 just for engagement purposes.

That's why you no skills Dak at 10 with 4 other QBs who are clearly better than him as honorable mentions.

that was stupid even by your standards...which is low to begin with

 

[GINeric]

Well if he's placed himself in the top 10 his whole career except for the years he was injured, this isn't new news. Every intelligent person knows Dak is a top 10 quarterback.

We also know he isn't elite.

 

[BoyzBlaster]

Even if you accept he's #10 (he isn't) the problem is if you add young QBs just starting their career who have a lot of potential (whereas we know Daks ceiling) he slides down to middle of the pack and we are paying top dollar for that.

 

[Pass2Run]

Mayfield ahead of him?

And Herbert?

 

[GINeric]

Judging by the honorable mentions, I am convinced that networks are pressured to put a Cowboys QB in the top 10 just for engagement purposes.

That's why you no skills Dak at 10 with 4 other QBs who are clearly better than him as honorable mentions.

You said Dak had the 2nd worst contract in NFL history. I haven't seen that on any of the worst contract lists I've seen.

Do you have a link? I don't want to accuse you of lying again but we like to use real life facts around here. Where have you ever saw Dak's contract posted as the 2nd worst in history?

The only contracts I've found to have been considered the 2nd worst in history was Russell Wilson (Denver Broncos contract, Albert Haynesworth or Nnamdi Asomugha. I've searched all over the internet and haven't seen Dak's classified on this list.

You have any links or sources that show Dak's contract is the 2nd worst in NFL history?

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Mayfield ahead of him?

And Herbert?

Herbert is a skilled version of Dak.

You can't be upset that Herbert is always in the top 10 of these lists, but be okay with Dak in them.

Herbert would be the owner of multiple QB single season QB records if he was the Cowboys QB. He's insanely better than Dak, that's no question, but as of now, he's a loser just like Dak also.

 

[DallasEast]

link

 

[GINeric]

Herbert is a skilled version of Dak.

You can't be upset that Herbert is always in the top 10 of these lists, but be okay with Dak in them.

Herbert would be the owner of multiple QB single season QB records if he was the Cowboys QB. He's insanely better than Dak, that's no question, but as of now, he's a loser just like Dak also.

How many playoff games have Herbert won again and what's his overall record???

Then let's see what quarterback is better than the other. Herbert is a decent quarterback, no doubt but I think you've inflated him a lil bit.

 

[pitt33]

Rankings are pretty much fluff.

You can count elite quarterbacks on one hand.

All the others need a lot to go right for the team to be successful.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Herbert is a skilled version of Dak.

You can't be upset that Herbert is always in the top 10 of these lists, but be okay with Dak in them.

Herbert would be the owner of multiple QB single season QB records if he was the Cowboys QB. He's insanely better than Dak, that's no question, but as of now, he's a loser just like Dak also.

by measuring standards of Daksessed crowd, he has zero playoff wins. he is 0-2. he shouldn't be in the top 20.

 

[Coogiguy03]

This thread has been untouched for 2.5 hours. Y'all are losing your touch. Commence Dakking and anti-Dakking. Here, I'll start:

"See? Most people out there see Dak as a Top 10 QB. He's good."​

​

"Oh yeah? Remember when y'all used to brag that he was Top 5. That arc is headed downward, sucka!"​

​

Coogs: "Post of y'all's lives!"​

Hey hey hey hey young man lol lol sounds pretty good lol

 

[thunderpimp91]

Mayfield ahead of him?

And Herbert?

Mayfield is coming off a 71% completion, 4500 yard, 41 TD year.

If you're going off of their full careers Dak is certainly ahead, but if we are doing more of a what have you done for me lately type of ranking I think Mayfield is clearly ahead of Dak.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Mayfield is coming off a 71% completion, 4500 yard, 41 TD year.

If you're going off of their full careers Dak is certainly ahead, but if we are doing more of a what have you done for me lately type of ranking I think Mayfield is clearly ahead of Dak.

Dak fans can't understand that "who is better now" is what really matters.

Cooper Rush should be ahead of Dak if we're being honest. Along with everyone on their honorable mentions list.

 

[Johannes44]

Dak fans can't understand that "who is better now" is what really matters.

Cooper Rush should be ahead of Dak if we're being honest. Along with everyone on their honorable mentions list.

They are still reliving his rookie year on an endless loop.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Many will disagree with Dak as the top 10, and I wouldn't argue, but I think the OP is giving him a pass for the 2024 season, excluding the playoffs. I think he's assuming a healthy Dak, alone, could return to 2023 form with Pickens' addition.

Hornable mentions........Stafford, Purdy, Love, Stroud, Murray, and Nix

Herbert and Baker would never make my top 10…pure stupidity.