GAC talks Romo vs Eli - 6/25/08

[dcfanatic]

GAC talks Romo vs Eli

------------------------

I think if you asked the other 30 NFL teams who they want, Romo or Eli, I think we would see at least 25 of them choose Romo.

Romo is more mobile and he's more accurate. He also has the leadership intangibles that any QB must have in the NFL.

Eli didn't play well for the entire 2007 season, he played well for the last 8 games or so. He gets his due for stepping up big time, but I don't think anyone is sold that he will do it on a consistent basis. Plus you could argue that if Asante Samuel hangs onto that INT towards the end of the game then Eli is blamed for losing the game.

 

[sonnyboy]

I'm 100% convinced that all 31 other teams including the Giants would take Romo.

No smiley face, no joking. I'm serious.

BTW What 5 teams along with the Giants do you think are foolish enough to choose Manning?

 

[dcfanatic]

I'm 100% convinced that all 31 other teams including the Giants would take Romo.

No smiley face, no joking. I'm serious.

BTW What 5 teams along with the Giants do you think are foolish enough to choose Manning?

I really didn't have 5 other teams in mind. I am just sure that at least 25 of them would have there head screwed on straight that day so they would take Romo.

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

Romo just needs to win a playoff game, after than everything else will answer itself...

 

[jobberone]

Interesting question. Manning silenced a lot of critics people. I'm not ready to let him play with my toys until he shows me last year was not a fluke though.

 

[DaBoys4Life]

Eli manning played goof in the playoffs he sucked in December I don't tired of this BS.

 

[switzersflask]

Eli can be pretty good sometimes, but there's no way you can sit here and tell me you would rather have Eli over Romo after watching them both play.

NY's super bowl just feels like a freaking default championship. Borefest through the season then gay their way to a title.

I don't know, maybe I just don't like NY. Dallas really let one slip a way.

 

[windward]

Eli manning played goof in the playoffs he sucked in December I don't tired of this BS.

I'm pretty sure Eli always plays goof.

 

[Nav22]

And just think... if Crayton doesn't drop that ball on 3rd and 14...

Or if Crayton doesn't hesitate on his route to the endzone late...

This "debate" would not even be worth discussion.

It still hurts.

 

[CrazyCowboy]

I have to go with MOXIE!