Give me your Grade A first 4 rounds

[Risen Star]

Mel and ToddToddToddTodd always do a Grade A mock that should be out soon. The idea is what picks would need to be made to get an A grade from you for that team? Being realistic of course in terms of where players will be selected. They do 3 rounds but since the Cowboys don't have a first round pick this year I thought 4 would be better.

Here are the picks we currently hold. Obviously this is fluid but for this exercise let's assume they make these selections.

2(58)
3(90)
4(128)
4(136)

If you would, kindly fill in the names that would make you believe the Cowboys aced these selections.

Again, please keep it realistic. They aren't getting Simmons at 58.

 

[TheBigEasy]

I think the forum is waiting for you to go first bro.

 

[Beaker42]

Mel and ToddToddToddTodd always do a Grade A mock that should be out soon. The idea is what picks would need to be made to get an A grade from you for that team? Being realistic of course in terms of where players will be selected. They do 3 rounds but since the Cowboys don't have a first round pick this year I thought 4 would be better.

Here are the picks we currently hold. Obviously this is fluid but for this exercise let's assume they make these selections.

2(58)
3(90)
4(128)
4(136)

If you would, kindly fill in the names that would make you believe the Cowboys aced these selections.

Again, please keep it realistic. They aren't getting Simmons at 58.

I’ll bite.

58 - Zach Allen BC DT
90 - Hooker
128 - Isaiah Johnson
136 - Hardman

 

[bodi]

58 - Thornhill or Nasir Adderley - S
90- Gerald Willis DT
128 Dennis Daley, OT
148 Charles Omenihu DE

Jalen Hurd, WR

 

[Alexander]

2(58) Jerry Tillery, DT, Notre Dame
3(90) Darnell Savage, FS, Maryland
4(128) Mecole Hardman, WR, Georgia
4(136) Ben Bonogu, DE, TCU

 

[kiheikiwi]

I'm in...as of today
#58 - Jaun Thornhill - S.
#90 - Trayvon Mullen - CB.
#128 - Khalen Saunders - DT.
#136 - David Sills - WR.

 

[Sandyf]

58. Juan Thornhill S Virginia
90. Anthony Nelson DE Iowa
128. Renell Wren DT Arizona State
136. Miles Boykin WR Notre Dame
165. Dawson Knox TE Mississippi

Frankly believe going to make 2 or 3 trades and end up with at least couple extra 4ths to add Isaiah Johnson CB and Dave Edwards OT.

 

[Kolemmitt]

58. Juan Thornhill S Virginia
90. Anthony Nelson DE Iowa
128. Renell Wren DT Arizona State
136. Miles Boykin WR Notre Dame
165. Dawson Knox TE Mississippi

Frankly believe going to make 2 or 3 trades and end up with at least couple extra 4ths to add Isaiah Johnson CB and Dave Edwards OT.

I like it, but no way we get Knox at 165.

 

[unionjack8]

2(58) Hakeem Butler
3(90) Darnell Savage
4(128) Dawson Knox
4(136) Joe Jackson

 

[Kolemmitt]

58: Thornhill
90: Knox
128: Daylon Mack
136: Jordan Brown
165: Eli Udoh
241: Alexander Mattison

Thornhill starts this year. Knox is our #2 TE by the end of the year. Mattison is our #2 back.

Mack, Brown, and Udoh are projects that push to start in 2020.

 

[Alexander]

136: Jordan Brown

 

[Kolemmitt]

Not a fan?

 

[Alexander]

Not a fan?

You are talking the South Dakota State corner, right?

I would think the kid is not among the top 150 in this draft.

 

[Killerinstinct]

58 Thornhill FS
90 Andy Isabella WR
128 Renell Wren DT
136 Isaia Johnson CB
165 Bryce Love RB
241 Ulysees Gilbert III LB

 

[Alexander]

58 Thornhill FS
90 Andy Isabella WR
128 Renell Wren DT
136 Isaia Johnson CB
165 Bryce Love RB
241 Ulysees Gilbert III LB

I have dug in a lot more on Isabella and what they say about his catch radius and body catching is very very true.

You better have a QB that can drill it into his chest on most throws.

Gilbert is a good one. Like him later on though.

 

[Beaker42]

2(58) Hakeem Butler
3(90) Darnell Savage
4(128) Dawson Knox
4(136) Joe Jackson

Joe Jackson - are we really going out with him?

 

[Beaker42]

2(58) Jerry Tillery, DT, Notre Dame
3(90) Darnell Savage, FS, Maryland
4(128) Mecole Hardman, WR, Georgia
4(136) Ben Bonogu, DE, TCU

If we don’t go my 4 picks I could live with yours.

 

[Beaker42]

2(58) Hakeem Butler
3(90) Darnell Savage
4(128) Dawson Knox
4(136) Joe Jackson

Nice combo - don’t know much about Joe Jackson

 

[Western]

58 -- Khalen Saunders DT
90 -- Chauncey Gardner-Johnson CB/S
128 -- Devin Singletary RB
136 -- Tytus Howard OT

 

[timb2]

58-Porter Gustin(6'-5,260 lbs) OLB/DE USC



90-Kavontae Turpin(5'-8",166 lbs) WR/Returner TCU



128-James Williams(5'-11",195 lbs) RB Washington State



136-Jalen Dalton(6'-6",295 lbs) DT North Carolina