Who's acting brand new? Yes, the script is written ahead of time and the QB gets too much praise and too much blame. Yeah, you got your Romo stans or whatever, but a truly objective fan will know that the Romo doesn't throw for 300 yards, 4 TDs, or whatever without someone on the receiving end, without some halfway decent blocking, without the run game at least looking average.
I think the issue is that instead of looking to Romo to praise/blame first, that folks should take a macro look at the offense as a whole. Folks mad at Romo because of a bad throw, then article comes out next day, receiver ran wrong route. It's happened too many times to count. When Romo truly spits the bit, it's usually not much of a debate when it happens.