Hostile, how about shawn mcdonald how much to give up for him?

[cowboyjoe]

Hostile, here are shawn mcdonalds stats, i know your high on roy williams or you were at some points, but roy had like 5 drops last week, some big passes too

here is mcdonalds stats
84 McDONALD Shawn 5- 8.6 178 4.44 543.14

and i point to what terry glenn was a small fast wr, and as you know wes welker was small too and did good his first year in new england,

and if you remember shawn springs cb for Commanders said what gave him fits, was small wrs that were quick and fast,

would mcdonald fit that bill for the cowboys and how high a draft pick would the cowboys have to give up to get him;

i still think miiles austin is about ready to turn the corner, but i also remember what welker did for the patriots as a quick fast wr, so what do you think hostile and other zoners

 

[tomson75]

I don't think that Hostile is going to agree with your 'like 5 drops' theory.

Could you format those stats to be a little clearer?

 

[CrazyCowboy]

we already have similiar players on our bench.

 

[dadymat]

we already have similiar players on our bench.

agreed

 

[DaBoys4Life]

Roy Williams or no1 unless it's Calvin Johnson Shawn mcdonald = trash.

 

[cowboyjoe]

84 McDONALD Shawn 5- 8.6 178 4.44 543.14


Shawn McDonald is 5-8 1/3 weighs 178 with 4.44 in the 40, not sure what the others stats are for. probably his rating as a wr.

 

[cowboyjoe]

here is wes welkers stats in comparison to mcdonald
83 WELKER Wes. 5- 8.2 191 4.55 731.65
84 McDONALD Shawn 5- 8.6 178 4.44

 

[cowboyjoe]

I am not saying that mcdonald is a great wr, but what if he could be and was in the wrong sytem this year, if you remember last year, shawn mcdonald was lighting up the nfl best to my memory

 

[CATCH17]

I'd rather see what Miles can do through out this season.

His potential is sky high.

 

[cowboyjoe]

i think thats what jerry jones wants to do, i just listened to his weekly jerry jones edition and he basically said that miles austin is stepping up and stanback is really stepping up and jerry wants to see stanback on the field,

 

[Rampage]

McDonald has a lot of drops too.

 

[jobberone]

I'd rather see what Miles can do through out this season.

His potential is sky high.

No doubt Miles is fast. I don't think he has the quicks though. We don't have that player unless you're counting Danny Amendola who has the quicks but is too slow IMO.

 

[jobberone]

i think thats what jerry jones wants to do, i just listened to his weekly jerry jones edition and he basically said that miles austin is stepping up and stanback is really stepping up and jerry wants to see stanback on the field,

That's a good thing. I'd love for Miles and Stanback to take off. There is definitely room for a WR to step up and make plays during games.

 

[CATCH17]

No doubt Miles is fast. I don't think he has the quicks though. We don't have that player unless you're counting Danny Amendola who has the quicks but is too slow IMO.

I disagree.

For a guy who is 6'3 he is pretty darn agile.

Hes got the Wiggle, Speed, and work ethic to become a really good player.

He plays like a big Terry Glenn. Now we just need to get him the ball more.

 

[tomson75]

I disagree.

For a guy who is 6'3 he is pretty darn agile.

Hes got the Wiggle, Speed, and work ethic to become a really good player.

He plays like a big Terry Glenn. Now we just need to get him the ball more.

He's very agile. Pretty fast...but I don't think he has Glenn-like quickness either. A few of our practice squad guys have had it in the last few years, but they obviously lacked in other areas. I don't see him as a slot guy.

 

[Rudy]

Why does everyone ask Hostile these questions?? Is he Stephen Jones or own a crystal ball? I don't get it. Somebody fill me in.

 

[big dog cowboy]

we already have similiar players on our bench.

That is what it really boils down to.

We need a #1 WR and McDonald isn't one.

 

[Common Sense]

here is wes welkers stats in comparison to mcdonald
83 WELKER Wes. 5- 8.2 191 4.55 731.65
84 McDONALD Shawn 5- 8.6 178 4.44

What significance does that have in relation to anything?

 

[dbair1967]

if we gave up a bag of peanuts for Shaun McDonald, I'd be ticked

he couldnt help our team one iota

 

[CATCH17]

He's very agile. Pretty fast...but I don't think he has Glenn-like quickness either. A few of our practice squad guys have had it in the last few years, but they obviously lacked in other areas. I don't see him as a slot guy.

Well of course not. He is 6'3 220, not 5'10 200.

But for a guy his size you couldn't ask for him to be much more agile.