How college players should think about being drafted

playmakers

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,238
Reaction score
154
With the salaries for college players in the NFL draft at an all time high, wouldnt you think that those players will become more selfish. Matter in fact, it would be an intellgent move by the player.

Say USC was playing Texas Tech and coming into the game Michael Crabtree was the player coaches mostly gameplan around. So Tech's coach goes up to Crabtree and tells him "This week we will not throw you one ball. Were going to use you as a decoy the entire game." So Crabtree goes into that game and catches 1 ball for 7 yards.

Now we fast forward and the draft is here. We are full speed ahead in evaluating talent. Michael Crabtree's name comes up to the likes of Mel Kiper, Todd Mcshay, Mike Mayock, Rich Eisen, etc and they all bring up the SC game. They ask the questions of "Where was he in the big game against USC? He let an average corner shut him down imagine what would happen when he gets to the NFL." Where does his draft stock go from here? Falling fast........

Draft day is here and Crabtree is taking in the late first round instead of the top 5 that he was orginally slated for. Instead of making 45 million for 6 years hes making about 16 million for 4. He just lost 30 million over a coaches decision to use him in a different way.

This is a fake scenario but its true. What if the coach tells the star player to be a decoy in half there games their senior year? What should he do when there's so much money to be had? Thats why college players should be greedy, selfish, and be bigger than the team. The NFL draft for 90 percent of them is there best chance at a pay day. If a coach wants them to be a decoy they should say no. Its not that I agree that players should be selfish but the system set up by the NFL encourages this. Isnt anyone suprised that the college game isnt ruined by now.

Another example, Ohio St is up 35-7 on Bowling Green at halftime. Coach tells his starters they're out of the game. Isnt this a chance to pad their stats? I know the injury factor is there but should a player be pulled if its going to cost them 100 yards and 2 scores? Not only this, there are more than one of these lop-sided games every year. In the end your costing a player probably 300 yards and 3 tds.

In closing, will college football become a "me/I" sport very soon if things are not changed? I ask the question if you were rated as a 1st round pick in the preseason by the experts, would you be a decoy the entire year if the coach asked you to knowing its going to cost yourself millions of dollars later? Also, if a highley totued college player straight up comes out and says he would not play hurt or second fiddle until he gets into the NFL, would that bother you. Jorge Julio is a prime example of this. When he comes out hes going to be a top 5 pick. If he said some quotes like that would you blame him. If he plays hurt all season his numbers would suffer and eventually lowering his draft status and costing him money. What would you do????
 

SaltwaterServr

Blank Paper Offends Me
Messages
8,124
Reaction score
1
This might be all a moot set of scenarios after the new CBA is negotiated. Owners will probably push very hard to get a rookie salary cap or salary pool as the NBA enjoys.

If you blow a top 5 pick, you're really hurting the franchise for years with the salary those picks get. How long did San Diego suffer as a franchise after the Ryan Leaf debacle?

Regardless, players outside of the top 10-15 picks are playing for their second payday in 3-4 years, at least it was that way in the past with the CBA structure.

The contra to my points is that the average player's career in the NFL is what, like two years now. They need to get what they can before injury or the next draft class knocks them out of the league.
 

THUMPER

Papa
Messages
9,522
Reaction score
61
That's an interesting scenario but I'm not sure what can be done about it. College sports have become the minor leagues for the pros these days anyway in both football and basketball. Players are not just concerned with winning games but with looking good and increasing their draft value and their earning power.

I don't know how much college coaches play into that or if some of them are even aware of it. They do have a measure of effect on a player's future though.

Good question but I don't know that there is an acceptable answer to it. I will just say this: the money professional athletes make these days has ruined sports in general. You can write that off as the "old guy" talking but it is the truth. Again, there is no real remedy to it at this point, it is what it is, but it still sucks.
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
I don't think NFL GMs, coaches and scouts are going to rely on the comments from the likes of Mel Kiper, Todd Mcshay, Mike Mayock, Rich Eisen, etc. They are going to research what went on for someone like Crabtree to only catch one pass in your example. They will watch game tape. They will ask the coaches. They will talk to Crabtree. I am confident that good organizations would figure out pretty easily that there was a specific game plan to use Crabtree as a decoy where as the talking head analysts would not.
 

Rogah

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,473
Reaction score
793
playmakers;2740088 said:
With the salaries for college players in the NFL draft at an all time high, wouldnt you think that those players will become more selfish. Matter in fact, it would be an intellgent move by the player.

Say USC was playing Texas Tech and coming into the game Michael Crabtree was the player coaches mostly gameplan around. So Tech's coach goes up to Crabtree and tells him "This week we will not throw you one ball. Were going to use you as a decoy the entire game." So Crabtree goes into that game and catches 1 ball for 7 yards.

Now we fast forward and the draft is here. We are full speed ahead in evaluating talent. Michael Crabtree's name comes up to the likes of Mel Kiper, Todd Mcshay, Mike Mayock, Rich Eisen, etc and they all bring up the SC game. They ask the questions of "Where was he in the big game against USC? He let an average corner shut him down imagine what would happen when he gets to the NFL." Where does his draft stock go from here? Falling fast........
Michael Crabtree is, IMHO, one of the best college WR's to play in the past 10 years. No college coach is going to take his tremendous talent and say "sure he's the best WR in college football, and sure USC is playing him in single coverage with some mediocre cornerback, but let's use him as a decoy (even though he's not decoying anyone) and not throw the ball to him."

Plus coaches want their star players to develop into highly touted, top draft picks. It helps a coach out if he can go to some high school prospect and say "look what I did for Michael Crabtree - he was drafted #4 overall. Play for me and we can do the same for you."
playmakers;2740088 said:
Another example, Ohio St is up 35-7 on Bowling Green at halftime. Coach tells his starters they're out of the game. Isnt this a chance to pad their stats? I know the injury factor is there but should a player be pulled if its going to cost them 100 yards and 2 scores? Not only this, there are more than one of these lop-sided games every year. In the end your costing a player probably 300 yards and 3 tds.
This is a much more plausible scenario, but you have to understand this isn't the 1960's where teams would get a pamphlet on college seniors and then literally draft guys they had never seen play. NFL scouting has evolved into a full time 24/7/365 job. Believe me, they know how much a player played, who he got his stats against, how much he sat out, etc, etc. If Ohio State has a 35-7 lead at halftime, chances are that their star QB/RB/WR/whatever has already had a nice day statistically. So resting up for most of the 2nd half is not really going to count against him.
 

NextGenBoys

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,252
Reaction score
1,964
joseephuss;2740183 said:
I don't think NFL GMs, coaches and scouts are going to rely on the comments from the likes of Mel Kiper, Todd Mcshay, Mike Mayock, Rich Eisen, etc. They are going to research what went on for someone like Crabtree to only catch one pass in your example. They will watch game tape. They will ask the coaches. They will talk to Crabtree. I am confident that good organizations would figure out pretty easily that there was a specific game plan to use Crabtree as a decoy where as the talking head analysts would not.

Lol exactly.

This is comical. These so called "scouts" on TV are making people believe that they really are scouts and that they have inside information.

There are actual scouts who are going to be able to tell if he is used as a decoy and what he did when he was asked to perform.
 
Top