How would you rank Meredith, Staubach, White, Aikman, Romo?

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by Zordon, Oct 10, 2013.

  1. DWhite Fan

    DWhite Fan It ain't over 'til it's over

    5,753 Messages
    438 Likes Received
    Imagine if Claiborne gave up a TD like Walls did to cost Dallas a trip to the Super Bowl...
     
  2. Pessimist_cowboy

    Pessimist_cowboy Well-Known Member

    10,429 Messages
    11,135 Likes Received
    Staubach
    Romo
    Aikman
    Meredith
    White
     
    SDCowboy likes this.
  3. tantrix1969

    tantrix1969 Well-Known Member

    963 Messages
    450 Likes Received
    this is how I would rank them
     
  4. rcaldw

    rcaldw Well-Known Member

    7,067 Messages
    1,181 Likes Received
    lol, enough said... you just have to lol
     
    TrailBlazer likes this.
  5. bayeslife

    bayeslife 187beatdown

    9,074 Messages
    7,801 Likes Received
    Aikman is really hard to rank and judge because he really never had to do much here besides hand the ball off.
     
  6. CanadianCowboysFan

    CanadianCowboysFan Lightning Rod

    20,898 Messages
    4,760 Likes Received
    ouch, I shudder
     
  7. Diogenes

    Diogenes Well-Known Member

    1,247 Messages
    76 Likes Received
    Yup, that's how Irvin got into the HOF. By Troy handing him the football.
     
  8. ABQCOWBOY

    ABQCOWBOY Regular Joe....

    55,650 Messages
    23,811 Likes Received
    Where does this stuff come from? I mean, seriously, I don't understand it.
     
    pjtoadie likes this.
  9. NYFan

    NYFan New Member

    15 Messages
    4 Likes Received
    Yes he will. Not by the Romo haters he won't, but by the real Cowboys fans he will.
     
  10. Fredd

    Fredd Well-Known Member

    4,995 Messages
    2,238 Likes Received
    Staubach, Aikman.......drop off....Romo.....enormous drop off....White, Dandy Don
     
    pjtoadie and LittleBoyBlue like this.
  11. tecolote

    tecolote Well-Known Member

    2,038 Messages
    1,196 Likes Received
    One big disadvantage that Tony has with the other QBs is that they had Tom Landry and Jimmy Johnson as head coaches and he has had Wade Phillips and Jason Garrett. That's huge.
     
    john van brocklin likes this.
  12. dart

    dart Benched

    811 Messages
    31 Likes Received
    THIS
     
  13. TrailBlazer

    TrailBlazer Well-Known Member

    5,569 Messages
    3,152 Likes Received
    A fan who appreciates success would not rank romo ahead of roger, aikman. A fan who is more concerned with regular season stats instead of superbowls might.
     
    tantrix1969 likes this.
  14. ABQCOWBOY

    ABQCOWBOY Regular Joe....

    55,650 Messages
    23,811 Likes Received
    Yes and no IMO. Yes, in that Coach Landry and Jimmy were oriented towards very balanced Offenses. They played much more into Field Position and other concepts that lend themselves towards helping the Defense but not necessarily providing the Offense with more opportunities.

    No in that Tony, under Phillips and Garrett, not so much. Basically, while not as accomplished coaches, Tony has benefited from having much more control over the Offense then he would ever have had under Jimmy or Coach Landry and much more opportunity to throw. Statistically, it's helped him a lot IMO.
     
    jobberone and PA Cowboy Fan like this.
  15. 5Stars

    5Stars Here comes the Sun...

    29,358 Messages
    4,338 Likes Received
    Romo
    Aikman
    Staubach
    White
    Meredith

    I put the order in chronological order. That is just to confuse the discussion of who was the best.

    The only reason I put Romo at the top is because the Cowboys don't have the other four.

    And the other four did not have the teams that Romo plays on, and Romo has not played on teams that those other greats played with. But all of them played, and are playing for the Dallas Cowboys.
     
  16. LittleBoyBlue

    LittleBoyBlue Redvolution

    35,737 Messages
    8,367 Likes Received
    Lol funnneeee
     
  17. tecolote

    tecolote Well-Known Member

    2,038 Messages
    1,196 Likes Received
    You are right about that. But as far as wins and losses go, it's the other way around.
     
  18. Diogenes

    Diogenes Well-Known Member

    1,247 Messages
    76 Likes Received
    Well the question was "how" would you rank them so I suppose chronologically is just as good as any.
     
  19. joseephuss

    joseephuss Well-Known Member

    26,698 Messages
    5,595 Likes Received
    Everson did pick off two of Montana's passes that day and almost had a third.
     
  20. 5Stars

    5Stars Here comes the Sun...

    29,358 Messages
    4,338 Likes Received
    You can't compare what happened between times. There is no way to say which of those greats are the best. But, it's really nice to have the one that we have.

    The problem with Romo is that...he wastes to much time with Candice! Romo's mind is not right, now. He has no smarts, he is rich, and, he is the QB of the Dallas Cowboys! Stay away from him...
     

Share This Page