Hypothetical Draft Situation... Calvin Johnson, Joe Thomas, Adrian Peterson, other?

[tyke1doe]

Okay, here the Cowboys sit at the No. 1 position in the 2007 draft. Who would you want to see them take?

Joe Thomas - definitely fills a need.
Calvin Johnson - not necessarily a need but having him ready to go when TO and Glenn leave would be ripe.
Adrian Peterson - he probably finds his way to daylight quicker than JJ.
Brady Quinn - in case Romo is a one-year wonder.

I'm divided between Calvin Johnson - once in a life-time prospect, a TO without the baggage - and Joe Thomas - would anchor the line for 10 years.

But I'm gonna have to go with Calvin Johnson. If he's the next TO, which I think he is, I'd gotta go with him. I don't know if JT is the next Anthony Munoz.

 

[mullet]

calvin johnson - no question.

 

[Portland Fanatic]

I trade down to the 3rd spot and draft Joe Thomas, then take Meachem with my other 1st round pick.

The we still have our pick at #22...

This is of course a dream scenario

 

[Hostile]

I don't even hesitate to take Calvin Johnson.

 

[Avery]

CJ is the best player in this draft and does fill a certain need as Glenn and Owens aren't getting any younger.

Next would be Thomas followed by Peterson then Quinn.

Where's Sidney Rice?

 

[carphalen5150]

I trade down to the 3rd spot and draft Joe Thomas, then take Meachem with my other 1st round pick.

The we still have our pick at #22...

This is of course a dream scenario

You trade beyond 2 and you watch Det take Thomas.

 

[cobra]

Calvin Johnson. And wouldn't think twice.

Assuming he dropped out of the draft, then I would seriously consider taking Brady Quinn over Joe Thomas.

If all three dropped out, I would trade out of the #1 spot.

 

[philo beddoe]

Peterson, of course, he's an OU guy.

 

[cobra]

Where's Sidney Rice?

In the 2nd round where he belongs.

 

[superpunk]

I said it before and I'll say it again - Ryan Leaf is a can't miss prospect. Him or Akili Smith - and I never look back.

 

[Doomsday101]

I said it before and I'll say it again - Ryan Leaf is a can't miss prospect. Him or Akili Smith - and I never look back.

I also recall Dallas being called stupid for taking Troy instead of a certain offensive line man. Another can't miss. :laugh2:

 

[Cowboy4ever]

Okay, here the Cowboys sit at the No. 1 position in the 2007 draft. Who would you want to see them take?

Joe Thomas - definitely fills a need.
Calvin Johnson - not necessarily a need but having him ready to go when TO and Glenn leave would be ripe.
Adrian Peterson - he probably finds his way to daylight quicker than JJ.
Brady Quinn - in case Romo is a one-year wonder.

I'm divided between Calvin Johnson - once in a life-time prospect, a TO without the baggage - and Joe Thomas - would anchor the line for 10 years.

But I'm gonna have to go with Calvin Johnson. If he's the next TO, which I think he is, I'd gotta go with him. I don't know if JT is the next Anthony Munoz.

Well my first thought is. . how do we know he won't have the TO baggage? When did TO become TO,, it wasn't his rookie year.

Second.. if you have the 1st pick in the draft, more than likely your team sucks. So you take the very best player and build around him. The only exception would be if you picked 1st the year before.. you don't take the same position. IE, you wouldn't take 2 QB's with number 1's in back to back drafts.

 

[superpunk]

The only exception would be if you picked 1st the year before.. you don't take the same position. IE, you wouldn't take 2 QB's with number 1's in back to back drafts.

http://img186.*************/img186/8413/millenbigboardcopyjy3.jpg

 

[ZeroClub]

I'd have to give JaMarcus Russell very serious consideration.

If I liked his interview and intangibles, I'd go with him.

 

[Hoofbite]

Peterson, of course, he's an OU guy.

Im sure that would fit nicely in your dreams with Ricky Ray and Bob Stoops....

 

[YosemiteSam]

Hmm. Joe Thomas. Offenise line is always first. If you have a pro-bowl level left tackle for the next 10 years, the rest is cake.

 

[Maikeru-sama]

Calvin Johnson would immediately allow us to get rid of Terrell Owens, if not this year but definately next year.

No way we get this guy, but if he is there you pull the trigger without hessitation.

 

[mmillman]

I would trade down in a position to draft Johnson. Dallas is going to be drafting late first round for a few years anyway and the success rate there isn't very good. Not many times you have a chance to add a potential Randy Moss without the attitude.

 

[Dday22t]

Calvin Johnson

 

[jay cee]

That's a good post. I think I would take Johnson, because in those circumstances, I would rather go with the guy that puts points on the board.

Now if you just had pure garbage at the tackle position, maybe you do go with Thomas.