"Has accomplished more than so and so"
Blake Bottles has been to the AFC championship and has more playoff wins than Dak.
That must mean that Blake Bottles is a Winner, and well perhaps he has the It factor too. Those two reason on why Dak is the guy that his supporters keep flaunting are way overly abused. An Average quarterback can win on a talented team. Dak came in on a very talented team and was instantly successful. That was before he was figured out and his dink and dunk was very effective. There is nothing wrong with dinking and dunking btw, like others pointed out Brady can make a living off of that. The difference is that Brady has the ability to start throwing it deep on will and other teams know this about him and respect his deep game. Dak on the other hand players from other teams came out and bragged about how their defensive coordinator made them watch tape and that they had figured out Dak and that he can't throw it deep. That is being disrespected right there. I thought this year team was a quarterback away from being able to get to the super bowl. The Winner thing also is a thing of perspective. some people care about regular season wins, while others care about winning in the playoffs, and we have yet to get to a championship game after decades of waiting. Shoots Dak is a winner to some people for winning the week 17 team against one of the worst teams in the NFL in a game that the giants should want to lose and the Cowboy's didn't need to win.
Then there is the whole "IT" factor that is often times abused. I saw the "IT" factor in 2016, but I haven't seen it since. And I guess people define "IT" differently and so they can say Dak has it no mater what? Is the "IT" factor that dak sometimes takes the moment into his own hands and does something special? Yeah that is one of his good traits, but he hasn't been doing it every game. I guess he looks amazing, highlights film worthy to some people in all games. But to me in many of those wins he looked average this year, and I keep seeing him miss some very open receivers with very badly thrown balls. And then the dak crowd will say that every QB misses receivers, but I guess there are different levels of ugliness in missing to.