It's what I've been saying for a while. I don't think it was Sturm that showed me those stats, somebody else that I can't remember. And I started to see it badly in games. As ScipioCowboy said, he really don't have that cutback move. What I see a lot of defenses doing with McFadden is that they will figure out what side the ball is going to be run towards and slant hard that way. The O-Line has to reach block and try to shove them that way. In order for the play to work, the RB has to cut back and DMC just doesn't have that and it usually ends up for a short game.
I don't think DMC is a bad RB at all. But, he's not a good fit for this scheme. We can re-work things by using more man blocking, but it doesn't make us as diverse with where we run. We become a much more in between the tackles team that favors left side instead of running left or right and inside or outside the tackles.
YR