Is M. Collins who we thought he would be

JoeyBoy718

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,715
Reaction score
12,709
2018 Starting Defense

WDE - Lawrence
3DT - Collins
1DT - FA
SDE - Irving

WLB - Lee
MLB - Hitchens
SLB - Smith

CB1 - FA
CB2 - Lewis
CB3 - Jones
CB4 - Brown

FS - Woods
SS - Awuzie
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
40,028
Reaction score
37,176
Cowboys have given up big rushing days this season. I believe that starts up front and not with Sean Lee.

Rams, Eagles, Pack all approached two hundred yards rushing on the Cowboys and the Broncos were over a 150.(with Sean Lee)

Cowboys only allowed ONE team to rush for over hundred last season and that was in the throwaway finale.

They make a mistake in thinking Collins could handle the tackle duties?

I think Collins got overhyped some last year because he was solid at 3-tech, but benefited sackwise from some stunt plays where he was freed up to attack the QB. He was playing solid but not spectacular at the position before Irving came back and showed the kind of penetration you need from the 1-tech.

Collins was switched to 1-tech and has not been a problem there since they decided to let him use his quickness to draw the double instead of just sitting there and absorbing it. Philly's running game took advantage of Irving's aggressiveness by trapping him and the fact that the linebackers weren't recognizing what was happening and getting there.

That's where we miss Lee. If Collins is doing his job as the 1-tech, then the linebackers (particularly the WLB) should be free to flow to the play. In this scheme, Irving was doing what he was supposed to by getting upfield, but the linebacker wasn't filling behind him.

Lee's ability to diagnose allows him to get in position to either make the play or alter it. There were multiple times where our linebackers came up to fill, but they didn't recognize where the play was going so they filled and got caught up in traffic.
 

Dwight

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,554
Reaction score
3,413
2018 Starting Defense

WDE - Lawrence
3DT - Collins
1DT - FA
SDE - Irving

WLB - Lee
MLB - Hitchens
SLB - Smith

CB1 - FA
CB2 - Lewis
CB3 - Jones
CB4 - Brown

FS - Woods
SS - Awuzie

I would not be pleased with that LB core. That’s repeating history. Defense would have the same issues at LB again.

Lee needs two LBs to help him.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
This defensive scheme is flawed against the run. It relies on smart, stout and physically superior players in order to maintain success over an extended period of time.

The line is instructed to slant and hit a designated gap based on offensive alignment. Each player picks a side of the offensive lineman in front of them to run through and they do with reckless abandon. The LBs do the same, pretty much. They each have a hole to fill and if there is a lineman in the hole when they get there, they have to stack and shed AND most importantly, stay in that hole. They make the play if it’s there to make. If not, they eliminate the cut back for the ball carrier.

Ideally, there is nowhere for the ball carrier to go because there is a defender in every gap. That’s only if the linemen upfront win their battles and the LBs stay clean.

It heavily relies on winning individual battles and/or having a crazy amount of hustle on each play. That’s why we see so many substitutions on long drives.

With all that said, it’s not too hard to see why Rod Marinelli was available.

The defense is antiquated. The caliber of players you need for this defense to succeed are too expensive if you want to have a capable offense. The bulk of our salary cap is distributed amongst the offensive players so this whole system is just a bad idea for Big D.

Sean Lee on the field reading plays presnap like a 2017 Tony Romo is a great deodorant for this coaching staff. When he’s out this defense shows the flaws it’s supposed to show.

We need new coaches on both sides of the ball.

Sorry for the long post...

Never apologize for quality.

That was some great stuff.
:thumbup:
 

kiheikiwi

Maui No Ka Oi
Messages
3,530
Reaction score
2,538
Irving is too small to play 1-tech or even 3-tech. He's listed at 273 #. Even if he has added weight up to say 290 # he's still too small as a starting defensive tackle. He can use his quick first step and strength (for his size) when he comes in when we play the 3 man front, and occasional series but he cannot hold up against 320-330 # guards and centers for a whole game. Collins is an ideal 3-tech at 310 # with a wrestling background. Put a true nose next to him like Philly has with Jerringan and Cox and see what happens.
This not valuing a NT is bull---- ! And has been holding the defense back for years, if Rod can or wont see it - he has to go. It is plainly an Achilles heel for him.
We have plenty of faults on defense Maliek Collins is not one of them, put him back to his position at 3-tech and watch him flourish.
 

Floatyworm

The Labeled One
Messages
23,020
Reaction score
21,190
I guess the fact we have now a streak of 28 quarters of no offensive holding calls on our D-lineman has nothing to do with it.:rolleyes:
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
2018 Starting Defense

WDE - Lawrence
3DT - Collins
1DT - FA
SDE - Irving

WLB - Lee
MLB - Hitchens
SLB - Smith

CB1 - FA
CB2 - Lewis
CB3 - Jones
CB4 - Brown

FS - Woods
SS - Awuzie
We need to keep Irving at DE and draft/FA a 1T...... I hope someone gives us a 1st for Irving and RGregory stays clean

DLaw-MCollins-Draft3-Irving
Taco-TCrawford-FA-Tapper

LBs are OK but we need to put Lee back at MIKE and ride or die......Draft a MIKE

DWilson-Lee-Hitchens/JSmith

DBs are pretty set

CBs- Brown, Cheeto, Lewis, Scandrick
Safeties- BJones, Heath, Woods, Frazier

Oh yeah and replace Marinelli
 

armadillooutlaw

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,496
Reaction score
3,556
Collins has been fine. Watching the games again it's easy to see he's been very disruptive.
He does a good job pressuring the QB from the inside.
One of his best games was against the Chiefs.
4 pressures and managed to hold up on double teams.
He's undersized for a full-time 1T but he hasn't been that bad against the run.
Only reason they have him there is because Irving has been playing very well at the 3T and we have no viable NTs on the roster.
 
Top