Joe Horn vs Koren Robinson - Who's your choice?

dcfanatic

Benched
Messages
10,408
Reaction score
1
Since we keep hearing that Jerry may be getting a little desperate right now for a 2nd WR, and it seems he's making calls around the league, I was wondering who you guys would choose between Horn and Robinson.

Me, give me a young kid who has some quickness to his game like Koren Robinson over an older slowing down, known to open his mouth too much Horn every time.

What about you guys?
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Ugh!

Is there an option C?

We already have a receiver with a bone-on-bone knee!

:banghead:
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
dcfanatic;2129907 said:
Since we keep hearing that Jerry may be getting a little desperate right now for a 2nd WR, and it seems he's making calls around the league, I was wondering who you guys would choose between Horn and Robinson.

Me, give me a young kid who has some quickness to his game like Koren Robinson over an older slowing down, known to open his mouth too much Horn every time.

What about you guys?

If his drinking problem is under control then yes. As for Horn if Dallas gets him I would think it would only be for the season as a stop gap if Glenn is not with us.
 

malone1970

Member
Messages
158
Reaction score
0
Well if it came down to it I would choose Korean Robinson over Joe Horn for the simple fact that he is younger. But that is not to say that I don't think Joe Horn is not a bad choice, but I will always choose the younger person.
 

Yeagermeister

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,629
Reaction score
117
Hostile;2129926 said:
Diarrhea versus constipation.

Which would you prefer?

pepto_center_home_1.jpg
 

InmanRoshi

Zone Scribe
Messages
18,334
Reaction score
90
Once again, it's all about targeted pass attempts. We already have a "#2 WR" .. his name is Jason Witten.
 

Tovya

New Member
Messages
777
Reaction score
0
dcfanatic;2129907 said:
Since we keep hearing that Jerry may be getting a little desperate right now for a 2nd WR, and it seems he's making calls around the league, I was wondering who you guys would choose between Horn and Robinson.

Me, give me a young kid who has some quickness to his game like Koren Robinson over an older slowing down, known to open his mouth too much Horn every time.

What about you guys?

I hate to say it, but I'd rather have Horn over Robinson.

Robinson being added to the roster is just too much... we don't need any more potential roster problems that Robinson stands to bring..

I think we should have a "one-bad-egg-a-year" policy. Let's focus on one comeback player per year.
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
I'd rather keep TO, Crayton, Glenn, Austin, Stanback, and Amendola.
 

iceberg

rock music matters
Messages
34,403
Reaction score
7,930
dcfanatic;2129907 said:
Since we keep hearing that Jerry may be getting a little desperate right now for a 2nd WR, and it seems he's making calls around the league, I was wondering who you guys would choose between Horn and Robinson.

Me, give me a young kid who has some quickness to his game like Koren Robinson over an older slowing down, known to open his mouth too much Horn every time.

What about you guys?

why are you making me want matt jones? i'd rather we just saw what we had. those guys will be there later. promise.
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
40,009
Reaction score
37,151
Why would anyone choose Robinson over Horn? Just because of age?

Robinson has had one good season in a career that is mostly marked by his off-the-field problems. (Sounds like someone else we've got on the team, but that's about where the similarities end.)

Robinson was arrested for drunk driving in May, 2005, and pleaded guilty to one count of driving under the influence. Prior to this he had also been suspended four games for violating the substance abuse policy in 2004 and completed an offseason alcohol rehabilitation program. He was subsequently released by the Seahawks. On August 1, 2005, Robinson checked himself into a 28-day alcohol rehabilitation program in South Carolina. Afterwards, Robinson was acquired by the Vikings for the 2005 season.

On Tuesday August 16th, 2006 during the 2006 pre-season it was reported that Robinson was again arrested and incarcerated for "driving while impaired". Robinson was released by the Vikings on Saturday August 26, 2006 [1]. The Vikings' decision resulted in Robinson and his agent filing a union grievance since the collective bargaining agreement prohibits teams from releasing players for disciplinary reasons. [2] On January 23, 2007 Robinson reached a deal with prosecutors to be sentenced on a single felony charge of fleeing police after leading officers on a high-speed chase in August, 2006. In exchange for Robinson's Alford plea, prosecutors dismissed seven lesser charges related to drunken driving, reckless driving and driving without a license.[3]

On February 20, 2007 Robinson was sentenced to 90 days in jail for fleeing police in August of 2006. He served the sentence at the same time he serves 90 days for violating his probation in a separate drunken-driving case in Kirkland, Wash., last year. Robinson will be on probation for three years and must also must complete 80 hours of community service and pay a $1,500 fine.[4] On October 17, 2007 Robinson was reinstated with the NFL.[2] He resumed practicing with the Green Bay Packers immediately.[3] Since August, 2007 he had been training in Arizona with Brett Favre's personal trainer, Ken Croner, in preparation for reinstatement. [4] On October 30, 2007, Robinson was activated by the Packers to fill a roster spot vacated by DeShawn Wynn, who was placed on injured reserve.

Horn has had no off-the-field problems and has proven himself on the field. I understand that he's getting old and his skills are in decline, but I'd take a proven vet any day over a troubled player who has athletic ability but has accomplished very little with it. (With Robinson we'd be taking on a high risk with potentially very little reward based on his previous performances.)

I'm not enamored with either player, but I do believe that Horn for the right price could be a decent addition to the team (if we part ways with Terry Glenn). He's a former star who could thrive in a fairly nondemanding role, since Owens and Witten are going to get the bulk of the receptions.
 
Top