Marion Barber Vs. Brandon Jacobs

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Not only do we have the better player but we can actually be proud of our RB.

I wouldnt be shocked if Tom Coughlin hated the guy too and tried to trade him.
Hes way overpaid and excels at nothing. And they have Bradshaw and a 4th round RB coming off an injury next year.

 

[DaBoys4Life]

Doubt Coughlin would trade him can't get much for him. But I can see them going RB early.

 

[dmq]

2.4, 3.4, 3.6

That is the yds per carry MB3 has averaged the last 3 games.Jacobs isn't any better, but I wouldn't exactly be holding Marion up as the standard to living up to a contract.

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

2.4, 3.4, 3.6

That is the yds per carry MB3 has averaged the last 3 games.Jacobs isn't any better, but I wouldn't exactly be holding Marion up as the standard to living up to a contract.

Fun. Now do just the odd weeks.

 

[AmericasTeam31]

2.4, 3.4, 3.6

That is the yds per carry MB3 has averaged the last 3 games.Jacobs isn't any better, but I wouldn't exactly be holding Marion up as the standard to living up to a contract.

He's like 27th in the league in RB's in terms of salary cap numbers... that's all that matters... What Jerry paid him in bonuses and what not doesn't and shouldn't matter to a fan... with a cap number of 2.6 million I'm happy with what he brings to the table every week!

Jacobs cap number is 5.6 million! Who is living up to their contract?

 

[Idgit]

2.4, 3.4, 3.6

That is the yds per carry MB3 has averaged the last 3 games.Jacobs isn't any better, but I wouldn't exactly be holding Marion up as the standard to living up to a contract.

You got to pay attention to the plays called and the field position if you're going to criticize a part-time back for YPC over just a three game stretch. Especially when we all know that at least 6 of those carries were goal line touches.

 

[johnny utah]

I believe they are both both very equal in talent and effectiveness. I also think they are both overrated. That being said, I would take MB3 anyday over loud mouth Jacobs.

 

[Sarge]

I think the Giants will be addressing RB in the draft this year and I see Bradshaw getting more involved next year. Jacobs is really no threat.