McCarthy gives his Top 5 QB list

[DallasInDC]

Do you believe Dak is a top 10 QB All Time?

He may not be a top 10 QB of all time, but I am sure as hell that he is much closer to that than where you have him ranked.

 

[Havic]

so the fact Mahomes is playing with an 80 year old TE and a bunch of nobodies doesnt impact Mahomes? Not one GM in all of football would take Jones over Mahomes. Stupid list.... but it gets clicks.

True but it isn’t who has had the better career it’s who’s playing their best football right now. Jones may not even be in the top 10 once the season concludes, who knows

 

[Reid1boys]

True but it isn’t who has had the better career it’s who’s playing their best football right now. Jones may not even be in the top 10 once the season concludes, who knows

Mahomes played awesome last week, and lost.

 

[WillieBeamen]

What YOU talking about???? Are you out of the loop? Been watching Any Given Sunday too many times???? Your avatar.

Dak is definitely in most people's Top 5.

LOL

 

[kskboys]

so the fact Mahomes is playing with an 80 year old TE and a bunch of nobodies doesnt impact Mahomes? Not one GM in all of football would take Jones over Mahomes. Stupid list.... but it gets clicks.

Not that hard, dude. This list is who is doing better RIGHT NOW. It's not about who's better for their career.

 

[RonnieT24]

so the fact Mahomes is playing with an 80 year old TE and a bunch of nobodies doesnt impact Mahomes? Not one GM in all of football would take Jones over Mahomes. Stupid list.... but it gets clicks.

Wait hold the phone.. Are you saying that a QB not having quality targets impacts his play? Nooo waaaaay!!!

 

[sbuscha]

Dak fans goal in life is to downplay the importance of the QB position.

And the Dak haters’ main goal? To promote supposed “inefficiencies” in Dak’s game (you can Google the definition of inefficiency if you need to). Funny how hard it’s been to find any poor play from him this year, huh?

Why is it that you constantly pop up in Dak threads but disappear when there’s actual football discussion going on? You really need to give it a rest. I’ll take the opinion of an NFL coach who’s worked with legends like Favre and Rodgers over that of a Philly internet troll any day.

Look at that post count climbing

 

[BoysForLife]

lmao

A pro Dak opinion column from the guy who got fired to make room for Brian Schottenheimer and you act like it's some big flex.

and you describe Dak critics as "weird"?

 

[America's Cowboy]

why do you keep saying things like this?

be happy that he isn't stinking it up thus far.

Why does the truth bother you, ESPECIALLY IF YOU ARE A SUPPOSED DALLAS COWBOYS FAN???

Damn, you guys suck! No other team's fans berate their own franchise star QB the way y'all do. It's pathetic. Y'all have a mental problem. Seriously.

 

[Qcard]

QB's are dependent on the talent around them. It is not the other way around.

Imagine a Dak Hater in an NFL locker room telling Grown Men they are being carried

Dak Haters are weirdos

QB's do not carry teams.

Dak Haters have been fed "QB carry team myth" by the TV Networks.....

They Need a Myth to embellish their World View...

 

[Rockport]

Yeah, based on Dak’s playoff performances I’d rather have one of our cheerleaders under center.

Well that shows your lack of knowledge.

 

[thunderpimp91]

The list is solid given the circumstances. From the entire segment they said they literally called McCarthy while he was dropping his kids off at school and had him name his top 5 of 2025 off the top of his head so this is not a well thought out list. He also talked up the value of efficiency and completion percentage. I didn't realize it until I looked it up but Daniel Jones is 3rd in the league in yards per attempt and 5th in completion percentage. From the criteria McCarthy put out there DJ fits the list.

 

[SportsGuru80]

I have Dak at 1 but I do not have a problem with this list.

 

[Reid1boys]

Wait hold the phone.. Are you saying that a QB not having quality targets impacts his play? Nooo waaaaay!!!

no, i wouldnt say that. The experts around here have made it clear that doesnt matter.

 

[Yobwocs]

Why does the truth bother you, ESPECIALLY IF YOU ARE A SUPPOSED DALLAS COWBOYS FAN???

Damn, you guys suck! No other team's fans berate their own franchise star QB the way y'all do. It's pathetic. Y'all have a mental problem. Seriously.

It's true. They act like they're normal and the whole of the NFL hates him. When it's just some extremists on this board. When you go to games theres usually more love for him than hate when Cowboys fans get together and talk about the current game that just happened.

 

[McKDaddy]

Why does the truth bother you, ESPECIALLY IF YOU ARE A SUPPOSED DALLAS COWBOYS FAN???

Damn, you guys suck! No other team's fans berate their own franchise star QB the way y'all do. It's pathetic. Y'all have a mental problem. Seriously.

Because it ISN'T THE TRUTH!!!

It's a point of view that you & maybe a couple others out of MILLIONS of Cowboys fans try to push. No one else believes it, thus it isn't "Clearly" the truth.

Damn, you guys suck!! No other teams fans try to push one player the way ya'll do. It's pathetic. Y'all have a mental problem. Seriously.

 

[McKDaddy]

Hoed Mahomes do in last year’s SB?

Better than any other QB outside the elite club would have done.

 

[starfan1]

Wait hold the phone.. Are you saying that a QB not having quality targets impacts his play? Nooo waaaaay!!!

It only matters when it isn’t Dak

 

[McKDaddy]

It's true. They act like they're normal and the whole of the NFL hates him. When it's just some extremists on this board. When you go to games theres usually more love for him than hate when Cowboys fans get together and talk about the current game that just happened.

How is saying he isn't playing the best hating him?

Literally, only one QB can be playing the best so are we hating everyone else also??

Stop posting things that have been proven a thousand time over that even the vast majority of Cowboy fans don't believe and being surprised when it's called out for being wrong.

 

[MarcusRock]

Some of it is entertaining at times but why do y'all do this over and over again? Just curious.