McGee not Romo, next quarterback to take the Cowboys to the Super Bowl

[vlad]

The lack of respect Romo gets is really amazing. His accomplishments on the field are pretty great. To complain that he hasn't won a playoff game yet (As if its all on him) is what is laughable.

I wonder if they could poll GM's anonymously how many would take Romo over their current starting QB.

Commanders
Minnesota
GB?
Tampa Bay
St Louis
SF
Sea?
Ari? (Age)
Det
Car
Buff
Mia
NYJ
Den
KC
Oak
Bal?
Cle
Hou
Jax
Ten

That seems like a pretty fair list to me.

 

[Aikbach]

Does this commentator have an Aggie in the family? Because College Station thought Reggie McNeil was better than Vince Young...I guess on a professional level the assessment was right or at least a tie.

If McGee proves himself starting material that boy is on the first train out of town for someone's first round draft pick in a blockbuster trade.

 

[Aikbach]

The lack of respect Romo gets is really amazing. His accomplishments on the field are pretty great. To complain that he hasn't won a playoff game yet (As if its all on him) is what is laughable.

I wonder if they could poll GM's anonymously how many would take Romo over their current starting QB.

Commanders
Minnesota
GB?
Tampa Bay
St Louis
SF
Sea?
Ari? (Age)
Det
Car
Buff
Mia
NYJ
Den
KC
Oak
Bal?
Cle
Hou
Jax
Ten

That seems like a pretty fair list to me.

He has the best winning percentage of any active QB that's started at least a full season.

Obviously Peyton manning runs a circle around him and Brady and Roethlisberger have a resume but other than that only Matt Ryan is the youthful contender I see that may eventually surpass him as the NFC's best quarterback.

My rankings

AFC

P.Manning
Brady
Roethlisberger
Garrard
Rivers
Cassell
Schaub
Palmer
Collins
Quinn
Flacco
Edwards
Pennington
Russell
Orton
Sanchez* (Rookie so withhold grade)


NFC

Romo
Cutler
Ryan
Brees
Rodgers
E.Manning
Warner
Delhomme
Garcia
McNabb
Hasselback
Bulger
Hill
Campbell
Jackson/ Favre
Stafford* (Rookie so withhold grade)