1. I am excited to announce the launch of ...
    NEWS and RUMORS is a powerful and versatile news and content search engine and reader that provides access to content from a large variety of sites.

    NEWS and RUMORS does not track individual users and uses a password-less login system so only an email address is required to login.

    Once logged in, you can add your favorite content feeds and searches to your Favorites list, bookmark content you want to read later, and find a lot of global, national and local content on a variety of topics.

    Dismiss Notice

Mike McCarthy's Analytics Fraud

Discussion in 'Fan Zone' started by Toruk_Makto, Jan 11, 2020.

  1. conner01

    conner01 Well-Known Member

    15,162 Messages
    12,692 Likes Received
    Going into the last week we was 7-1 in games we ran 29% or more play action
    I thought that was interring that half the games we didn’t
    Sometimes you get behind and I get that but I think play action should be huge in our offense
     
  2. FuzzyLumpkins

    FuzzyLumpkins The Boognish

    31,570 Messages
    21,899 Likes Received
    You can call it whatever you want but those teams would be stupid to follow your advice. They are indeed different than everyone else.

    You can argue it all you want but when the premise of your fallacy does not apply you should stop using it. Every team is not the same.

    And let's be clear here, the analysis was not remotely exhaustive. That was simply one permutation of real world examples and it showed you to be wrong. There is no reason to believe that organizing it by opposing defense or something else is not going to do the same.

    You were wrong to claim it was true in all cases. Admit it and move on.
     
    Luther and zrinkill like this.
  3. Hadenough

    Hadenough Well-Known Member

    5,208 Messages
    5,676 Likes Received
    Are you saying this was a bad hire?
     
  4. big dog cowboy

    big dog cowboy THE BIG DOG Moderator

    80,079 Messages
    54,785 Likes Received
    McCarthy > Garrett.

    /thread.
     
  5. garyo1954

    garyo1954 Well-Known Member

    1,917 Messages
    2,093 Likes Received
    I'm going to go out on a limb and say the whole mess is a stretch.

    How does this help me in a situation like 1st and 10, inside my 20, 1st quarter, score tied at 0?

    If I'm on defense, what can I expect from the offense?
    If I'm on offense, what am I going to do?

    It would be much more helpful if I knew New Orleans faced this situation 5 times and they passed each time, being successful 80%. They never ran in that situation.
    On the other hand, in the same situation, Seattle ran 5 times and was successful 60% of the time. They never passed.

    That type information helps me on defense.

    Offensively I'd need to know what the defense is doing in these situations to have any advantage.

    Big difference in quoting stats and understanding how you can use them in a game situation.

    But yall go ahead and argue. I'll go dribble over there......
     
    Luther, CowboyStar88 and conner01 like this.
  6. The Fonz

    The Fonz Correctamundo

    5,155 Messages
    6,518 Likes Received
    It was all BS moves from MIke and his friends in the media and JJ fall for it.The guy football IQ is questionable.
    I guess we will find out soon....hoping for the best expecting the worse.
     
  7. NeonNinja

    NeonNinja Dash28

    13,644 Messages
    9,451 Likes Received
    Noted, OP.
     
  8. Toruk_Makto

    Toruk_Makto Well-Known Member

    13,991 Messages
    17,131 Likes Received
    What part of this is not true don't you understand?
     
  9. CIWhitefish

    CIWhitefish Well-Known Member

    982 Messages
    285 Likes Received
    Thanks man!
     
    Runwildboys likes this.
  10. Hadenough

    Hadenough Well-Known Member

    5,208 Messages
    5,676 Likes Received
    I'm less worried about McCarthy and more worried about Dak. A coach can have a great play design but its up to the QB to execute the throws.
     
  11. Proof

    Proof Well-Known Member

    5,745 Messages
    7,261 Likes Received
    Couple things, just for clarity.
    Is this a new quote?

    and also since I assume the study is across the league, is there any isolated study on teams that do have a potent rushing attack and how PA benefited or didn’t based on their rushing?


    Like I just wonder if the ravens, 9ers, Seahawks, boys etc have a larger efficiency boost than say the bucs or falcons
     
    Runwildboys likes this.
  12. iamliko22

    iamliko22 Well-Known Member

    1,173 Messages
    1,483 Likes Received
    62
    22
    18
     
    garyo1954 and Runwildboys like this.
  13. lwehlers

    lwehlers Well-Known Member

    2,711 Messages
    1,686 Likes Received
    McCarty has not had a running back like Elliott before. so maybe he will change and run the ball more. if not we will see Elliott and pollard catch a lot of passes which sometimes is just a short handoff in a westcoast offense.
     
  14. Toruk_Makto

    Toruk_Makto Well-Known Member

    13,991 Messages
    17,131 Likes Received
    Then why does the same play action split occur with poor rushing teams?
     
  15. mahoneybill

    mahoneybill Well-Known Member

    5,622 Messages
    3,432 Likes Received
    Telling that no HC offers came his way. Proof of what league/ teams thought about him
     
    CowboyStar88 likes this.
  16. mattjames2010

    mattjames2010 Well-Known Member

    18,196 Messages
    16,457 Likes Received
    A lot of nerd crap in this thread that completely separates itself from the game of football.

    The same goes for McCarthy - maybe this analytic stuff matters in preparation for a game, but once you hit the field that stuff often goes right out the window due to situational football and all the analytical nerds can ever look at are the outcomes of games.

    Lame and labeling him a "fraud" while he holds something very few other coaches in NFL history has held is hilarious. He obviously got it right once before.
     
    garyo1954 likes this.
  17. Toruk_Makto

    Toruk_Makto Well-Known Member

    13,991 Messages
    17,131 Likes Received
    Thats not what the article said about Dak. It said when Zeke was out he performed poorly and they postulate that maybe Zeke had an impact on PA. Of course we know Zeke played poorly in that stretch due to Tyron being out and not Zeke.
     
  18. johneric8

    johneric8 Well-Known Member

    1,237 Messages
    1,987 Likes Received
    Jason is that you?
    :(
     
    CowboyStar88 and NeonNinja like this.
  19. Toruk_Makto

    Toruk_Makto Well-Known Member

    13,991 Messages
    17,131 Likes Received
    I didn't say that. And nowhere did I argue that we should have kept Garrett.

    But from what McCarthy said his analytics claims seem dubious at best.
     
    Hadenough likes this.
  20. Haimerej

    Haimerej Well-Known Member

    2,080 Messages
    2,710 Likes Received
    Do you know the success breakdown of PA bootleg vs standard PA dropbacks or shotgun PA?
     
    Runwildboys likes this.

Share This Page