My Issue Isn't with the Moves, It's the Timing

I bet jerry sweetened the pot after seeing that nightmare Monday night.
That's an interesting take......whether the Arizona results had an impact on what we were prepared to offer and whether any other teams were interested. If we were the only interested party whether Jerry tried the ...."we dont need to do the trade now, we'll come back next year".
Id guess there would be enough interest and the price would be high due to the limited DT's expected in the middle of the1st Rd of the 2026 Draft.
 
I do not necessarily take issue with the specific moves lately, but my major problem is that the timing of these moves indicates that there is basically no grander strategy being employed.

Why in the world are we lighting draft capital on fire when we have a historically bad defense that will need 5+ new starters to even be competitive next year?

Why was Micah Parsons not traded before the draft or even the previous season when we clearly had no intention of winning the next two years and had likely already decided we were probably not going to resign him?

Why did we not trade for a single impact player from 2021-2023 when this team had a real, concrete chance at winning the super bowl with just another great defensive player to put them over the top, but now we're throwing picks like they expire tomorrow to save a god forsakenly awful team this year?

The decision making is just completely manic, emotionally driven, and schizophrenic. Where is the vision for this team actually going? Absolutely nowhere in my opinion.
So you’re saying they should’ve done nothing because it should’ve been done last year? I agree they should’ve done something like this during the offseason but they didn’t. They’ve done it now and are still in the hunt for a playoff spot so you should be happy and not so negative.
 
I don't think anyone disagrees that there wasn't a plan to improve the team but I don't understand why people keep acting as though Jerry didn't intend to sign Parsons. He 100% was going to take the path of keeping Parsons & calling that enough. Therefore, the arguments about making these trades before the draft or last year are null & void.

Who knows where all this leads us. But they are finally putting some resources into the center of the defense so maybe they have finally clued in to the real way to build a team. We do need quite a bit but you might be surprised how quickly it can improve IF we use our resources wisely.
 
Can’t see how they keep Clark now with so much money at DT. Looking more and more like we traded Micah for Williams straight up. Especially if they trade down with the GB pick to get a 2nd and 3rd, which I think is highly likely.
demand OSA takes a paycut
 
Is Quinnen that good? I wanted to stand pat too. Is Quinnen a needle mover? Game changer? I’m not arguing I need someone to make me feel better about this because I didn’t want to make a move. I don’t watch the Jets much and when I did watch them this year it seemed like we handled Quinnen.
I will qualify by saying I haven't watched him that much recently BUT he has been that guy that the offense plays to avoid rather than to move. Solidify that middle & make teams plan to go elsewhere. It really gives your D an advantage.
 
So you’re saying they should’ve done nothing because it should’ve been done last year? I agree they should’ve done something like this during the offseason but they didn’t. They’ve done it now and are still in the hunt for a playoff spot so you should be happy and not so negative.
No, I am saying that I probably would have held onto my picks for the most part and rebuilt this team through the draft for a year or two until they reached contention again. I love Williams though and think he will be awesome here, but I still don’t think it was the best decision given the circumstances.

When you are in need of as many players as Dallas is to field a competitive team again, you need to hoard those high level draft picks to really jolt the team with young new blue chip talent.

This is the type of move you make when you’re in win-now mode and need a player to put you over the top. The type of move Jerry never makes unless his team already is in deep, deep trouble. This move should have been made in 2021, 2022, or 2023, not now.
 
demand OSA takes a paycut
I don't know if that would work but if we somehow keep Osa & Clark, I kinda like the idea of letting Osa play end getting them all on the field together.

If we can't keep them, we should be able to trade Osa & recover some value.
 
I do not necessarily take issue with the specific moves lately, but my major problem is that the timing of these moves indicates that there is basically no grander strategy being employed.

Why in the world are we lighting draft capital on fire when we have a historically bad defense that will need 5+ new starters to even be competitive next year?

Why was Micah Parsons not traded before the draft or even the previous season when we clearly had no intention of winning the next two years and had likely already decided we were probably not going to resign him?

Why did we not trade for a single impact player from 2021-2023 when this team had a real, concrete chance at winning the super bowl with just another great defensive player to put them over the top, but now we're throwing picks like they expire tomorrow to save a god forsakenly awful team this year?

The decision making is just completely manic, emotionally driven, and schizophrenic. Where is the vision for this team actually going? Absolutely nowhere in my opinion.
Jerry Jones lives his life a 1 quarter of a football game at a time.

Joking aside, he has never shown to have the patience or discipline for establishing a long term strategy and then discipline to follow through. He's a "gunslinger" and likes to gamble. Okay for a billionaire business owner, not so okay for a process and detail oriented sport.
 
I don't think anyone disagrees that there wasn't a plan to improve the team but I don't understand why people keep acting as though Jerry didn't intend to sign Parsons. He 100% was going to take the path of keeping Parsons & calling that enough. Therefore, the arguments about making these trades before the draft or last year are null & void.

Who knows where all this leads us. But they are finally putting some resources into the center of the defense so maybe they have finally clued in to the real way to build a team. We do need quite a bit but you might be surprised how quickly it can improve IF we use our resources wisely.
You do realize you are allowed to resign your best players and continue to add other great ones to the roster, right?

Parsons should have been resigned AND a player like Williams should have been added if they viewed the next 2 or 3 years as being a “win-now” window.
 
I don't know if that would work but if we somehow keep Osa & Clark, I kinda like the idea of letting Osa play end getting them all on the field together.

If we can't keep them, we should be able to trade Osa & recover some value.
someone has to want him too, I was being sarcastic, he's not going to take a pay cut we just have to live with the fact that we jumped in paying him this much. I love that idea of getting them all out there, let's see how it goes!!
 
No, I am saying that I probably would have held onto my picks for the most part and rebuilt this team through the draft for a year or two until they reached contention again.
That was a viable option as well. I think some clubs would have chosen to sell, accumulate capital & do exactly as you suggest. Jerry can't allow irrelevance so he wasn't going to chose that option.
 
No, I am saying that I probably would have held onto my picks for the most part and rebuilt this team through the draft for a year or two until they reached contention again. I love Williams though and think he will be awesome here, but I still don’t think it was the best decision given the circumstances.

When you are in need of as many players as Dallas is to field a competitive team again, you need to hoard those high level draft picks to really jolt the team with young new blue chip talent.

This is the type of move you make when you’re in win-now mode and need a player to put you over the top. The type of move Jerry never makes unless his team already is in deep, deep trouble. This move should have been made in 2021, 2022, or 2023, not now.
I predicted it. No matter what they do Zoners would crap all over it.
 
All today did was make their job easier next off season. Getting a top player like Williams can't be overlooked.

Parsons wasn't traded before the draft because they Cowboys had every intention of extending him.
I just think this team desperately needs a huge infusion of cheap, young talent, and those draft picks are going to be missed.

I wish this move would have been made after 2 years of using our war chest of picks to repair the depth of the roster and hopefully land some blue chip starters.

Honestly, I just don’t believe they had an honest, realistic plan to resign Micah. Of course the negotiation was going to be difficult given his agent and Micah’s huge ego. If they really, really wanted him here, a few million a year wouldn’t have been the issue it became.
 
You do realize you are allowed to resign your best players and continue to add other great ones to the roster, right?

Parsons should have been resigned AND a player like Williams should have been added if they viewed the next 2 or 3 years as being a “win-now” window.
Of course. But you have to realize that Jones & Parsons got sideways. So whatever could have happened went out the window. Also, without the picks from the Parsons deal, we didn't have the "extra" draft capital to swing a trade like this and still have meaningful picks to rebuild the rest of the roster.

When your roster is as lacking as ours, you are generally going to have to let go of some players as part of the retooling.

Commiting those kind of resources to an EDGE who has shown a lot of immaturity on & off the field was almost certainly going to be a mistake anyway.
 
Of course. But you have to realize that Jones & Parsons got sideways. So whatever could have happened went out the window. Also, without the picks from the Parsons deal, we didn't have the "extra" draft capital to swing a trade like this and still have meaningful picks to rebuild the rest of the roster.

When your roster is as lacking as ours, you are generally going to have to let go of some players as part of the retooling.

Commiting those kind of resources to an EDGE who has shown a lot of immaturity on & off the field was almost certainly going to be a mistake anyway.
No team in the entire league rebuilds like this. You trade away talent, stockpile picks, draft a ton of blue chippers over 2-3 years, and THEN you make a trade like this to put them over the top. You don’t start with the trade when your roster is this thread bare.

But yeah, I can live with the Micah situation, it just didn’t seem to be part of a coherent strategy.
 
someone has to want him too, I was being sarcastic, he's not going to take a pay cut we just have to live with the fact that we jumped in paying him this much. I love that idea of getting them all out there, let's see how it goes!!
there would be plenty of interest. teams are starved for talent at a lot of positions. now exactly what compensation we would get & how it all impacts the cap, I haven't delved into.
 
I agree, the timing is off by about 18 months. Where was Dallas in 2024 when several top DTs were available in free agency? The Cowboys sat out that off season instead of jumping on a top tier DT. Then in the 2025 draft, there were a bunch of high potential DTs in the draft and the Cowboys took an OG at #12.

Clearly, the Cowboy did not place a priority on DT. Someone changed their minds, but it is years late.

Imagine if Jerry signed a top tier DT in 2024 to play alongside Micah Parsons? That's where we should be now instead of loading up on DTs while out outside guys can set an edge and our LBs can't fill a gap.

And while we celebrate the Cowboys getting 5 sacks against the Cardinals, keep in mind they are the 5th most sacked offense in the league. The pass rush has been spotty at best.
 
Why in the world are we lighting draft capital on fire when we have a historically bad defense that will need 5+ new starters to even be competitive next year?
Because they need 5+ players, and the draft alone isn't going to cut it.

Why was Micah Parsons not traded before the draft or even the previous season when we clearly had no intention of winning the next two years and had likely already decided we were probably not going to resign him?
Because the events surrounding Parsons was unforeseen.

Why did we not trade for a single impact player from 2021-2023 when this team had a real, concrete chance at winning the super bowl with just another great defensive player to put them over the top, but now we're throwing picks like they expire tomorrow to save a god forsakenly awful team this year?
Because the Cowboys are happy enough with just a playoff team. Our front office believes like many fans do, that if you make the playoffs, anything can happen. You probably have seen people post that in here.

If Dallas is a playoff team, their standard operating procedure is to solely build through the draft.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
470,714
Messages
14,280,556
Members
23,850
Latest member
Heretic
Back
Top