NBCDFW Magary: The Trouble With Tony

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,278
Reaction score
45,634
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
If only Tony Romo were glaringly bad. If only he sucked EVERY game, instead of five or six key games each year. It would be so much easier to deal with him. It really would. You could simply demand he be replaced, and then he WOULD be replaced. That’s the nice thing about horrible quarterbacks.

But that’s too easy for Tony Romo. No, Tony has to play a handful of games every year where he looks like an absolute world-beater. Against the Bucs, or any garden-variety filler opponent, Romo displays all the arm strength, mobility, field vision, and ballsy swagger needed to be a championship QB.

And then, there are games like Sunday Night, where Romo looks like a dog trying to ride a surfboard. He’s jittery. He’s sloppy. He’s careless. His final interception of the night was a majestic example of pointless, arrogant, Leafesque brain flatulence. Good quarterbacks don’t huck the ball up in the air like that, throwing their team’s fate aloft, allowing it to come crashing down to Earth so easily. That isn’t something the Peyton Mannings, the Tom Bradys, or even the Matt Ryans of the world do.

The question is, will that component of Tony Romo’s game ever go away? He’s displayed all the characteristics of a good quarterback. He LOOKS the part. But he’s still yet to BECOME a consistently good QB. And it’s fair to start asking if he ever will. Al Michaels asked the question Sunday Night. Will he be Aikman? Or will he be Danny White, good but never good enough?

Hasn’t Romo been playing long enough now that we probably know for sure?
Everyone has an opinion on Romo these days. Tony Dorsett took time out from appearing in idiotic Miller Lite ads to publicly blast him:

“Well, for one thing, I don’t know why on God’s Earth Tony Romo has been anointed a superstar in the National Football League,” Dorsett said. “Tony is very young in his career. Not to say you can’t be young in your career and be a superstar because you’ve got one up there in Minnesota in Adrian Peterson.

“But the thing is this: you have a guy who hasn’t done much and quarterbacks in the National Football League, most of them go through this growing curve. He hasn’t gone through that growing curve, but he was anointed this great player all of a sudden. Now he’s having to live up to that. And obviously Tony has some deficiencies.
And Colin Cowherd, who is horrible, went so far as to compare Romo to JaMarcus Russell. Ouch. Our message board patrons were no kinder…

drgrant1912: Sorry folks, but Romo MUST go! He is still WAY to [sic] immature to lead the Dallas Cowboys to anything and I don't think he'll ever rise to the level of the Cowboy's greats. Trust me, if it was my BILLION dollar stadium and he played like he did, he would have been gone before the light were turned out. Enough is enough. Time to turn the page!…

Facebook User: when you put him up against a colt mccoy/bradford skills are there but heart is not. too much money for medicore performance…

anonymous: Tony Romo is not the quarterback to take this team to a ring. Unfortunately, he is becoming more and more of a Danny White, decent enough to give us a chance to win, but again, will never win the big one....

iKNOWitALL: I wish we could blame Simpson but shoot we will just have to chalk up the stupidity to Romo himself.

anonymous: Bill Parcells nailed it when he said Romo will always make that one big mistake every game that will hurt you and just how good does the rest of your team have to be to overcome it? Get used to this...get used to losing big games that count because that's all Romo has done...

harleyman: So how does Romo blame now...Owens is gone, Jessica is gone...His mom?
Jerry Jones rushed to Romo’s defense and says the QB has his full support. You do these kinds of things when you’ve invested millions of dollars in Romo and only have Jon Kitna waiting behind him.

Romo’s not going anywhere any time soon. But after yet another big game collapse so early in the season, it’s more than fair for Cowboys fans to start believing that their quarterback is, as he is now, as good as he’ll ever be and no better.

BY Drew Magary // 6 hours ago

http://www.nbcdfw.com/blogs/blue-star/The-Trouble-With-Tony-60675177.html
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
newnationcb;2965169 said:
5, 6 games a year? I dear any of these idots to list those:rolleyes:
Yup, read that far and stopped.

Obviously the person is clueless.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,102
Reaction score
11,420
This is about the third Magary post I've read, and they've all been worthless.
 

Rampage

Benched
Messages
24,117
Reaction score
2
newnationcb;2965169 said:
5, 6 games a year? I dear any of these idots to list those:rolleyes:
2nd Philly game, Baltimore, Pittsburgh, 1st skins game, Green Bay(we won though) Arizona

even in the 1st Philly game he cost us 10 points off of turnovers.
 

Everlastingxxx

All Star
Messages
7,209
Reaction score
188
theogt;2965172 said:
Yup, read that far and stopped.

Obviously the person is clueless.

Why? I can name about 4 or 5 from last year he didnt play well. The Last 4 games of last season he didnt play all that well.

Romo needs to eliminate the stupid mistakes. He has to, plain and simple, or he wont last.
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
Rampage;2965176 said:
2nd Philly game, Baltimore, Pittsburgh, 1st skins game, Green Bay(we won though) Arizona

even in the 1st Philly game he cost us 10 points off of turnovers.
In the first Commanders game, the Green Bay game and the Arizona game he had a combined 97 QB rating with just under 300 yards per game and 7 TDs against 2 INTs.

If you throw in that first Philly game, he had combined 102.4 QB rating, with 10 TDs against 3 INTs and over 300 yards per game.

You can't just take 3 games he performed poorly in and add three games in which he completely rocked and assume people will just pass over it and take you for your word.
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
Everlastingxxx;2965182 said:
Why? I can name about 4 or 5 from last year he didnt play well. The Last 4 games of last season he didnt play all that well.

Romo needs to eliminate the stupid mistakes. He has to, plain and simple, or he wont last.
Really? He didn't play well in that Giants game?

Try actually looking back at the games before you make stupid statements like this. That way you won't embarrass yourself....maybe.
 

DandyDon1722

It's been a good 'un, ain't it?
Messages
6,386
Reaction score
7,008
I just will never understand how everybody thinks there are 10-12 teams in this league that are pushovers ever single time.

Tony only wins THOSE games. This just in...THOSE guys get paid too.
Geez
 

21Savage

newnationcb
Messages
2,895
Reaction score
961
Rampage;2965176 said:
2nd Philly game, Baltimore, Pittsburgh, 1st skins game, Green Bay(we won though) Arizona

even in the 1st Philly game he cost us 10 points off of turnovers.


The 1st distinction there is that we are talking about sucking and terrible QB play.

The second distinction there is that we're talking about a yearly occurrence.

In 2007, you can say Buffalo and then the Philly game. That's it! He was good to great in the other games, and yes, that includes the playoff game.

In 2008, he was bad in the Pitt and Baltimore games.

How the hell can you blame him for the 1st skins game when he was actually very sharp in that game. He threw one ball a bit behind TO and the other turnover was all on TO because he coughed up the ball after getting hit. Romo brought us back in that game with a perfect pass to Marty B on the TD and a push throw on 3rd down to Miles to seal the game.

For you to even include the GreenBay game shows the extent of your blind hate or your ignorance. He threw a pick in the end zone, yeah, and almost turned the ball over on a fumble before the half that Flo recovered. But he played really well otherwise and sealed the game with throws to Miles.
 

TwoCentPlain

Numbnuts
Messages
15,171
Reaction score
11,084
Rampage;2965176 said:
2nd Philly game, Baltimore, Pittsburgh, 1st skins game, Green Bay(we won though) Arizona

even in the 1st Philly game he cost us 10 points off of turnovers.

Pawned by Rampage. Rampage listed 5 games where Romo absolutely sucked last year.
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
ninja;2965206 said:
Pawned by Rampage. Rampage listed 5 games where Romo absolutely sucked last year.
Next time, try reading the rest of the thread first.

LOL.
 

Rampage

Benched
Messages
24,117
Reaction score
2
theogt;2965190 said:
In the first Commanders game, the Green Bay game and the Arizona game he had a combined 97 QB rating with just under 300 yards per game and 7 TDs against 2 INTs.

If you throw in that first Philly game, he had combined 102.4 QB rating, with 10 TDs against 3 INTs and over 300 yards per game.

You can't just take 3 games he performed poorly in and add three games in which he completely rocked and assume people will just pass over it and take you for your word.
umm the 1st skins game his stats were great at the end of the game. his int was what screwed us as we could never catch up after that. not to mention him forcing 20 passes to Owens. Green bay again 2 ints luckily our defense actually showed up that game. Also If Mcnabb doesn't botch that gift of a fumble to us we lose. Tony's turnovers are killing us. he gives us a great chance to win but he also gives us a great chance to lose cause he's a turnover machine.
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
Rampage;2965214 said:
umm the 1st skins game his stats were great at the end of the game. his int was what screwed us as we could never catch up after that. not to mention him forcing 20 passes to Owens. Green bay again 2 ints luckily our defense actually showed up that game. Also If Mcnabb doesn't botch that gift of a fumble to us we lose. Tony's turnovers are killing us. he gives us a great chance to win but he also gives us a great chance to lose cause he's a turnover machine.
LOL @ you trying to argue that a 102 QB rating over 5 games and 145 passes is anything but spectacular.

Seriously, give it up. The INTs killed us? Then what did the 3-1 TD/INT ratio do for us? Most people would kill for that kind of ratio.
 

Rampage

Benched
Messages
24,117
Reaction score
2
theogt;2965217 said:
LOL @ you trying to argue that a 102 QB rating over 5 games and 145 passes is anything but spectacular.

Seriously, give it up. The INTs killed us? Then what did the 3-1 TD/INT ratio do for us? Most people would kill for that kind of ratio.
like I said his int during the skins game cost us big time cause we could never catch up. he had good stats that game yet he played average at best. but your gonna use a qb rating to say he played good. if only a qb rating determined how detrimental turnovers are in a game.
 

SLATEmosphere

Benched
Messages
9,633
Reaction score
2
theogt;2965217 said:
LOL @ you trying to argue that a 102 QB rating over 5 games and 145 passes is anything but spectacular.

Seriously, give it up. The INTs killed us? Then what did the 3-1 TD/INT ratio do for us? Most people would kill for that kind of ratio.

It's a complete wash. He turns the ball over and hurts the team and also helps the team by making great throws.

It's like kicking and beating someone up and then helping them by bringing them to the hospital.
 
Top