You obviously have done your hw where I'm using simple eye test so will defer to you tbh. Esp knwn the play Lewis snagged his pick coverage, etc. Can I fall back on the "it" factor?
Good post proving your point.
Good conversation.
I had seen many posts that Lewis should be a starter and before studying them specifically in 2017/2018 game footage I personally had the feeling that Lewis was better than Brown; however, as I've detailed previously I just didn't see that in the extensive study of their game footage.
Lewis definitely has the Alpha mentality which is needed at CB. The All-or-Nothing episode when Dez tried to show him up and Lewis wouldn't back down was fantastic. When the team was in a big group at the end of practice to listen to Garrett, Dez was still pacing around mumbling to himself because of his frustration with Lewis. Having more self control, Lewis just took a knee in the team group like everybody else (except Dez).
Lewis was a rookie standing up to a star player on a 70M contract.
It does suck for Lewis personally that the Cowboys are deep at CB. Most other years he would easily be top 3 on the depth chart. I think back to the days of Nate Jones as a starting CB. Lewis would be the #1 CB in those years.
Lewis still has a chance to be top 3 on the depth chart in 2019. Kris Richard teaches a different type of press technique than most other teams/coaches and the overall techniques are different as well.
The KR CB techniques are basically the polar opposite of how Lewis played in college or in 2017. Lewis was slower to adopt these technique changes than the others. Byron Jones adapted more quickly than the others because it's similar to the style he played when covering TEs in 2017/2016.
More specifically, Lewis likes to play "under" and KR requires playing "over" or trail technique on the WR. You probably know over/trail but I'll give a quick explanation for anybody that's interested.
Trail is when the CB stays between the WR and QB.
Over is when the CB stays between the WR and the endzone (yes, this is an overly simplistic description).
Lewis often played an exaggerated trail in college which baited QBs to throw to that WR then Lewis would under-cut the throw giving him opportunities for INTs. In the NFL it requires a Safety over the top to that side of the field if the CB is playing a lot of trail (i.e. 2-deep Safety alignment or single-high FS does not give help to opposite side CB).
KR wants CBs to stay over WRs meaning they can play man without Safety help but may give up some underneath throws that wouldn't happen if playing trail. The CBs do play other coverages (zone, off man). Off-man is over type coverage by definition and zone always has somebody over.
The key to the KR base coverage for CBs is the kick-step press technique. It's somewhat opposite of what most CBs have played previous. KR and Richard Sherman refer the common press technique as Soft-Shoe press.
Lewis appeared to be slow to adopt the KR techniques in the preseason.
By the time that Lewis played extensively in 2018 (Awuzie missed game 6), he appeared to be playing much more of the KR style than he had in the preseason.
My opinion on the reasons Lewis was the 4th CB:
1. Slower to adopt the KR techniques.
2. Takes more risks than preferred by KR/RM.
3. Speed. (4.54 vs 4.33 for Brown)
.
.
4. Size (Brown has a small advantage here).