Post Week 14 (2025): QB Combined Statistical Ranking

[SpaceCowboy99]

So he's ranked 6th in this cherry picking stat... Should he be paid as the 6th highest QB then?

 

[gtb1943]

I hate to bring it up but Tony Romo had a six turnover game at Buffalo in 2007. Five picks and a lost fumble. But Dallas won 25-24 on a walk off Nick Folk field goal.

because Romo had 2 passing TDs

 

[Ranching]

I was told there would be no math.

They said, meth

 

[Chasing6]

They said, meth

I wonder wins are not factored in to the equation.

 

[America's Cowboy]

Thru 14 weeks of the 18 weeks...
We are through all the bye weeks, so leveler playing field, stats-wise

Weekly Disclaimer on this statistical ranking (unlike other rankings, no personal opinions)
This does NOT say which QB is "the best"....ONLY how they have played so far this year.

"Combined Stats" just means using two key stats that --when combined--almost always point to the QBs having the best season (the eventual All-Pros, MVPs, etc)

Those stats are:
1) Standard QB Passer Rating Rank
AND
2) TD-Turnover Differential Rank: Total TDs (Rushing and Passing) - Total Turnovers (Fumbles lost and Interceptions)


Here are the QB Rankings using Combined Stats thru Week 14:

1. Stafford
2. Maye
3. Goff
4. Allen
5. Love
6. Prescott
7. Hurts
8. D Jones
9. Rodgers
10. Mahomes
11. Jackson
12. Darnold
13. Mayfield
14. Dart
15. Herbert
16. Williams
17. Brissett
18. Pennix
19. M Jones
20. Nix
21. Stroud
22. Young
23. Lawrence
24. J Daniels
25. Murray
26. Gabriel
27. Rattler
28. Tagovailoa
29. Mariota
30. Flacco
31. G Smith
32. McCarthy
33. Cousins
34. Shough
35. Ward
36. Wilson
37. Browning

Excluded due to less than 6 games: Murray, Wentz, Burrow, Purdy, Huntley, Taylor, Pickett, Ewers, Rush, Milton, Dalton, Mills, Sanders, Winston, Brosmer.Leonard, Cooks

Not a fair listing. Dak was attributed 2 INTs from the Lions game, but we all saw how those 2 INTs were all on the WRs and not Dak. Same for almost half of Dak's INTs so far this season. Half have beeb on the WRs.

 

[Shotgun Dave]

Settle down.....Pappy would be proud of you. A good, fair zoner, trying to start a serious thread and you come in and derail it with your, mountaineer wannabe, jibberish

Imagine that…

 

[DFWJC]

So he's ranked 6th in this cherry picking stat... Should he be paid as the 6th highest QB then?

These Combined QB stats threads have been going on for many years

Not at all about Dak, more about predicting the MVP

But some folks always want to make it about him

BTW, if a stat correlates 96% to what its trying to correlate to, it’s FAR from a “cherry picked” stat.

The very definition of the exact opposite

 

[Ranching]

I wonder wins are not factored in to the equation.

Stay off the meth....lol

 

[Ranching]

These Combined QB stats threads have been going on for many years

Not at all about Dak, more about predicting the MVP

But some folks always want to make it about him

BTW, if a stat correlates 96% to what its trying to correlate to, it’s FAR from a “cherry picked” stat.

The very definition of the exact opposite

Some of these guys have a fixation on Dak's money....they used to piss me off, now I laugh at their obsession....they don't know chit about the game, so they just post anything negative! Lol..
Reminds me of some of the booster club members, back in the day....
Hope all is well, brother. Miss those old Beer thread days. Still talk to Waldo, he's in Hong Kong right now. Came down from Malibu for a visit a while back. Salud!

 

[DFWJC]

Some of these guys have a fixation on Dak's money....they used to piss me off, now I laugh at their obsession....they don't know chit about the game, so they just post anything negative! Lol..
Reminds me of some of the booster club members, back in the day....
Hope all is well, brother. Miss those old Beer thread days. Still talk to Waldo, he's in Hong Kong right now. Came down from Malibu for a visit a while back. Salud!

The beer threads were so fun.

Salud, brother

 

[StarLord]

Not a fair listing. Dak was attributed 2 INTs from the Lions game, but we all saw how those 2 INTs were all on the WRs and not Dak. Same for almost half of Dak's INTs so far this season. Half have beeb on the WRs.

So should the 2 near INTs that went off/through the defender's 2 hands count against him?

If WR errors shouldn't count against him then defenders' errors that otherwise would totally be Dak's fault should count against him.

 

[Chasing6]

Stay off the meth....lol

Because wins are a team result.

 

[America's Cowboy]

So should the 2 near INTs that went off/through the defender's 2 hands count against him?

If WR errors shouldn't count against him then defenders' errors that otherwise would totally be Dak's fault should count against him.

Those INTs didn't happen. I know it bothers you, but why do you follow this team since it does? Or are you an opposing team's fan posing as a Cowboys fan?

 

[acr731]

Not a fair listing. Dak was attributed 2 INTs from the Lions game, but we all saw how those 2 INTs were all on the WRs and not Dak. Same for almost half of Dak's INTs so far this season. Half have beeb on the WRs.

Those INTs didn't happen. I know it bothers you, but why do you follow this team since it does? Or are you an opposing team's fan posing as a Cowboys fan?

Let me ask you this - do you think it's fair when a QB throws a 3 yard pass that's turned into a 75 yard gain with the YAC and the QB ends up getting credit for the whole 75?

Dumb question, of course you think that's fair, especially if the QB is Dak. You might not feel the same if were Hurts, Mahomes, or any other opposing QB, though.

Fair or not, INT's are a QB stat, just like the passing yards example I just gave you. It doesn't matter who is really to blame for the INT, the QB is the one who gets the mark, not the receiver who might have tipped a ball to a defender that lead to the INT.

In 2019 Jameis Winston lead the league with 30 INT's. How many of them weren't his fault? None of them because he isn't Dak, right? By the way, Winston was also the #1 overall QB that year, even with all the INT's. Didn't matter in the end, though, they finished 7-9 and missed the playoffs. Goes to show you how meaningless all these rankings are.

 

[DFWJC]

So should the 2 near INTs that went off/through the defender's 2 hands count against him?

If WR errors shouldn't count against him then defenders' errors that otherwise would totally be Dak's fault should count against him.

fwiw....;over the course of a 17 game season, the dropped interceptions by the defense and the ones that should've been caught by the WRs tend to balance out.

But in a single game, it can skew the results....no doubt

 

[America's Cowboy]

Let me ask you this - do you think it's fair when a QB throws a 3 yard pass that's turned into a 75 yard gain with the YAC and the QB ends up getting credit for the whole 75?

Dumb question, of course you think that's fair, especially if the QB is Dak. You might not feel the same if were Hurts, Mahomes, or any other opposing QB, though.

Fair or not, INT's are a QB stat, just like the passing yards example I just gave you. It doesn't matter who is really to blame for the INT, the QB is the one who gets the mark, not the receiver who might have tipped a ball to a defender that lead to the INT.

In 2019 Jameis Winston lead the league with 30 INT's. How many of them weren't his fault? None of them because he isn't Dak, right? By the way, Winston was also the #1 overall QB that year, even with all the INT's. Didn't matter in the end, though, they finished 7-9 and missed the playoffs. Goes to show you how meaningless all these rankings are.

Shows how ignorant and desperate you are. So glad watching Dak play so well eats you up.

 

[Captain-Crash]

Some of these guys have a fixation on Dak's money....they used to piss me off, now I laugh at their obsession....they don't know chit about the game, so they just post anything negative! Lol..
Reminds me of some of the booster club members, back in the day....
Hope all is well, brother. Miss those old Beer thread days. Still talk to Waldo, he's in Hong Kong right now. Came down from Malibu for a visit a while back. Salud!

sounds like you got a small turtleneck on, try a medium if it doesn't keep sliding down.

 

[RonnieT24]

Hurts with -5 (TDs-Turnovers) in one single game
Might be worst I’ve seen in 20 years

Remember that game at Buffalo when Romo had 6? And we still somehow managed to win that one. That game made me sick to my stomach.

 

[DFWJC]

Remember that game at Buffalo when Romo had 6? And we still somehow managed to win that one. That game made me sick to my stomach.

A truly great comeback. Surprised that would make you sick.
Maybe the ups and downs...kind of like sea sickness? lol

Romo was a -4 that day. (2 TDs, 6 turnvovers)
So not quite the -5 Mr Hurts gave us (0 TDs, 5 turnvoers) the other night, but really ugly for much of the game

He dug Dallas a big hole...down 24-13 in the 4th and Dallas scored 12 straight in the 4th to win it

Dallas QBs have had minus 4s several times over the years (that was his only one) and even a -5 by some dude named Pulluer. But Dallas winning the game was weird. Having a "game-winning drive" even made it weirder.

 

[RonnieT24]

A truly great comeback. Surprised that would make you sick.
Maybe the ups and downs...kind of like sea sickness? lol

Romo was a -4 that day.
So not quit the -5 Mr Hurts gave us the other night, but really ugly thru 3 quarters.

He dug Dallas a big hole...down 24-13 in the 4th and then flipped the switch.
Dallas scored 12 straight in the 4th to win it

Dallas QBs have had minus 4s several times over the years (that was his only one) and even a -5 by some dude named Pulluer. But Dallas winning the game was weird. Having a "game-winning drive" even made it weirder.

Watching my QB throw two pick sixes amid 5 total INTs and having a fumble in there too. 6 total turnovers by one guy and two TD passes to the other team .. yeah that's gonna make me sick every time. Win or lose.