Sounds more like wishful thinking & misogyny on your behalf.
No, it sounds like he want to try and use critical thinking in examining known facts.
All we have at this point is hearsay of the baby mama. For me, that is not enough.
She went to
his hotel uninvited.
She was not hit by any account.
The alleged car punch was in the parking lot and should be caught on security cameras if it indeed did happen.
That last one is key to me. If the cops had anything more than the he said she said then he would be charged already. The medical examiner has done their thing and unless the cops are incompetent then they have gotten the security tape.
I am not going to actually pin it on her because I don't know but it is entirely possible that she is unhappy with the child support court order or nature of their existing relationship and she was the instigator. I guess some men here have never argued with a vindictive, angry woman. Again, I do not know that to be the case but it is just as right to pin it on her as it is to pin the girl beater title on Randle.